What happens next?
Back to Val's POV
Chapter 14
Valerie POV
I got home around five.
Three hours. Three hours of fries and fitting rooms and Chloe petting a leather jacket she couldn’t afford like it was a cat, and I had said out loud, in a food court, that my brother had big dick energy. I’d walked home through cut grass and sunshine with my secret sitting in my chest like a hot-water bottle. I did it, and nobody knows. I felt like a girl in a movie.
I took out my key, and opened the front door.
I looked up, and the hall was full.
Mom and Dad stood by the stairs in the clothes, like people in a photo they hadn’t agreed to be in. And in the middle of the rug—
Steph.
My brain did a little stutter, like a video buffering.
I knew that coat. Long, black, ugly, the coat she wears to banks and funerals. It was buttoned to the chin, in a house that was seventy-five degrees. Her hair was down. She had lipstick on. I could count the times I’d seen Steph in lipstick, and two of them were a wedding and a wake.
No, I thought. It wasn’t even a sentence. It was a flinch. Not her.
“Stephany?”
“Hi, Val!”
I flinched again, for real. That wasn’t a voice. That was a bird. Steph has the voice of a person reading you your own terms and conditions: low, dry, tired. She’s the one who picked up when I called from that party in tenth grade, and didn’t ask a single question until I was in the car. She taught me how to change a tire, and never to put my drink down, and which of Mom’s moods you can joke through and which you have to wait out. She lives across the city with three monitors and a router, and she says no to everyone about everything.
“What are you doing here?”
“I missed everybody,” said the bird. “I thought I’d stay a few days.”
She said it like she was reading it off a card. I could practically see the card.
After that the words went by like cars. I said something. She said something about shopping. I think I said Chloe and Yas. I wasn’t listening to either of us. I was reading her instead.
The buttons, every one done up, in order, like she’d checked them in a mirror. The lipstick, a shade too bright, put on by somebody who’d never had to pick one. One hand locked on the collar, white at the knuckles. Steph doesn’t dress up. Steph doesn’t arrive. Steph shows up already annoyed, with a laptop bag, and leaves first. Whatever this was, she had rehearsed it on the way over.
Mom was beaming at her. Dad held the duffel like it might go off. And Steph looked at the shorts, and the apron, and Mom’s dress that wasn’t a dress, and didn’t say a word, and I stopped breathing.
Please don’t ask.
Because if she asked, I’d have to answer, and I didn’t have a sentence for it. My brother did it. It’s fine. It’s great. I’m in it too. None of that would fit through the door.
A stair creaked.
I was the only one facing it. Steph had her back to the staircase, so I got Brian first, over her shoulder, coming down slowly with one hand trailing the rail. He didn’t hurry. He never hurries. He stopped on the third step, where the light from the landing window falls, and he looked at the back of my sister’s head the way you look at a text you’ve been waiting for all day.
No pants again.
It’s kind of se—
What am I thinking?
“Hey, Steph.”
She turned around, and from where I stood I only got the back of her: the neck going from white to pink in about a second, the shoulders dropping an inch, her heels coming up off the floor. I knew that drop. Mine did it every time he said my name.
“Hi,” she said, to somebody’s chest. Then words came out of her, the kitchen table, the wifi, something about already having told Mom, and I stopped listening. I was watching him. He wasn’t listening either. He’d put his hands in his pockets, and he was wearing a look I knew from the receiving end: patient, interested, a man watching a kettle he knew would boil.
When she finally ran out of words, he let the silence sit there for a second. I knew that trick too. The silence did the work.
“This is your home, Steph. You never need to ask.”
He came down the last two steps.
“Take it off,” he said. “Stay a while.”
Say no.
I was thinking it at the back of her head, as hard as I could, as if it might go through the bone. You say no to everybody. Say it. Say it, Steph.
He took the top button between two fingers, and I started counting. Nine buttons. At two, Dad found something interesting on the ceiling. At four, Mom smiled at nothing. At six I understood that nobody in this hall was going to say a word, because nobody in this house said a word anymore, and Steph wasn’t going to either, because I could see her face and she was too far gone.
Her cheeks were flushed, her eyes were locked on every button. Her mouth was open, like she was grasping for air.
She’s enjoying this.
That left me.
The coat came off.
It took my brain a second to put it together, because the pieces looked wrong on her. A schoolgirl. A little cardigan with a crest, a tie somebody else had knotted, white socks to the knee, a woman’s shoulders and a woman’s chest in a kid’s blouse. I had seen the same thing in every adult shop on the mall when I passed by.
