Dinner and Admissions

The girls had prepped another fantastic dinner, and while it wasn’t quite the visual presentation as it had been the week before since everyone still had all their clothes on, it was wonderfully relaxed and casual. Seeing Rhia, Elyse and Tori all feeling at home in my home, freely moving around the kitchen, was a sort of trip all by itself. And the conversation ranged far and wide - some of it was banter about shit that I had to categorise in a ‘not my generation’ mental box because I had no idea about the show or music artist they were talking about. And a bit of it was gossip about other college students in their classes. But plenty of it was right in my wheelhouse; movies, old and new. Local news. Some of the Profs in their program, a couple of whom had been my profs as well and the others who I was familiar with through the local theatre community.

And then dinner was over, and the girls refused to let me help clean up as they took turns sitting at the table and keeping the conversation going while the other two would clean.

And then the clothes dropped all at once, and all three of them were naked and ready for the hot tub.

“You know, you could bring swimsuits over,” I teased them once we were all out there and ensconced in the glorious warmth.

“But then we wouldn’t get to ogle you,” Tori grinned.

“Or let you ogle us,” Rhia chuckled, bouncing in her seat a little so that her breasts bobbed right at the edge of the water.

“Or each other,” Elyse tacked on at the end with a snort, reaching out one foot and prodding Rhia’s boob with her big toe, making all three of you laugh.

“Hey, don’t think I’m complaining here,” I said. “I just want to make sure you all know it’s not expected.”

“Shane,” Tori sighed, shaking her head and sliding down her side of the hot tub closer to me. “The moment one of us feels like getting naked with you is expected is the moment we all get uncomfortable, and this ends. So just enjoy the eye candy, and the blowjobs, and the fucking.” She got half out of the water to lean over and purse her lips, kissing me lightly before sitting back in the water and returning to her seat.

“Um… on that note…” Rhia said, her confidant tone diminishing significantly. That had both Elyse and Tori looking at her in concern, and I could understand why. It sounded like she was about to admit she was uncomfortable or feeling like there were expectations. Way to pick your timing, Rhiannon, you thought with an internal sigh. “So, I need to, uh, tell you guys something.”

“You OK?” Elyse asked with a frown, scooting towards her through the water.

“No- I mean, yes, I’m fine,” Rhia said, holding up a hand to assure the other two girls. “I’m totally fine. Maybe too fine, even?”

“Rhia, what does that mean?” Tori asked.

“I just mean all of this - the eye candy, the blowjobs, the fucking - it’s kind of like… what I… wanted?” Rhia said slowly, her voice rising almost two octaves as she spoke.

“Wait, like… you wanted it before it happened?” Tori asked after a moment.

“Like you planned it?” Elyse asked. Then she looked at me. Concerned.

“Shane didn’t know,” Rhia said quickly. “I- OK, just listen to me for a sec, OK? This is weird and complicated. Shane already said he has another game that is like this one, right? Well, that one is with my parents and their friends. I kind of discovered it was a thing a few years ago, and it’s been like a thing for me? And so when we had a group of us who wanted to play, and it was mostly people I thought would be… compatible… I thought maybe it could happen. But I didn’t tell anyone, which I know is kinda fucked and not being a good Party member. Or a good friend. Then the guys dropped out, but we still had Shane, and like - it could still happen, but I didn’t tell him I was kinda angling for the sex and stuff until after the first session, and he was immediately like ‘What the Fuck, Rhia?’ and warned me and got a little mad that I was keeping secrets. So he made me own up to my parents first that I knew about their game, and that was a whole thing. And at the same time, it was like, I didn’t want my horny fantasy to fuck with how fun the game already was. But I also kinda still wanted stuff to happen. So I tested the waters and you girls were totally down to flash Shane, and then everything happened out here with the hot tub, and Shane had the whole consent talk and we’ve all fucked and now I’m telling you guys too late but I also had to tell you because I’ve felt awful for not telling you but I didn’t want to ruin it and-” she cut off, gasping for breath. It sounded like she was about to start rambling all over again but Tori shut her up by splashing her, leaving Rhia spluttering.

Elyse looked at me. “You really didn’t know she was planning for us to be all Fucky-Fucky?” she asked.

“Not until after the first session, and then I was trying to keep my eye out to make sure neither of you were being pressured,” I said. “She was supposed to tell you sooner than this.”

“Fuck, Rhia,” Tori sighed, glaring across the hot tub at her friend. Then she snorted and rolled her eyes. “You horny bitch.”

“Hey, you were the first one to do stuff with him,” Rhia said. “And it’s not like I suggested it.”

“That’s true,” Tori chuckled, shaking her head at her own actions.

“Technically, I’m the one who did something with him first,” Elyse said, then made the universal Blowjob hand motion. “And to be fair, even if all this hadn’t happened I was still planning on hooking up with you, Shane. I told you that already.”

“You did,” I chuckled softly.

“I dunno,” Elyse continued, leaning back and shaking her head as she spread her arms out along the back of the hot tub seats, her nipples peeking up out of the water. “I for one am happy with how things are going right now, and I don’t know if I would have agreed to all this if I’d known you were planning it ahead of time, Rhi. It kind of sounds like a ridiculous mess when you spell it out. But I also kind of love it so it’s hard to even be mad.”

“That’s true, I definitely wouldn’t have gone along with this if you’d just said, ‘Hey, I know this DM who runs Sex D&D,’” Tori snorted. “But I also see you didn’t actually push us into anything. We definitely made our own choices. And you didn’t push us at all for anything, Shane.”

