Choose Carly.

The whole point of this excursion was to see Carly naked, so, of course you pick her! You slowly make your way down the deck and take a left. Around the bend you spot her in the dim glow of the garden lights. She’s covering herself, self consciously. She sees you coming and starts moving back and forth, anxiously. You try to keep her at ease with a gentle smile. She smiles back.

“Hi…” you say to her, softly.

“Hi…” she replies, barely able to look up.

“Some day we’ve had, huh?” you ask.

Carly giggles and brushes her hair aside, nervously. “Yeah… wasn’t expecting to be naked in a stranger’s backyard….” she agrees. She clings to herself and leans closer to whisper, “I don’t normally do stuff like this…”

You smirk. She giggles.

“Well, I’m glad I get to be here when you do,” you tell her. She smiles, sheepishly. “You must be really good friends with Abigail to do this for her…” you add.

“Well,” Carly says hesitantly. “It was actually, sort of… my idea…”

Your eyes widen. “Oh?”

Carly covers her face in embarrassment and explains. “I wasn’t sure if you were more interested in me or her, and this way you wouldn’t have to reject one of us directly.”

“That’s pretty clever,” you admit.

“Thanks…”

“And you know what?”

“What?”

“I chose you…”

Carly’s shy grin grows into a bold smile. You return her smile as she straightens up and drops her arms, giving you a full view of her naked figure. She is petite yet well developed. She has perfectly round natural breasts that shine in the lamplight. The lamps also draw out her hourglass figure in soft yellow lighting. .

“May I touch you?” you ask politely. Carly steps forward and takes your hand, guiding it up to her breast. She is warm and soft to the touch. She exhales softly and continues to guide your hand down her body. You feel the tuft of hair over her mound and the slickness of her labia. You step in and give her a kiss. She kisses back.

Your fingers press into her slit. You feel her rise up and gasp. Your finger slides inside and begins to rub the tender flesh. Carly moans into your mouth and reaches out for your cock. It’s already hard and she gets a firm grasp around it. You groan between your locked lips and continue to make out. She strokes you through the fabric of your shorts as you smack lips, sucking on each other’s faces.

Eventually, Carly lets go of your cock and you feel her tugging down your shorts. You oblige her and, once free of clothing, you take her by the hips and lean her against the deck. She gasps and lets you take her. You guide your cock between her legs and can feel her body tremble with excitement. She moans softly as you slide yourself in.

“Oh my God….” she gasps, clutching onto you as if she were stranded at sea. You thrust into her, feeling her tight pussy squeeze around your rigid cock. She shivers and holds you tight. You thrust again and she lets out a soft moan. You keep pumping and she pushes her body into yours, straining for every inch of pleasure she can from you.

You grab Carly’s fine ass with each hand and squeeze her cushy cheeks before lifting her up onto your hips. From there, you can feel the full weight of her body push down onto your stiff cock. You feel her legs wrap around your body as you groan with pleasure. She bounces, getting a feel for her position and gaining her balance. Then, she bounces harder. Soon, she is steady enough to bounce her body into yours at a steady pace, giving you an up front view of her jiggling breasts as they try to catch up with her hips and ass. The wet smacks of your horny bodies slapping together soon become more audible than your quiet moans.

You become worried that you might give yourselves away to the others, but Carly is more focused on the pleasure she is getting from your hardened appendage. Her cries of pleasure grow faster and higher pitched. You can feel her body tensing up as she nears her climax. You grunt out, feeling yourself close to cumming too.

“Please don’t cum inside me…” Carly begs, feeling your intensity as well. You bite your lower lip and hold yourself in a little longer as she shudders from her climax. She makes a squeaky yelp and shudders in your arms. You focus all your mental strength on not bursting inside her as she enjoys her orgasm.

Once she settles, you set her down to her feet and pull out. She falls to her knees, ready to finish you off, but you’re already over the edge! You blow your load all over her face. She yelps as your spunk splashes her face and dribbles down her chin. Your second shot splatters her breasts. A third and forth ejaculation has her coated and oozing with your fluids in mere moments.

“Sorry, I didn’t mean to....” you apologize quickly.

Carly holds up her hand and shakes her head, “It’s alright…” She wipes her face down and admires your work. “I didn’t know you had so much in you!”

“What do we…?”

“I guess we gotta go back up…” Carly says with some trepidation.

You head onto the deck first and look around. Lynn and Abigail are nowhere to be seen. You tell Carly the coast is clear and she joins you. In the pool lighting, you get a better view of Carly’s full figure. Her curves are so appealing to the eyes, accentuated with sexiness with every step she takes. The bluish tinge of the pool lighting makes Carly’s skin glimmer from below. She wades into the pool and washes herself off, glancing at you with less embarrassment. You wonder if she’s enjoying this bit of exhibitionism as she wipes away your cum.

Soon, Lynn and Abigail pop onto the deck. Carly covers herself instinctively, but realizes that the other girls are naked as well. From the looks of things, they were having their own fun. The lot of you are all smiles and giggles. You dress and head back to the car. Carly and Abigail are dropped off at the shop and Lynn takes you home.

“Nice stuff,” Lynn congratulates, after the girls are gone.

“Not bad yourself,” you tell her.

“We should do this more often!”

“I have to admit, this was fun.”

“So, you up for another challenge?” Lynn asks with a wry grin.