She stood with her arms stiff at her sides, looking up at him, only him, like the rest of us had been unplugged.
“You wore it,” said Brian.
She started explaining, in the bird voice: the bag he’d brought, her old school, how she thought it had shrunk. It sounded like an apology for something she hadn’t done.
“No,” said Brian. “It fits.”
And my sister, twenty-eight years old, with a lipstick smile and her knees pressed together, looked at him exactly the way Mom looks at him. Exactly the way Dad does. Exactly the way I do.
This was the one person. The one person in my whole life who still said no. And I was watching her not.
“You look beautiful, Steph.”
He said it the way you sign something.
That was it.
I couldn’t take this anymore.
SLAP
The sound was enormous. It cracked off the walls and rang in my palm, hot and stinging and wonderful, and Brian’s head went sideways.
The rest comes in pieces. Steph saying my name in her bird voice. I know son of a bitch was in there, because Mom sucked in air. I know I said the one person. I know that at some point I stopped yelling at him and turned around and yelled at her, you don’t even know what he did to you, and Steph’s face went from confused to hurt in slow motion, and I’m going to be seeing that for a while.
And I know Mom said “Valerie,” because I felt it, sharp, the way you feel a door slam in another room.
Then Brian turned his head back. Slowly. There was a pink print of my hand on his cheek, and he touched it with two fingers and looked at his fingertips. He wasn’t angry. His mouth was a little open, and his eyebrows had pulled together, and he looked at me like he’d never seen me before.
“Val,” he said. “What—”
I had braced for anger. My whole body had been braced for it since the second my hand left my side, for the cold, flat, falling feeling, for him to say one word and make me say sorry. What I hadn’t braced for was his eyebrows.
That’s when I it down on me what I have done. It felt good but also really bad. And I wanted to cry.
I could have taken it back. I didn’t want to.
I ran. Up the stairs two at a time with my hand over my mouth, the tears starting somewhere around the landing, and I slammed my bedroom door so hard the pictures on the wall jumped.
I lay on my bed with my face in the pillow and cried until my nose was clogged and my head hurt.
I hit him.
It kept going around and around. I hit Brian. I hit my brother. I hit my… I couldn’t even finish the word. I’d had four whole steps to change my mind, and I hadn’t.
I should be scared. I waited to be scared. I waited for the cold, flat, sinking feeling I’d felt on Friday, when I thought he might be angry and I’d have to say sorry.
It didn’t come. I was just furious. Furious and sick, and under both of them, small and ugly and hot, something else, and I didn’t want to look at it.
Someone knocked.
Two knocks. Not loud.
“Go away,” I said, into the pillow.
Nothing.
Then he opened the door anyway.
I didn’t look at him. I heard the door close behind him, the latch clicking shut.
He didn’t say anything. He crossed the room and sat down at the edge of the bed. Not close. A careful distance, the way you sit next to a dog that might bite. The red mark was already going dark on his cheek.
I dragged myself up until my back was against the headboard, pulled my knees to my chest, and put my face between them.
Silence.
“Does it hurt?” I said, into my knees. My voice was thick.
“A little.”
“Good.”
He nodded, like that was fair.
“I’m not sorry,” I said.
“I didn’t ask you to be.”
“You did something to her.”
“What did I do?”
“Don’t.” I lifted my head and wiped my face with the heel of my hand. “Don’t do that voice. I saw her. I saw how she looked at you. That’s how Mom looks at you. That’s how Dad looks at you. That’s how I—” I stopped. “She’s talking like a kid. She did the thing with her collar. She’s walking around in a stupid costume saying it shrank, and she believes it, Brian, she believes it’s her school uniform, and she’s twenty-eight and she runs the security for a whole company.”
“I know.”
“She was the only one,” I said, and my voice cracked. “She was the only one left. Mom and Dad and me and now her, and I thought, if I stayed in the middle of it and kept it together, then at least there’d be someone outside. Someone who could just— look at it and see. And now she’s going to be one more. Another one of your women. Like Mom.”
It hung there.
“You think I broke her,” said Brian.
“You did.”
“Mm.” He took off his glasses and rubbed his eyes, and without them he looked younger, and tired, and a little pink around the nose. “Val. Come here.”
“No.”
“Val.”
I didn’t decide that either. I was already crawling down the bed, and then I was against his shoulder, and his arm came around me, and I was crying again, hard, into the gray cotton, and he let me. He rubbed my back. He didn’t say shh. He just waited until I ran out.
