Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 21 by telaviv telaviv telaviv telaviv

Let's skip ahead then.

But I want smut!

Alright, get your willies out and ready your hoo-haas, because here we go:

It's the next morning, and the girls are starting to stir at your sides. Ashley sits up, stretches, and contorts her face in a big yawn. "We have an eventful day ahead of us. I've never been somewhere only for pets, and I don't want to miss anything. John, why don't you take care of your pets so we don't get horny out there?"

"I don't think that would work, but I'm happy to try." You and reach out to pull her down on top of you. You kiss her deeply, enjoying the pressure of her soft breasts against your skin. Your hands roam over her body until they reach her waist. Latching on, you take Ashley with you as you roll onto your front, and she finds herself on her back beneath you.

You keep kissing your sexy bunny as you lie between her legs. Your dick rapidly swells and presses against her upper thigh. Ashley's hands land on your butt, and she tugs you into position so the head of your dick touches her pussy. There's some moisture, but she's not ready to be penetrated yet. You're content to grind against her, your tongue swirling inside her mouth. You still can't believe you're doing this with your closest friend. You can't believe it took you this long to see her as anything other than a friend.

You're ripped from your thoughts when Ashley turns her head to disengage her lips from yours. For a second you think you've done something wrong, except she's smiling up at you. "That feels nice but I was hoping for more than a dry-hump. Fuck me, master!"

Nodding eagerly, you reach between your bodies to make sure your cock is lined up with her entrance before slowly pushing forward.

"Ooooh," she moans as her pussy stretches around you, and the sound pulls Tibby into full consciousness.

"Mmmm, what's going on here?" she asks as her eyes open. "I'm not even awake yet and this horny bunny is getting some?"

Ashley tries to say something in response, but is cut off when you pull back and slide into her again. You reach out and pinch the kitty's nipple before resting your hand on her toned stomach. "Don't complain. First come, first cum. You'll get a turn after Ashley's had hers. If you're impatient you could sit on her face and let her eat you out."

"That sounds like fun," Tibby purrs, "but I'd have to get up to do that. Why don't you just finger me while I lie here?"

"I spoil you, don't I?" you ask with another thrust into Ashley.

"If you know what's good for you," Tibby grins up at you.

You pinch her nipple again, hard enough to make her squeak, but then you loosen your grip and tweak it gently, playing with it while you increase the speed of your lovemaking. You trail your hand down her body, build up her anticipation by stopping to draw little patterns here and there, and slowly work your way toward her cunt. It's already wet when you get there, and you slide a finger in with an eye on Tibby's face. She grabs your hand to pull you in deeper, which presses your palm against her. You curl and uncurl your finger as you move your hand, rubbing your palm against her clit. She moans, and Ashley joins her.

Your attention shifts back to your friend. She has one leg wrapped around you to keep you in position, the other is splayed out on the bed. Her pussy clutches at your cock and massages you as you slide in and out of her rhythmically. Her breasts juggle with every thrust, but you look past them to her beautiful face. Her eyes seek out yours, and you can feel her joy when you make eye contact. You adore her. You love Tibby too, but your feelings for Ashley exist on a deeper level. It's not that you love her more per se, but you've known her so much longer. You know her intimate secrets, and she knows yours. You lean down to kiss her, not a lustfull tongue kiss but one of romantic passion. If she changed her mind about being a pet, you could easily see her as your girlfriend.

Of course, neither of those would be an option without Tibby. You were completely oblivious to Ashley as more than a friend until the mischevious cat opened your eyes by lending out her ears. You owe all this to her. You look back at her, and through the haze of lust in her eyes you can see her adoration. She's at ease around you and trusts you completely, which is no easy feat after being abandoned by her own childhood friend, a person who meant as much to her as Ashley means to you. She opened up to you about that painful past, even if she hasn't told you much about it yet. You move your finger inside her faster, and grind your palm against her harder, which makes her moan appreciatively. You love her.

Both girls shudder as they reach their orgasm together. You kiss Ashley again, then you pull out of her dripping pussy to switch to Tibby. As you move from bunny to kitty, you notice that they've reached out to hold hands. The adorable sight fills you with joy. You couldn't possibly choose between them, and fortunately you don't have to. They're as into each other as they're attracted to you and either would kick your ass if you tried to get rid of the other, not that you ever would.

Before you can get on top of her, Tibby turns onto her side to look at Ashley, who does likewise and gets in close to kiss the cat. Since missionary is out you drop onto the bed behind Tibby and spoon against her back, your slick cock poking at her crack.

"I don't do anal in the morning, master." Tibby giggles while you adjust your position so it can slide between her legs. She's wet and ready for you, but you take the time to enjoy the crevice between her thighs first, only bumping against her pussy teasingly.

Then you lift her leg slightly to make some room to work in, rub the tip of your dick against her wet slit one more time, and pull her lower body against you as you move forward. The angle you're penetrating her from means your cock pushes against her inner wall with every thrust, and she's soon moaning too much to focus on kissing. Ashley adapts by shifting closer to the foot of the bed and sucking one of Tibby's nipples into her mouth, which transforms the cat's moans into a loud wail. She's like a ragdoll, bouncing around with her leg in the air as you fuck her from behind and Ashley plays with her nipples.

Her pussy ripples around your shaft, squeezing and massaging it as you drive each other into a frenzy. When you cum you slam deep into her and her whole body tenses. A second later Ashley is kissing her again, muffling the scream of Tibby's orgasm with her mouth.

For a while you all lie there, Tibby sandwiched between you and Ashley as you reach out to stroke her body and each other's lovingly.

"Should we be getting ready to go now? How early do you want to be at this park?"

What's next?

More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)