Cordelia Part 2

“And so this led to the two of you dating?”

“Obviously. A fucking like that, yeah I was willing to put up with the social hit. I even bragged to the other girls about how good his dick was.”

“It was just sex then,” Anya suggested.

“That’s what I wanted the others to think. And, at the time, it was mostly about the sex. He was romantic, don’t get me wrong. Once he spent an entire class period stroking every inch of my body and another time he went down on me for a full hour. I mean, the latter time we got attacked by a werewolf, but it was still pretty amazing. It was more than that though, he knew just the right date spots to take me to and gifts to get me.”

“It was a long time into our relationship before that happened,” Anya said. “So you were the one in control.”

“Naturally. There were exceptions of course. When those assassins were hunting Buffy and I didn’t want to give him a ride he bent me over his knee and spanked my naked ass. When I tried to break up with him on Valentine’s Day he pulled me into a bathroom and fucked me in the ass until I was begging him to never leave me. I was a good girlfriend as well. He stayed on the swim team to finish up the year and I really enjoyed giving him blowjobs on the bus.”

I licked my lips as I wondered whether I should bring up how good Xander’s cum tasted. I decided to keep that to myself. Anya could learn on her own.

“But other than that, no other girls?”

“Not until Homecoming,” I answered. “Buffy and I were competing for votes and both of our campaigns wanted Xander. Between my stories and his natural romantic nature lots of girls were willing to listen to him. I knew he was wavering on helping out Buffy, so I decided to throw in a little surprise. I snuck him away from lunch and informed him my ass was nice and lubed for him. We’d had anal sex before, but given the size of his cock it’s not something I did normally.

“He got hard instantly, which he usually did around me anyway, I am hot after all, but this time was even quicker. I blew a load out of him first, I needed something to eat and I knew he’d be good for at least one more round. He bent me over and right as he was pushing against my butt though we heard a noise. We went to investigate and he came back with Sheila.”

“Sheila?” Anya interrupted me. “Who is Sheila?”

“Sheila? You don’t know Sheila? She’s one of the group. Been friends with Buffy ever since that parent teacher night went sideways when Spike showed up. Seriously, you don’t know her?”

“The name never came up.”

“Well, that kind of ruins the story. Sheila is something of a badass rebel, so watching her beg to be included was a huge turn-on. Especially when she admitted that she found me the hottest girl in school. So Xander fucked my ass, far harder than he ever had before because of the audience, and then Sheila cleaned me up with her tongue. She did such a good job that I didn’t even protest when she requested that Xander fuck her in the ass as well. The slut took it like she was a natural.”

“So that was your first experience with girls?”

“Hey! I’m not a lesbo. I’ll let a girl go down on me, but I don’t go down on her. Well, normally.”

“Explain,” Anya requested.

“After Xander and I broke up…”

“Because of Willow,” Anya cut in.

I couldn’t help it, I burst out laughing. “Willow! That’s hilarious. Is she not a lesbian in your alternate universe?”

“Again, my universe is the base. Yes, she is, but it took her longer to realize that. Please continue.”

“Anyway, I broke up because of Xander and Buffy. I caught her blowing him to try and win his favor for the Homecoming vote. That would have been one thing, but apparently they’d been having sex behind my and Angel’s back for years. I couldn’t stand the idea that he was willing to work with her for Homecoming after everything, so I broke it off.”

“Homecoming? Not the cheating?”

“I mean, that wasn’t great. But I understood it. Xander’s a panty dropper with a massive sexual appetite. I can live with someone else eating his cum, but the Homecoming betrayal? That was too much.”

“And yet today you are marrying him.”

“Yeah, well, that connects to the lesbian story. You know how Buffy got mind reading at one point? Well, we were researching her sickness and she realized I was still thinking about Xander. She was all like ‘don’t hide that you want him to stuff your cunt with his massive dick and cum on your face, I can read your mind’. She admitted that she was constantly thinking the same thing and Xander pretty much always pictured us in a threesome, perv, so we should just go for it. She said that she knew I was worried that Xander was going to choose her and I called bullshit immediately. Girl has mind reading and suddenly thinks she’s hotter than me? No, we had a deep throat competition right then and there. God, that turned me on such much, it was like his dick had gained a couple of inches since I last sucked him off.

“One thing led to another. We were swapping cum back and forth and that turned into deep kissing, which led to us rolling around on the floor, which led to a 69. It didn’t stop Xander from fucking us, but we ate each other’s pussies like we were true dykes.”

“And then the two of you got back together?”

“Not right away. It was after the orgy at the prom. Wow, that was amazing, you really missed out.”

“What happened at the prom orgy?”

There was a knock at the door and Buffy poked her head in, “Are we having a wedding or not?”

“Tell everyone I’m touching up my makeup,” I said as I glanced in a mirror. “Fuck, I’m perfect, but it’s nice to make them wait. Are we done here?”

“I think we have stuff to come back to,” Anya said as she turned around. “But I need to talk to Buffy anyway."