“Nobody’s ever hit me for somebody else before,” he said, after a while.
I laughed. It came out wet and awful.
“I mean it. I thought about it the whole way up the stairs. You were so mad. You were so—” He turned my face up, gently, with one finger under my chin. “You love her.”
“She’s my sister.”
“I know. That’s why you hit me.” He wiped under my eye. “That’s a good thing, Val. That’s not something to be ashamed of.”
My throat was too tight to answer.
“I’m going to tell you something,” he said. “And I need you to listen without hitting me again, okay?”
I nodded.
“Steph isn’t broken. And she’s not like Mom.” His thumb moved on my cheek. “She’s a piece. A big one. I need her, Val. She’s smarter than the rest of us put together, and she knows how to get into places no one else can get into. She’s the best thing that’s happened to me since the whole thing started. And I’m going to do what I have to, to make sure she’s with us.”
A piece.
I had so many questions that none of them could get out. They crowded up in my throat. What do you mean, the whole thing? What do you mean, with us? What did you do to her? What did you do to them?
“What did you do to them?” I said.
“I made them better.”
“Dad wears pink satin shorts.”
“Dad’s never been happier in his life.” He said it so simply. “Ask him. He cries when he cooks, did you know that? Not because he’s sad. Because he finally has something to do that makes him feel like a man.” His eyes didn’t move off mine. “I didn’t break anybody. I gave them what they were missing.”
I thought of Dad humming over the stove that morning. I thought of the way he’d said thank you when Brian told him what to do, like someone had handed him a present.
It made sense.
That was the awful part. It made sense. It slid into me, easy and warm.
“It’s not going to stop at this house,” said Brian.
“What?”
“Mom, Dad, Steph. You.” He wasn’t smiling. “I’m going to keep going, Val. There are so many people out there who are unhappy and lost and don’t know what they want. I’m going to give it to them. More women. A lot more. Everyone who matters, eventually. And it’s not just sex.” His mouth twisted. “Sex is the easy part. It’s the door. What’s behind it is everything. Money. People who run things. Real power. Nobody’s going to look down on us again. Not our teachers. Not our bosses. Not the guys who laughed at me in high school.”
He wasn’t performing. I knew his performances. This was just my brother, in a low voice, saying what he really wanted.
And I felt it go through me like a wave. Warm, from my stomach to my face. My whole body leaned in.
He’s going to do it. He’s actually going to do it.
And I get to be there.
“Why are you telling me?” I whispered.
“Because I can’t do it alone.” He took my hand and held it in both of his. “I’m not asking you to be Mom. I’m not asking you to cook and clean, or sit in the corner. I need someone next to me. Someone who thinks, who sees what I don’t, who people actually listen to. A captain.” His eyes were dark, and bright, and very serious. “My right hand.”
My heart was trying to get out through my ribs.
“Is that—” I said. “What does that mean?”
“It means Mom can have the kitchen,” said Brian. “And you can have me.”
I made a noise. I don’t know what kind. Something between a laugh and a sob.
“Am I—” I couldn’t get it out at first. “Brian. Did you do it to me, too?”
He didn’t say anything.
“You said you made them better. Did you do it to me? Is that why I—”
Why I…? Why I don’t know how to feel? Why I want you?
“Is that why?”
He looked at me for a long time.
Then he kissed me.
It was slow, and soft, and he tasted like the tea he hadn’t drunk, and my mouth opened before I told it to. His hand came up into my hair. His other hand was at the hem of my skirt.
That’s not an answer, I thought, from very far away.
But it was hard to care. He lowered me onto my back. The weight of him settled over me, warm and heavy, and my mind went quiet and white, like someone had turned the lights down in a room.
“Val,” he murmured against my throat. “Do you want to know what you are?”
“What?”
“Look at me.”
I looked.
“There’s a box in your nightstand,” said Brian. “Dad put it there.”
There was. I hadn’t noticed it that morning, but I opened the drawer, and my hand knew where to go, and the little foil square was between my fingers, cold and flat. My hands were shaking. He took it from me, and sat back on his heels, and shoved his boxers down, and put it on in about four seconds while I watched him, breathless, with my skirt shoved up around my waist and my thong pulled aside by his thumb.
“You’re not like Mom,” said Brian.
He came into me slowly, all at once, a long deep push that made my back arch off the mattress. I made a sound I didn’t know I had. I was still sore. It stung. It was the best thing I’d ever felt.
