Carly

When Beth was finally able to sit back up she was just laughing and grinning. “Well, I don’t know how to dare anyone to have more fun than I just had,” she smiled. “I thought dares were supposed to be about making someone do something they didn’t want to do. It looks like now we’re just trying to see who we can make have the most sex with whom. Not that I’m complaining….”

She looked around the room contemplatively, trying to think of something that hadn’t been done yet.

“Ok, I think I got it,” she announced. “Carly, I want you to give David a blowjob while Amy eats your pussy.”

“Sure, that doesn’t sound too hard,” Carly smiled. “Maybe one of us will even enjoy it,” she laughed. “I guess the only question is whether David is up for it again.” The girls giggled again.

“Hey, I’m willing to go for it,” I piped up. “With four hot naked girls wanting my cock, I’m managing to recover pretty quick. I’m ready to go again.”

Carly got down on the floor on her back and I straddled her chest on my knees with my cock dangling in her face. Amy got down on the floor on her knees and bent her head down between Carly’s legs.

“So it looks like everybody’s ready,” Beth said. “Oh! But I forgot to tell you about the conditions. Number one, you only have five minutes. Number two, you have to make both Carly and David cum. If they don’t cum, there will be a punishment.” She laughed evilly. “Ok, ready? Go!”

Beth started a timer on her phone as Carly quickly grabbed my hips and wrapped her lips around my slowly growing member and Amy pushed her head between Carly’s thighs and began licking her wet pussy with her tongue. I figured that Amy wouldn’t have much trouble making Carly cum, but I wasn’t sure if I could cum again in five minutes even with Carly giving me a fantastic blowjob. I wondered who would be punished if we failed, Carly or me or both?

I had to admit, Carly was doing a hell of a job on my cock. She was probably the best cock sucker out of the four. My cock quickly grew steel hard and returned to its full length as she teased the tip with her lips and tongue, then sucked my rod deep into her mouth, hitting the back of her throat. She sucked hard, causing her cheeks to suck in and rub the sides of my full length as she bobbed back and forth on my cock, in and out of her warm wet mouth. Now I was totally erect and could feel some excitement starting to build up in my loins. Maybe I would be able to cum within the deadline after all. I closed my eyes and concentrated on the sensations I was experiencing as Carly sucked my cock for all she was worth.

In the meantime, I could tell that she was getting pretty excited too, as Amy was apparently doing quite a number on her pussy. My back was to her but I could hear the slurpy squishy sounds of her pussy and feel Carly’s body moving and shaking beneath me. Her sucking got more and more intense on my cock as she became more and more turned on by what Amy was doing to her pussy. I could feel my tension building quickly and could tell I was indeed going to cum very soon.

When Carly started moaning and humming on my rigid rod, I lost it and starting pumping another huge load of hot white cum into her mouth. My cock was at the back of her throat as my jizz shot out and she swallowed ever last drop before she released it quickly at the same time as she released a room-shattering scream. Her body thrashed and quivered as she moaned and groaned her way through her own orgasm. Then I heard Amy moaning too, not quite as loud. I turned to see that she was having an orgasm of her own too. Apparently sucking Carly had turned her on too and she had fingered herself to orgasm as she brought Carly to orgasm with her mouth.

In a few moments we all finally came down and relaxed where we were, finally silent for the moment. Beth looked at us in a pile there on the floor and gave a wry little smile.

“Well, I guess I have to say congratulations,” she said. “Four minutes and twenty-eight seconds. You came in under time, pun intended. And all three of you came, that was pretty cool.” She looked down at Carly who was still on her back on the floor, “So you ready to make the next dare?” she asked her.