Beth

Susie looked around the room. I wasn't sure how long we could keep this game going. Would we run out of ideas of what we could do to each other? I’m wasn’t sure if it was possible to run out of ideas for sex.

“Beth,” my sister called out finally. “I dare you to let David fuck you in the ass!”

Hurray! My sister was looking out for me. She must have realized I was wanting some more action.

Beth looked at my sister then looked back at me. “You call that a dare?” she asked with a sly smile. “I was planning on letting him fuck me in the ass later after the game was over. Besides, how do you know I like it up the ass?”

She jumped up from the sofa and hustled over to my chair. “Come on, big boy! I dare you to help me complete my dare.”

“My pleasure, I grinned.

I jumped out of my chair and grabbed Beth around the waist, pulling her up against me and giving her a big sloppy kiss. I grabbed her ass with both hands as we kissed, pulling her cheeks apart and sliding some fingers over toward her bunghole.

Beth reached down and grabbed my cock by the base. “Oh yeah, I think you’re ready. Where do you want to do this?”

“I have an idea,” I smiled. I guided her over to the end of the sofa. I had her bend over the arm of the sofa. “Oh, yeah, that looks like a good target,” I winked at her as she looked over her shoulder at me. The result of course was that while her ass was facing me, she was actually facing the other three girls.

“Anybody got any lube?” I asked.

“God, you dumbass,” Beth spat over her shoulder. “My pussy is dripping already. Just get some of my juice back there.”

Well, you know it’s no fun to be called a dumbass by the hot girl you’re getting ready to fuck in the ass. But that wasn’t going to deter me. I reached down with one hand and slid my fingers along her pussy, which was indeed totally wet. I slid my fingers in and got them as wet as I could. Then I slid back to her tight little brownie and slid my fingers in her hole. I repeated this action two or three times. Then I rubbed my cock with my wet fingers to lubricate it too.

“You don’t know how many times I’ve dreamed about doing this to you, Beth,” I told her as I positioned my now throbbing cock in front tight pucker hole.

“Just shut up and do it already,” she spat back at me.

Ok, so maybe we weren’t in love. But we definitely both wanted to fuck each other. I didn’t hesitate any longer. I pushed my purple mushroom head into her sphincter and once I felt it was in, I rammed the rest of my hard cock up her butt. She squealed as I immediately went in deep, all the way to the hilt. The feeling was so strong it made my head spin. Once I was all the way in, I grabbed her hips and held them steady as I started to withdraw then plunge right back in.

Beth groaned and pushed her hips back against me. “Oh yeah, David. Just like that! Fuck me! Fuck my ass!”

Like she had to tell me what to do. I went after it hot and heavy, thrusting as hard and deep into her rear entry as I could. We were both breathing hard and I knew it wasn’t going to take long now until we both exploded in a crazy mutual orgasm.

I let go of her hip with one hand and reached between her legs and squeezed her swollen clit.

“ARRRGGGGGGHHHHHH!,” Beth let loose with an ear-piercing scream, as her body quivered wildly beneath me. My hand on her clit felt her warm juices flowing out of her pussy as wave after wave of her bliss rolled over her. “Jesus christ, David! What the fuck did you do to me?” It was obviously one of her hardest cums ever.

I felt the hot tingling in my balls starting to rise up my shivering shaft, but I didn’t want to waste my hot seed inside her barren ass. I whipped my cock out as it started to gush stream after ropey stream of white jizz all over Beth’s ass and back. To my surprise, Amy and Carly jumped up from the sofa and put their faces up on Beth’s back in front of me trying to catch the final spurts from my one-eyed monster. They licked Beth’s ass and back as she collapsed on the sofa. I fell backward ending up sitting on the floor next to the sofa. Beth and I were both wasted. I wasn’t sure how long it would take her to recover so she could make the next pick.