“Mom is the woman of the house,” he said, close to my ear, steady, with his hips rocking. “She keeps the kitchen. She can have that. She can be as jealous as she wants.” A deep thrust. My nails went into his shoulders. “She’s mine. Dad’s mine. Steph’s going to be mine. But you.”
“Brian—”
“You’re my queen.”
I came apart.
Yes. Not a princess anymore. A queen.
I couldn’t have stopped it. It was like falling down a stair. His voice was in my ear, and I felt it in my chest and between my legs, one big wave from top to bottom. I cried out, one high, thin, short sound, and every muscle in my body let go all at once, like someone had been holding a string for days and finally dropped it.
He kept going. A little longer. His breathing got ragged. “My queen,” he said, against my mouth. “Say it.”
“Your queen.”
“Mine.”
“Yours.”
He came with his face in my neck. I held him, with my legs around his back, and my whole body felt wrung out and soft and clean.
It wasn’t until later, afterward, lying there with his weight on me and his heart still pounding on my ribs, that I thought, in a thin, small voice, from very far down:
He never answered.
And then I thought: It doesn’t matter.
He pulled out and got rid of the condom and lay on his back next to me, and I curled against his side. For a minute neither of us said anything. The light in the room had gone orange.
“I have something for you,” he said.
“What?”
“A job.”
I propped myself up on one elbow. He was looking at the ceiling, with his glasses off and the red mark on his cheek and a small, tired, satisfied smile.
“Chloe and Yasmin. Did they like the video?”
“I— yeah. They watched it. I told you. They—” My face got hot. “They think you have big dick energy.”
Brian laughed. It was a real laugh, helpless, surprised, and for a second he covered his eyes with his arm.
“They said that?”
“They said you’re a creep. But you have it.”
“Good. That’s good.” He took his arm off his face. “I want them here, Val. Tomorrow. After class.”
“Here?”
“You said it was a tutorial. For a look. Makeup, outfits, whatever it is you girls do.” He turned his head on the pillow. “Invite them over. Make them want to come. Don’t tell them anything. Just get them in this room.”
“Okay,” I said. It came out immediately. It wasn’t even a question.
“Good girl.”
I put my head back on his chest and listened to him breathe. My ponytail had come out. My top was twisted around my ribs. I could hear Mom somewhere down the stairs, banging a pot.
And I thought about Steph, down there in the hall, in her tie and her little socks, with her face on fire. You don’t even know what he did to you.
“Brian.”
“Mm?”
“Be nice to her.”
“I’m always nice to her.”
“I mean it.” I made myself say it. I didn’t know where it came from. “She’s mine too.”
He was quiet a second. Then he tilted my chin up and kissed me, quick, on the forehead, like a prize.
“I know,” he said. “That’s why she’s going to be fine.”
We came down together.
He went first. I let him. My legs hadn’t completely stopped shaking, but they had found a way to do it that looked like walking. My top was crooked. My ponytail was a ruin. I could feel my face, swollen and blotchy, flushed to the collarbone, and I didn’t fix any of it. Let them look. I held my chin up and my back straight, and I had never in my life come down my own stairs like that.
The living room went quiet before we got there. The TV was off. Somewhere a clock was ticking that I had never noticed before.
From the landing I could see the back of Steph’s head on the couch, the little navy cardigan shaking, and Dad’s big hand going up and down between her shoulder blades like she was a baby he’d been told to burp. Mom stood in the doorway with her arms crossed under her chest, locked tight, like a door with the bolt thrown.
Brian went to Mom first. Of course he did.
I couldn’t hear most of it. I got Mom, and his hands on her face, and the low, easy voice he’d used on me, the one that makes your knees decide things without asking you. Then the house got quieter, or he got louder, and I heard: “—woman of this house. No one’s taking that.”
It landed in my stomach, quick and hot. A pinprick.
Woman of the house. He’d said it up there too, to me, in the other voice: Mom can have the kitchen. I knew what the title meant now. It meant a pot and a ribbon and an apron, for people who weren’t getting anything else. I knew that, and I still stood on the stairs with my hand on the rail and watched her fold.
Her forehead went to his collarbone. Her arms came uncrossed. His hand slid down the gingham, over her butt, slow, and stayed there, and she let out a breath I could see travel through her whole body, like a phone being set on a charger. Her eyes closed.
Then they opened again. Over his shoulder. Right at me.
It was a very short look. It was the hardest look I’ve ever had from my mother, and I’ve been getting looks from her since I was in diapers. You, it said. You little—
I gave her nothing. I looked at her like you’d look at a chair.