“Thanks for confirming that,” I sighed and nodded thankfully. “I was worried that Little Miss Horndog was getting in my head.”

“Excuse me, my title is ‘Princess Horndog,’ thank you very much,” Rhia said with a grin. Then she looked at her friends. “Seriously, guys, I’m so sorry, but also not sorry.”

“Forgiven,” Tori decreed.

“Nothing to forgive,” Elyse added her own decision.

“OK, but seriously for a second, you wanted to do Sex D&D with Nate?” Tori asked Rhia.

“Well… no,” Rhia said. “But I figured you and him were already, like, sexual Elyse, and he was a package deal with Isaac.”

“You like Isaac?” Tori asked.

“You think I fucked Nate?” Elyse asked over top of her roommate.

“No, I don’t like Isaac, I just thought he would be able to handle it and wasn’t weird, and he has that cute butt chin,” Rhia said. “And you didn’t fuck Nate at the start of last year?”

“No,” Elyse said. “God, really? Nate?”

“I don’t know, you guys were hanging out all the time and stuff,” Rhia said.

“Nate’s-” Elyse started, then cut off abruptly.

“Nate’s what?” Tori asked.

“Oh,” Rhia said.

“Don’t say anything to anyone!” Elyse said quickly.

“I won’t,” Rhia promised.

“Nate’s what?” Tori asked, not having clued in as fast as I had.

“I’m guessing, Tori, that Nate might play for the other team,” I said. “And that’s something that shouldn't be gossiped about.”

“Oh,” Tori said, then shook her head and nodded. “Oh, right. Yeah. OK. I promise I won’t say anything.”

“God, I didn’t know that was a rumour,” Elyse murmured, rubbing at her face. “Me and Nate?”

“Well, I guess it helped keep his secret in the closet, cause I had no idea,” Rhia shrugged. “Fuck - that would have made Sex D&D real interesting.”

Elyse snorted and looked at me. “Do, uh, any guys get involved with each other in your other game?”

“No,” I said. “And it’s not something I’m particularly interested in. The closest we get is group sex with two or three guys focused on one woman.”

Tori grunted, clearly envisioning it for a moment.

“Fuck,” Rhia sighed. “That really would have made things awkward unless Isaac or Ian were down to fool around with him.”

“Honestly, I wouldn’t have done any of this if any of them were here,” Tori said. “I mean, I like Ian and Isaac and Nate, but not like that. I’m not attracted to them, at least more than a casual glance. I wouldn’t have felt safe being **** with them like this. Like, Shane, you look but you don’t stare at us when we’re naked. You give off this, ‘Damn, I acknowledge you’re hot and I appreciate that you’re naked, but I’m in full control of myself and not going to do anything stupid’ vibe that I can’t imagine any of those guys having.”

“To be fair, I think Nate would be able to control himself,” Elyse smirked, making Rhia snort.

“Fair,” Tori chuckled. “Anyways, we’re making proclamations and confessions, so here’s mine - I’m really fucking happy to be friends and fuck around with both of you girls, and I’m really happy for you to be our Sex D&D Dungeon Master and explore myself sexually with you, Shane. You girls are totally my best friends by a mile, and you’re the coolest person I know, Shane.”

“I- Thank you,” I said, finding myself surprisingly emotional over the slightly ridiculous stuff she’d said. All the words made sense in the order she said them, but the situation was… stupendous.

“We’re not just best friends, we’re breast friends,” Elyse grinned, standing up out of the water and stepping into the middle of the hot tub, naked and exposed down to her hips. “Come on, group hug.”

Both girls got up out of the water and slipped their arms around each other, and then all three of them looked at me. I rolled my eyes with a smile and stood, my erection coming up out of the water as I wrapped my arms around the three of them and we shared a wet, naked hug.

“So…” Elyse said as we held each other. “No sex during the session today. Who’s down to get ourselves off in front of each other?” The other girls started laughing, and I looked up at the twinkle lights woven into the roof of the hot tub enclosure, trying not to blush. “What? I wasn’t kidding. I’m horny as fuck and watching you guys play with yourselves was so hot last time,” Elyse said.

“... Fine,” Tori eventually said, pulling away from the hug and sitting on the tub's edge. “I’m in if you guys are.”

“I’m in,” Rhia said, backing away and sitting her butt on the edge as well, spreading her legs and running two fingers along her pretty lips.

“It was my idea,” Elyse grinned, taking her own seat.

They all looked at me.

“Fine,” I finally chuckled. “Sure. It’s a tough ask, but I think I can manage it.”

Rhia snorted, grinning as she eyefucked me from head to cock. “‘Fine’ he says. Like he doesn’t get to watch three hot coeds diddle themselves and will love every second of it.”

“Hey,” Tori said. “Your mom is pretty fucking hot, Rhia. And he gets to do Sex D&D with her. Maybe jerking off to college girls just isn’t as exciting when he can fuck your Mom.”

“Oh, God,” Rhia groaned. “Puh-lease don’t start making Your Mom jokes to me about this?”

“You think your Mom gives good head?” Elyse asked as I sat down and shook my head, not planning to save Ria from the consequences of her actions at all. “Maybe she could give me some tips.”

Rhia groaned again.

Breakthebar erotica is powered by Patreon,. PM if interested in making a Commission.