Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 43 by thosearemysecret thosearemysecret

Did Ashley beg enough or does Cindy need more?

Cindy needs more

Of course, with her mouth still open and tongue hanging out, Ashley nods her head in the affirmative. Cindy gives a devilish smile that gives even you chills through the computer screen. You start wondering what you've created.

"Not yet, pet," she keeps her thighs spread and steps a little bit closer to Ashley so her pussy is inches from her mouth, "tell me how much you've wanted this."

Ashley's eyes widen and she pulls her tongue back into her mouth, "n-never, I've never thought about you like that."

"Tsk, tsk. I don't believe you. If I've learned anything over the last week it's how much of a needy pervert you are. Like that time you said we should make out on the beach to tease the boys and I said no? Wasn't that just because you wanted me?"

"I-I was drunk, Cindy."

Cindy thrusts her crotch forward a little. Ashley doesn't move even though her friend's spread pussy is practically touching her nose. You think Ashley releases a little gasping moan.

"Tell me you've always wanted me," Cindy sternly commands.

Ashley is silent for what seems like a long minute. Finally, she whispers, "I've always wanted you."

Cindy reaches down and pushes her fingers into your daughter's hair, "be more specific, pet."

"I've always wanted to taste you, to taste your mouth, your lips, your..." she definitely moans "...pussy. Please let me bury my face in your pussy."

Her fingers grip into a fist in your daughter's hair, "and if I give what you've always wanted will you do anything for me?"

Ashley licks her lips and her eyes are fixed between Cindy's legs, "anything, please let me have it. I'll be yours, Cindy. I'll worship every inch of you." Her voice turns to a pleading whine, "please let me finally taste what I've always wanted."

With that Cindy pulls Ashley's head forward and holds her face between her thighs. Cindy says "I own you." and starts to moan as your daughter has her first taste of her best friend's juices. You're completely entranced by what you see on the screen. Ashley licking and nibbling while Cindy grinds against her face. They're both moaning, Cindy from pleasure and Ashley from a **** need to please. You can't help but wonder what made your spoiled brat Princess become such a submissive, well, slut? And is Ashley gay or bi or was she just telling Cindy what she wanted to hear to get it over with?

Eyes glued to the screen you start to stroke your cock in tandem with Cindy's hips moving against Ashley's face. You see Ashley pushing her tongue between Cindy's folds and focusing on her clit but in your head she's kneeling before you and going to work on your cock. Occasionally when Cindy let's out an especially happy groan the image in your head changes and it's you kneeling in front of this 18-year-old girl and worshipping her with your mouth. Sometimes Ashley is there alongside you, sharing her friend's slippery and delicious cunt. Other times the fantasy switches back to Ashely on her knees and Cindy kneeling next to her waiting to share. In yet another fantasy you imagine Ashley kneeling before the both of you after you've finished fucking Cindy. Your daughter, eager to please the both of you, is eating your cum from Cindy's pussy before moving on to clean up your cock.

Cindy's moans increase and you can tell by the look on her face she's close to her single allocated orgasm. You stroke furiously watching her but thinking about the fantasy that turns you on the most.

I need a little help figuring out the direction you'd like me to take this story. Leave some comments as to how you'd like the blackmailer to **** the direction for you. Some ideas:

  1. You submit to Cindy alongside Ashley
  2. Ashley is the ultimate sub and submits to both of you
  3. The tables are turned and Cindy is **** to submit to you alongside Ashley
  4. You're **** to continue to be nothing more than an observer as you watch your daughter **** into deeper perversions
  5. A heirarchy is established: You submit to the blackmailer, Cindy submits to you, and Ashley submits to everyone (this is already sort of happening in the branch where Cindy gives the orgasm to Ashley, so if you like tbis idea click back a couple of threads and go that way)
    (and, of course, anyone is welcome to take a scenario and run with it! I'd love to have more contributors on some of these threads)

Which fantasy turns you on the most?

  • No further chapters

Comments

      Want to support CHYOA?
      Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)