Butt Stuff!

"I know! You can stick it in my butt!"

"Hu- what?" you ask, flabbergasted by the sudden offer.

"Well I have been practicing with my plug tail," Ashley giggles. "I've been waiting for a good time to bring it up, and this seems as good as any."

"Oh. Are you sure you want to?"

"Don't question it you fool, she might change her mind!" Tibby exclaims.

"Ok, but... do we have lube?" you sputter.

"We have this." Ashley picks up the tube of toothpaste and grins at you. "But yes, we do have lube. There's some in the bedroom. You wanna go?"

Instead of answering, you scoop the bunny off the toilet and almost start running, but there's no sense ruining this opportunity by slamming her head against a door frame or something. So you take it slow. Ashley whoops in surprise when she's lifted into the air and wraps an arm around your neck as you carry her to the bedroom, where you unceremoniously toss her onto the bed. She bounces, but catches herself before she hits anything. "Someone's eager!" she exclaims and reaches for the lowest drawer of the bedside stand, waving her tail in your direction as she does.

"Nice view!" Tibby shouts when she makes it into the bedroom. "Almost makes me wish I was a guy so I could be the one to pound that ass."

Ashley turns around, her face red with embarrassment. "Tibby, shut it! I don't know why you're so obsessed with my ass."

You can't help piling it on. "She's obsessed with it because your ass is to die for, and maybe we should buy a strapon so she can have a turn."

"Nobody's getting a turn if you don't both shut up," Ashley says, her face even redder. But then a lewd smile sneaks onto her face. "So what'll it be, want to crack another joke or are you going to fuck me in the ass already?"

"You said 'crack,'" you snicker before clapping your hand over your mouth. You mime zipping your lips and get on the bed with Ashley.

She throws a small bottle of lubricant your way and rises onto her knees so she can undo her belt. Then she drops onto her back and points her feet at the ceiling while pulling her pants down, or rather up, her legs. It's an incredibly impractical way to take off tight jeans but damn does it look good. Her nude thighs wiggle as she works her pants past her calves, and you catch a flash of her pussy every time her legs open slightly.

Tibby rolls the chair from your desk over and gets comfortable, watching Ashley contort herself out of her clothes with interest. You have a much easier time getting naked, all you have to do is undo the towel wrapped around your waist. Then you open the bottle of lube and look for something to smear it on. Thinking quickly, Tibby gets up to duck into the closet and emerges with a large ball of cotton that she lobs at you on her way back to the chair.

When you catch it you recognize it as Ashley's other tail, the one with the plug. Holding it by the poofy white end, you drip some lube onto the rubbery part and spread it around with one finger. When it's thoroughly covered Ashley, now naked except for her white collar and ears, crawls backward until her booty bumps into your arm. "Stick that thing in me," she says with a look over her shoulder at the tail.

Before you do so you run a hand admiringly over her ass. Its perfect curve is free of blemishes, only interrupted by a small dimple on each side. It ripples just a bit when you give it a light smack... and then you pull one cheek to the side and her little pucker stares back at you. It's darker than the skin around it, and your gaze naturally glides from it down to her glistening pussy. You dip your fingers into that familiar orifice, gathering some of Ashley's fluid to carry up to its neighbor.

You press your fingers lightly against Ashley's rosebud, stimulating her in a new way as you spread her cum onto it in little circles. Then you move your hand onto her cheek again, spreading her crack so you can touch her tail to the same area. You press the lubricated plug gently against Ashley's sphincter, and it pops in without much resistance. She groans quietly, used to its size but still surprised by the intrusion.

You wiggle the tail side to side in an effort to loosen her up, but the fluffy ball doesn't give you much leverage. After a while you pull it out and use your fingers instead, sliding two lubed-up digits into Ashley's rear entrance while two more travel down to stroke the lips of her pussy.

The naked Tibby rolls right up to the edge of the bed on your chair to get a closer look. Both her hands are busy between her legs as she watches you rub Ashley's clit while you finger her asshole, spreading your fingers to open her up in preparation for your prick. You want to make Ashley cum like this, but before you can she tells you she's ready for the main event and reminds you to lube yourself up too.

Tibby leans forward in her seat to stoke Ashley's fire while you smear lube around your shaft. It doesn't take long to get it everywhere, so she switches to spreading Ashley's cheeks while you guide your cock into her crack. You rub it up and down for a second, but this isn't the time for teasing. With Tibby watching intently, you begin to push forward, slowly increasing the pressure until your head breaks through. You stop immediately when Ashley emits a loud groan, and just marvel at the tight sensation of her sphincter squeezing you from every side. When its tight grip relaxes slightly, you start moving again. Inch by inch you ease into Ashley's ass, each time making sure she's adjusted to your size before pushing it further in. Tibby helps things along by taking one hand off Ashley's rump, reaching down to stroke her thighs and pussy lips so her mind can focus on something other than the intruder in her rear.

By the time you bottom out in her, Ashley's groans have started sounding more aroused than uncomfortable. Tibby watches with glee as your last inch slides into Ashley and your hips press against her cheeks. "She really took the whole thing," she says with admiration. Her eyes widen even more when you pull most of the way out and slide back in, in one smooth motion this time. You grin at her and give Ashley a few more slow, deep thrusts.

After a while Tibby gets off the chair and sits on the bed by Ashley's head so she can see her face. "Your booty really is amazing, Ash. I don't know if mine could handle all that, but I kind of want to try it."

"More than you want to try a strapon?" Ashley manages to press out between her lust-filled grunts.

"They're both on my bucket list," Tibby says brightly. "It depends on how much you enjoy this with John."

You thrust into Ashley a bit harder and it's clear that she does enjoy it. Each penetration makes it easier for her to take the next, increasing her pleasure and decreasing the pain you're causing her. Which is fortunate because between the thrill of fucking someone's ass for the first time, the tight embrace of the orifice in question, and the fact that you're inside Ashley without a condom again, you have to fight to avoid shooting your load too soon.

Tibby shifts the odds in your favor by bending down to push her tits into Ashley's face. She shakes her chest to jiggle them and rubs them against the bunny's face before guiding one of them to her mouth so she can suck on her nipple. At the same time she reaches down with both hands to grab Ashley's boobs, and eagerly plays with the dangling pair. Despite being muffled by a mouthful of tit-flesh, Ashley's moans get louder and louder as you grab her hips and thrust into her from behind.

You give her ass a few more smacks too, hesitant at first but with more enthusiasm once you're sure she likes it. Then, knowing you can't hold back any longer, you grab her hip again with one hand and use the other to rub her clit while slamming into her. Her whole body shakes, and her ass clenches almost painfully around your cock as she screams into Tibby's tit. You can barely move, but you don't have to as her muscles spasm and milk your cum into her bowels. Even after you're drained you stay lodged in her rear, until she comes down from her orgasm and releases her grip on you.

You carefully extract yourself from her tight asshole, and look down to see it gape for a second before closing again, trapping your seed inside her body. You're still breathing heavily when Ashley spits out Tibby's nipple so she can speak. "I hope you enjoyed that enough to accept my apology, master."

When you nod wordlessly, she smirks and turns back to the cat sitting in front of her. "And what about you? Think you want to give this a try?"

For once it's Tibby who has to blush. "I don't know. That was pretty intense. Maybe I'd better stick to master's fingers until I'm ready, or you could beat him to the punch with a small strapon."