More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 5 by Callum95 Callum95

Who will John Fuck?

Both of them, of course! But not right now.

//It has been a while since i added to this section of Sexual Privilege. I have re-read my past two chapters but i may accidentally end up making a small discrepancy in the story. But then again, we just wanna see some sex right?! Well get strapped in! The redhead Abigail is inspired by the pornstar Lauren Phillips.

John replayed the choices in his head, either he could go and fuck his childhood best friend (a person he had crushed on and had fantasies about) but it would change their friendship irreparably or he could go and fuck her mother, a woman who is clearly a MILF by suggestion of her suggestive clothes, her always flirty attitude to hot men and women and the raucous sounds that emanate from her sound according to Claire. It was a tough decision until he just simply thought and slightly whispered "why not both?".

He had been told by his sister that he basically had the ability to go and fuck any redhead, either naturally or dyed and be thought of as cute or romantic when he did. Through that twisted, new way of thinking, he should be able to suggest the idea of fucking Abigail to Claire and she would swoon in awe at the great 'romantic' idea he came up with. Even if in reality, he was asking his new girlfriend to have a threesome with her own mother.

With his decision decided, he goes up to Abigail's room and knocks on her door. John waits for a second before a slightly startled Abigail answers with "who is it?"

John replies with "it is me, John. I wanted to ask you something"

Abigail replies with a sudden calmness as she says "Come on in"

John turns the door knob and comes in, to immediately stop with a look of shock and a twinkle of lust in his eyes. Abigail is half naked, with some tight jeans on that show that her arse is tightly contained within them. Even though Abigail may be in shape, the fat on her body has gone to the right places. But above the waist, she is void of clothing as her 36C tits hang unhampered in perfect view for John. John fights to hold off the incoming erection he is about to harbor at seeing his friend's mom's tits for the first time. Unfortunately, he can't help it and a formidable bulge appears on his pants.

Abigail goes to answer John's incoming question before he can even think to speak. "As soon as i knew it was you, i didn't mind if you saw my tits. I thought you was my daughter, that is a different story." There John learnt two things. One, he could walk in on redheads naked or doing anything naughty and they would be fine. Two, he assumed that because he was the one having sex with Claire and Abigail, that Claire would think him romantic and Abigail would be happy to help. However, he forgot to think that the relationship between the two would strain his newfound ability. He would be able to fuck either one separately but together, would bring up issues.

To solve this issue, he made up a quick plan to fuck them both separately. He would suggest the idea to each of them after sex that the idea of sex in a threesome between all three would be good. He would argue against Claire by saying this will be his new life of fucking redheads, she couldn't refuse that and then he would say that to refuse the threesome would be refusing his natural sex with redheads. A bit manipulative so he would work on it. With Abigail, he would say that he wants a relationship between the three of them as he wants Claire as his girlfriend and Abigail as his redhead to use. To say no to the threesome would mean she is putting strain on the relationship her daughter wants and what she wants herself with John.

It was a shitty thought plan but a plan, nonetheless. He decided to fuck Claire first as she is actually sleeping with him due to true love, not a sudden urge to do what he says due to hair colour. With that, John stammers out an apology that is more stutter and letters than words then goes downstairs into Claire's room. He walks in on Claire on the bed, with just a nightie on and what he assumes was nothing else on. She looked at him with a lust he had never see in someone before and he knew he had to have her right then and there.

But which way should he play it? Be dominating and rough? Loving and sensual?

How should John have sex with Claire?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)