Something went across her face. Then Brian’s hand moved, and she shut her eyes again.
When he let her go he went straight to the couch and crouched in front of Steph, with his back to me. I could see her over his shoulder: the smeared mascara, the wet, blotchy face, her two hands disappearing into his. I only caught pieces. Nobody’s mad at you. Tea.
She looked so small. Something in my chest gave a funny little twist, and I didn’t know which side of the twist I was on.
Mom watched them go into the kitchen with the face of a woman reading a bill. The kettle started. I stood in the middle of the carpet with my arms at my sides and Mom six feet away, and for a long time the only sound was the clock.
“Fix your top, Valerie,” she said at last, in her teacher voice, without looking at me.
“No.”
It came out calm. It surprised us both. She turned her head, finally, and I looked at her with my chin up and my hands very still, and I waited for her to say something.
She didn’t. Her mouth opened a little. Then she walked past me into the dining room and started setting the table, with a great deal of noise and her back so straight it shook.
Dad was still on the couch with his hands between his knees. He gave me a tiny, helpless smile.
“You okay, sweetheart?”
“I’m fine, Dad.”
“He’s not angry, you know,” he said, very quietly. “He told me. He said you were just upset.”
“Dad.”
“I’m just saying.”
“I know.” I sat down next to him. I leaned my head on his shoulder, and he put his arm around me, carefully, like I might go off. His shorts were pink and satin, and the apron smelled like garlic. It was the most normal thing that had happened all day.
Dinner was at seven. Nobody had to call us twice.
Dad had made lasagna, enough for twelve. He brought it in with a rooster on each hand and set it down in front of Brian like an offering, and then he just stood there until Brian said thank you. What his face did at the thank you I’d rather not describe.
We sat almost where we always sat. Brian at the head. Mom on his left, chin on her fist, aimed at him like a satellite dish. Dad down at the far end, in Brian’s old seat. Steph on the right side of the table, in the plaid, with a napkin spread over her lap as if it could do something about the rest of her.
Then Brian stood up and pulled out the chair on his right.
“Val.”
It was the chair that had always been empty.
I sat down in it. I felt Mom’s eyes slide from the chair to me to him, and her jaw lock, and I looked at my napkin instead. My hands were shaking, so I put one on top of the other. Under the table, Brian’s knee found mine and stayed.
That put Steph one seat down from me, with her elbow almost in my plate. Close enough to smell: soap, and a little sweat, like she’d been running.
Mom asked her about work in her Aunt-Linda’s-divorce voice. Steph answered with her mouth and nothing else. Brian said something about a table by the window, and a few days turned into a few weeks, and I watched my sister’s whole face go soft and stupid, with her fork stopped in the air.
I looked at my plate.
I’d cut my lasagna into little squares and hadn’t eaten one. Dad kept getting up to refill the water jug, which was full.
I should be furious.
I went looking for it. The fire from the hall, the sick shaking. I turned over the whole afternoon like a coat pocket, searching for the place where it had gone.
It had gone somewhere. I couldn’t find it.
“Steph,” said Brian. “Sit up for a second.”
She sat up like somebody had pulled a string. I don’t think she knew why. He set his fork down and looked at her, at the red tie, at the blouse, at the plaid, slowly, the way a guy looks at a car he built himself.
“Val. Look at her.”
I looked.
She was right there, an elbow away. Mascara clumped on her bottom lashes. A smear of lipstick at one corner, where she’d been chewing it. The tie went up and down with every breath, too fast and too shallow, and under the napkin I could hear her knees knocking together. She looked like a rabbit at the vet. She looked like she’d either cry or catch fire, and honestly it could go either way.
Steph. My big sister. With her own stupid, perfect, wide-open face.
“Doesn’t she look good?”
“Brian,” Steph squeaked.
“Yeah,” I said.
My voice came out low and strange. It didn’t sound like mine. “She does.”
Her eyes flew to me and away. I felt my whole body go hot from the middle outward, quick and heavy, a fist closing between my legs. Oh no, I thought, and it wasn’t the same oh no as before. This one had a different shape.
I couldn’t look away. It was the tie, and how it moved. It was the blush. It was that she had no idea, none, what she was doing to the table.
I’d hit him for her. I’d hit him for this. For her red face and her ruined mascara and her little squeaks, and I was sitting at the dinner table with my thighs squeezed together and my face on fire, wanting to put my hand on her knee.
What is wrong with me.
Then I made myself look at the rest of the table.
