Badly - both of them

"HEY! You are not! Stacey, I order you to clench your butt as tight as you can the entire time he is pushing in, until he cums." Olivia chimed in. "I told you, no remorse!" She sounded angry, but Finn did not care about her anger. He only cared about his failure that just made this ordeal way worse for the girl he loves.

He had a slight hope that Stacey had not heard the new order though. This was because she had started to scream from the sensation of her asshole being **** open by a dick that was an almost inhuman size. Sadly he could feel that she did. Once his tip was embedded inside of her, he could feel her muscles clench down on him and give him a massage.

Almost robotically he felt his hips move forward, while his hands pulled back Staceys hips, sinking deeper into her brown star. Her clenching made it impossible to thrust in faster, and so did the lack of lube. He had feared she would rip and start bleeding as he had begun this, but non of that happened.

Instead he felt his mouth move and heard his own voice stating. "Your ass is the tightest hole I ever were in, Olivia!" Followed by a deeper push that ended him 70% buried inside. He again had hoped that maybe at least Stacey would not have heard this as he spoke in a normal volume. The reason for that was that she had not stopped to scream and was bawling her eyes out from the pain she had feared anal would bring her from the beginning.

"Stacey, I order you to remain quiet, and now since he is inside you, I order you to grab the vibrator and fuck yourself with it in the same rhythm that your ass is being fucked." Olivia ordered as she stepped behind Finn and put her hands gently around his upper body, resting her head against his neck in what seemed like a loving embrace. When it weren't for the fact that he was forcefully sodomizing the woman he would want to have in a hug like that, and not a psychotic lunatic.

Still, he would be lying if he said he never wanted to fuck Staceys ass, but he clearly did not want it like this. However, his mouth did seem to disagree. "This is the best feeling I ever had on my cock." He said in a silent room, knowing that if not the first one, then at least this one was clearly heart by both girls.

A tear formed in his own eyes and he could not stop it rolling down as he began to cry, not even able to grasp the torment he was giving to his girlfriend. But his hips had finally bottomed out inside of her. "I wish we had done this sooner, it is like getting a handjob while fucking you at the same time, Olivia, I love it."

Somewhat lucky for him, his voice did break in that line that his body decided to speak against his will, so maybe Stacey would be able to realize how little he truly enjoyed it. At least emotional. Physical he could not deny that the feeling was absolutely heavenly, but that was completely nullified by the situation.

"If it so nice... let me help you" He heard Olivias voice right next to his ear. She whispered it. "I order you to start fucking her ass fast now, at least two thrusts each second, all in. And I order you to act like while you are hot for her ass, you hate her more than anyone else on the planet. This only counts for as long as my hand is on your shoulder, though. I don't want you to scheme a **** on me, when I leave you a lone for a hot second some time. Though, when I do it and if you feel it needed, spank her or reach around to hurt her titties and clit, that's fine with me. But make sure you make it vocally known how much you despise her as well, babe." She slowly moved her hand up to his shoulder to use her newest order, as he felt his body begin the true torment that was to come over the ****-to-silently-sobbing girl that he loved.