Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 45 by DarkSoulDrinker DarkSoulDrinker

Who to follow first?

Chloe and Zack

Zack spat into the toilet. Chloe stood by with a glass of water and concerned face. He took the glass when she offered it but he couldn't look her in the eye.

"Zachary Bishop," Chloe barely managed to avoid shouting at him. "What is going on? Ever since I got back you can barely talk to me."

Zack closed his eyes. His stomach was turning again, but not with nausea. "While you guys were gone, Ashley convinced me, Kurt, and Brandon to gang up and fuck her all together."

Chloe blinked at that mental image. She put a hand on Zack's shoulder and sighed. "Your mom ate me out."

Zack opened his eyes and looked up at Chloe in confusion. "What? When? Where?" Chloe couldn't help herself. She giggled. This in turn caused Zack to start laughing. It took them a little while to calm back down. Zack slowly stood up and looked at Chloe. "But seriously how did you and my mom end up hooking up?"

"While you were fucking Ashley," Chloe lightly punched Zack in the side, "I was lying helplessly on an exam table while your mom had her way with me."

Zack took a long sip of water before continuing. "I've gotta admit. This conversation is going in a completely different, weirder direction that I imagined it would."

Chloe smiled and leaned against Zack's arm. "I'm not mad if that's what you're worried about. Well, not too mad. I guess I'm a little jealous, but I did lick Ashley's pussy just last night so I guess it's not that crazy that you fucked her."

Zack felt a weight leave his shoulders. "That's pretty much the same logic Ashley used when she begged me to assist."

"You mean you didn't dive right in when she presented herself to you?" Chloe smirked as they started walking back to their bedroom.

Zack closed the door and tried to put a stern face on as he faced Chloe. "I initially protested her desire until she out logicked me." Chloe smirked at the idea of Ashley being the logical one. "But you're seriously okay with us?"

"I'm okay. Besides, once I get Brandon, Gavin, and Kurt to tag team me, I figure we'll be even." Chloe laughed as she watched Zack's face screw up in revulsion. "I'm teasing. Though it would serve you right."

"I'm a hypocrite," Zack settled onto the bed and pulled Chloe down with him. "Sue me. You still haven't explained how my mom ended up having her way with you."

"Oh God," it was Chloe's turn to be embarrassed. "I still don't fully believe it myself." She snuggled into Zack's arms and began recounting her visit to the clinic. As she retold the parts with Zack's mom teasing her, she felt Zack begin to get harder. By the time she finished her story she was rubbing his cock threw his pants. "You seem reasonably okay with all this."

"It's a little weird, but also kinda exciting," Zack squirmed a little and tried to slip his hand inside Chloe's pants. She batted his hand away but then started to remove her clothes. Zack followed suit and they were soon naked and snuggled together again.

Chloe traced her fingernail along the shaft of Zack's cock making it twitch. "I told you about your mom. Now you have to tell me about Ashley." Zack eyed Chloe for a moment but then figured fair was fair. He started with Ashley's surprising proposal in the kitchen and went all the way to the end. As he told the story, he and Chloe both began exploring each other's body. When the story was finished, Chloe was slowly stroking his cock while Zack languidly teased her clit. "I don't know about three guys at once, but Ashley might be on to something with a dick in both my ass and pussy." She looked Zack in the eye and began stroking him faster. "Do you think you'd be willing to share me with one of your friends?"

Zack fought his jealousy and pondered the question. "I guess I've already essentially shared you with Brandon. And I think I'd be okay Gavin."

Chloe kissed him softly and smirked. "Are you sure you're just not trying to think of ways to get with Ashley or Victoria." Zack stammered and Chloe laughed. "You're so easy to tease, Bishop."

Zack mock frowned at Chloe and shifted from teasing her to trying to get her off. "Careful McRose, sometimes if you tease someone too long, the person you're teasing snaps."

"Oh yeah," Chloe moaned. "And what happens when you snap?"

Zack quickly rolled on top of her. "Why don't we find out?" He kissed Chloe fiercely and thrust into her. She moaned into his mouth and wrapped her legs around his back. Visions of Ashley and Heather faded as Zack stared down at the beautiful redhead beneath him.

"Yes, Zack," Chloe writhed. Despite everything, Zack made it all seem right. He made her feel good in more ways than just physical. "I love being filled by you. I...I love you."

Zack heard Chloe's confession and it spurred him onward. "I love you too, Chloe." He was ramming his cock in and out of her. Despite the passion running through him, he realized he really did mean it. Chloe wasn't just his friend. She wasn't just a fuck. She was the woman he wanted.

Chloe started to rake her fingers across Zack's back. She needed him to take her. "Fuck me, Zack. Make me yours."

Zack thrust in an out of his love. She met him thrust for thrust. They were somehow perfectly in sync with each other. Their lips met and Zack knew he was done for. Chloe dug her nails into his back and tightened her legs, trying to pull him deeply into her.

"CHLOE!" Zack grunted and buried himself inside her.

"ZACK!" Chloe's body clamped down as they orgasmed together.

They lay together for a moment before Zack finally rolled off next to Chloe. She snuggled up to him and they just stared into each other's eyes for a few moments. Zack was the first to break the silence. "I meant what I said. I love you."

"I love you too," Chloe kissed him slowly and tenderly. She sat up and eyed his half hard cock. "Now let's see what we can do about getting you ready for some more action. I'm not done with you yet."

Who to follow next?

More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)