Dad at the far end, in his satin and his apron, serving and sitting and chewing without lifting his eyes from the plate. Mom’s arm vanishing under the tablecloth to the elbow, and I didn’t need to look to know where it went. Brian at the head, calm as a king, with his knee still against mine.
And me.
It wasn’t anger. I kept waiting for it to be anger. It was the feeling I get when I’ve finished a full face and step back from the mirror, and every single thing is exactly where I put it. Dizzy and bright and pleased with myself, and a little scared by how pleased.
I did that.
Not all of it. But I was there. I cleaned the house. I put on the uniform. I carried the video, hand to hand, and I sent it to my friends with my own fingers. I’d said yes a hundred times, every time he asked, and every yes had been another stair.
Look at what we made.
“Brian,” I said.
It came out thin and shaking. My hand was white-knuckled on the edge of the table. I couldn’t stand it. I’d been wet since the second he said look at her, and now it had turned into something else, a hard, hot, pulsing need so big I thought I’d scream.
“Please. I can’t— Can I?”
He didn’t ask what I meant.
He took a sip of water. He set it down.
“Go ahead.”
He thought for a moment.
“You don’t have to ask me anymore.”
I pushed my chair back from the table.
“At least wipe your hands first, Valerie,” said Mom, mildly, without looking.
“She doesn’t have to,” said Brian.
“Of course.” Mom nodded, as if he’d just corrected her about the salt. “Sorry, dear.”
I shoved one hand under my skirt.
I didn’t go slowly. I couldn’t. Thong aside, two fingers, and I was so wet it was almost funny, and the first touch tore a sound out of me that wasn’t a word. The chair creaked. The tablecloth hid everything and nothing. Dad’s fork clinked. Somebody poured water. The whole room kept on being dinner at me, and my hand kept on working.
It was so good. All day, all week, I’d needed this, and I had only just been allowed.
Somewhere very far away, Mom asked Dad to pass the salad. Dad passed it.
Steph had stopped eating. She was holding her fork like somebody had handed her a live wire, staring at one square of lasagna she hadn’t touched in a minute. I could see her jaw working, and her knuckles going white, and I wondered if she knew what her legs were doing under the napkin.
She knows, I thought. She doesn’t know she knows.
My fingers went faster. I made a small, wet sound. Then another. It was getting hard to see.
Then Steph looked up. Just a second. Not at me.
At him.
I saw Brian look back. He’d been watching her for a while, with his fork in his hand and his small, steady smile, and now he was just glad she’d noticed. He wasn’t watching me. He wasn’t looking at me at all. He was looking at my sister, and he had been, the whole time I—
That was what did it.
I gave a high, broken cry and bent forward in my chair, and it hit me from the toes up. It went on a long time. I thought it might never stop. I saw spots. A fork scraped a plate somewhere, very far away. I rode it all the way down, shaking, and then I sagged back in my chair, panting, with my hand still tucked between my thighs and my eyes half closed.
All the tightness had gone out of me. All the wire. My whole face felt loose and soft, and I wanted to put my head down on the table and sleep.
“Thank you,” I whispered.
Not to the room. To him.
“Good girl,” said Brian. “Eat.”
I picked up my fork, and I ate.
Afterward we watched TV. I couldn’t have told you what. Something with a laugh track, strangers laughing at things we couldn’t see. Mom took the left side of the couch and I took the right, and Brian sat in the middle with an arm around each of us, like a man at a very strange drive-in.
Her head was on one of his shoulders. Mine was on the other. I could feel her heat through him, and smell her, vanilla with something sharper underneath. Her knee touched his leg. Mine touched the other. His fingers moved in my hair, slow, and I thought, two of us, and he still has room.
Neither of us said a word to the other. The air over the middle cushion was thick as syrup.
From the kitchen came running water, plates, Dad humming, and every so often Steph’s voice, very small, asking something I couldn’t catch.
At ten, Brian lifted his arm from my shoulders and stood. He went to the kitchen doorway and leaned in it.
“Steph.”
“Yeah?” She sounded about fifteen.
“Let me show you to your room.”
“I know where it is,” she said, and I heard her go red. “I mean. I’d like that.”
She came out drying her hands on a dish towel, with her face scrubbed pink, like a girl who’d washed it three times. She picked up her duffel. She went up the stairs first, and Brian went after her with one hand lightly at the small of her back, looking at the backs of her legs the whole way.
I’d have given a lot to know what she was thinking.
Mom didn’t move. Her eyes were on the stairs, and her mouth was shut so tight it had gone white.
After a minute, she got up. She turned off the TV. She went to her room without a word.
I stayed on the couch.
At twelve-thirty I was in bed with the lamp off and my phone an inch from my nose, in a group chat that had been running since dinner and was mostly Chloe.
Chloe: “ok i’m going to say something and nobody is allowed to be weird about it”
Yasmin: “That’s a terrible way to start a sentence.”
Chloe: “i keep thinking about the food court”
Valerie: “what about it”
Chloe: “BIG DICK ENERGY. about ur BROTHER. out loud. a kid dropped his fries”
Yasmin: “He did drop his fries.”
Valerie: “i said YOU said it”
Chloe: “i said he’s a creep. u said the other thing”
I smiled at the screen like an idiot. For a second it was the most normal night in the world: three girls, one chat, a joke about somebody’s brother.
Chloe: “do u think he actually does tho”
Yasmin: “Chloe.”
Chloe: “i’m just saying statistically”
Yasmin: “Go to sleep.”
Yasmin: “...”
Yasmin: “Why are you still typing, Val?”
Because my thumbs were hovering over the keys, and I knew. Yes. I know exactly. I had it this afternoon. None of it would fit in a chat window. I typed lol idk ew, which is what you type when you don’t have an answer, and I sent it, and I lay there feeling like a spy.
At ten past one, the floor creaked.
Not the stairs. Up here, in the hall: the one board outside the bathroom, which has been announcing everybody in this house since I was six. I stopped breathing. Him, I thought, and my whole body turned toward the door like a plant toward a window. He’d said I didn’t have to ask anymore. It hadn’t occurred to me that he might just come.
I was out of bed before I’d decided to be, and I had the door open an inch.
It wasn’t him.
It was a back. A gray T-shirt down to mid-thigh, hair flattened on one side, two bare heels. My sister was walking away from me down the hall on the outsides of her feet, the way you do in a house where you’re not supposed to be awake. She passed the bathroom. She passed Brian’s room, and I watched her head turn to the dark doorway and the made bed, and turn back.
Steph. Where are you going?
At the far end, a thin gold thread of light lay under Mom and Dad’s door. She stopped in front of it. Her hand went up and found the wall, flat, like someone steadying herself on a boat. I knew that hand. It was the same hand that had held a phone to my ear when I was fifteen and said, breathe, Val, I’m coming, where are you. It was telling her to turn around.
Turn around, I thought. Go to bed.
Don’t.
I honestly didn’t know which of us I meant.
She pushed the door.
I was already moving. Down the hall on my toes, skipping the loose board, because I know every one of them. By the time I got there she had slipped inside and left the door standing open a foot behind her, swinging slowly toward the wall, and she didn’t look back. I caught the edge with two fingers and slid in behind it.
The gap between an open door and the wall is exactly wide enough for a girl who played hide-and-seek in this house for eighteen years. I stood in it with my back against the cold plaster, the door’s edge an inch from my nose, and my heart going like a fist on a table. Through the crack at the hinge, I could see most of the room.
It smelled of Mom’s vanilla, and warm sheets, and something else, something I’d smelled on my own skin that afternoon. The lamp was on low. And on the dresser, tilted a little, the big mirror showed me the whole bed from an angle I was never meant to have.
Brian, against the headboard, with one arm around Mom. Mom, in the wreck of the blankets, with her face against his chest and her eyes closed. And my sister at the foot of the bed in her T-shirt, with her toes curled in the carpet, like somebody waiting to be told she could come in.
He didn’t look surprised. He just lifted the corner of the blanket on his other side. That was all. Steph made a small noise that I felt in my own throat, and crossed the room, and got in.
Mom’s right there, I thought, the way Steph must be thinking it. And then I looked at the mirror again, and I saw Mom’s face.
Her eyes were open.
Not wide. A slit, a line of wet shine under the lashes, watching the top of Steph’s head settle on Brian’s shoulder. She wasn’t asleep. She had never been asleep. She was lying with her cheek on her son, listening to her daughter’s feet cross the floor, and she was waiting.
My stomach dropped and tightened at the same time. I had no idea what that meant.
For a long while nobody did anything. Brian’s thumb moved in Steph’s hair. I watched her shoulders come down an inch at a time, until the whole line of her went soft. He whispered something. She whispered something back. And her hand, her dry, practical, sensible hand, settled flat on his stomach and stayed there, like she was holding on to a bannister. I counted my breaths. I got to forty. The wall was cold on my shoulder blades.
Then Steph’s breathing went long. Her mouth fell open against his collarbone. My big sister, who had not once in her adult life been seen sleeping in public, was asleep on my little brother’s shoulder with her mouth open, in our parents’ bed. It was the sweetest thing I’d seen all week. I got a lump in my throat. I was actually about to slip back out and leave them to it.
Then Mom moved.
She did it very slowly, the way you lift a full cup. Her hand, the one on his chest, slid down over his ribs, across his stomach, and under the blanket. Brian’s eyes closed. His head went back against the wood.
“Good girl,” he breathed, to the ceiling. I couldn’t tell which of them he meant.
The blanket began to shift. Brian turned his head and kissed my sleeping sister on the mouth, softly, again and again, until she made a sound and her eyes came open. She looked up at him. I watched her work out where she was, and whose arm was under her, and whose hand was moving down there under the cover, and I waited for her to scream.
She didn’t. She went scarlet, to the roots.
“Brian,” she whispered. “Mom’s—”
“I know,” he said. “Look at her.”
Steph turned her head. Mom was looking right back at her. No shame in it at all. A small smile, a mother’s smile, the one she gives you when you’ve finished your plate.
“It’s okay, honey,” Mom whispered. “Go on.”
I put my fist against my mouth.
Brian pushed the blanket down to his hips, and in the mirror I saw all of it: Mom’s slip strap hanging off her shoulder, her hand around him, working, slow and patient and sure, like she’d been doing it for years. Steph’s T-shirt dragged up to her ribs. Her bare stomach, rising and falling. Her white underwear. Brian’s other hand sliding down that stomach, over the white cotton, between her thighs, and Steph’s hips came off the mattress. She jammed her knuckles into her mouth. Her heels pushed the sheet into a ruck.
“Quiet,” said Brian.
She nodded frantically against her own fist.
I knew I should leave. Instead my back slid down the wall an inch, and my thighs pressed together, and I understood that I was not frightened at all. I was soaked. I was shaking with it. Every time Mom’s hand moved I felt it, and every time Brian’s fingers curled I felt that too, and I stood behind that door and watched my mother and my sister come apart on either side of my brother, and my own hand had already gone into the waistband of my shorts. I didn’t remember doing it. Two fingers, flat, against myself, and a sound in my throat that I swallowed just in time.
Not just heat, though. Under the heat there was something else, and it had a different taste.
His hand was in Steph’s hair. His hand was on Mom’s neck. Mom bent and kissed his stomach, and his chest, and Steph kissed his jaw, and he said something into her ear that made her whole body arch, and all of them were in that bed, all of them, so close together that there wasn’t any room for anybody else.
I’m his queen, I thought. I’m the one he—
I leaned too hard. My shoulder bumped the door, and the door tapped the wall, a small, dry knock, nothing, a house settling.
In the mirror, Brian’s eyes opened.
He didn’t look at the door. He looked at the glass, and found me in it, a girl-shaped piece of dark behind the hinge with her hand down her shorts, and his mouth curved. He smiled at me. Slow. Warm. Not even surprised. And then he winked, once, and turned his head back to my sister’s face, and went on kissing her as if I’d never been there.
I got out. I don’t know how. I slid along the wall and through the gap and down the hall in my bare feet, past the loose board, and I shut my bedroom door and leaned against it and had my hand back where it had been before I’d even reached the bed.
I didn’t ask. That was the strange part. I got on my back in the dark and I didn’t ask anyone, because I didn’t have to anymore, and I did it fast and hard, with the pillow over my face, picturing the mirror: Steph’s mouth around her knuckles, Mom’s open eyes, his hand in her hair. I came in under a minute, and it didn’t help.
Afterward I lay there with my heart going, and the sweat cooling, and my body perfectly, stupidly satisfied.
It was the other thing that was still awake.
I made myself look at it. It sat low under my ribs, small and sour and bright, nothing like the warm gold that Brian put in me. I had been touched all day. I’d been touched in the afternoon, and I’d been given permission at dinner, and I was the queen. I’d been told so. So why was I the one lying alone in the dark with my own hand, while my sister slept in his arms?
It was a mean little feeling, and it had my sister’s name on it.
I’d looked at Steph’s face in that mirror, the way it went when he touched her. And for the very first time in my life, I’d wanted it to be mine.
0 comments
No comments yet
The story has no discussion yet. Leave a note here when a branch gives you something to say.
No chapter comments yet
No one has commented on this branch yet. Add the first note above.