What happens next?

Monday with friends - Val's POV

Chapter 15

Valerie POV

Monday morning, Dad made pancakes.

I came down at seven, dressed for school, with my hair still wet. The kitchen smelled like butter and maple syrup. Dad was at the stove in the heart apron and the satin shorts, humming. Mom was at the table in the gingham, with her ribbon in and her lipstick on, and Brian was at the head of it with his phone propped against the juice jug and his glasses on, as if it was any other morning.

Which, I guess, it was. It was just that nothing was ever going to feel like an ordinary morning again.

I stopped in the doorway.

My chair, the one on his right, had Mom’s handbag on it.

“Oh,” said Mom, pleasantly, to the table. “I didn’t know anyone was using that. Sit anywhere you like, Valerie. It seems to be your week.”

I looked at the handbag. I looked at her.

She wasn’t looking at me. She was holding the coffee pot in both hands, with her chin up and her nostrils a little white, and I realized, with a flicker of something I couldn’t name, that she was scared. Not of me. Of the chair. Of what it meant.

“Mom,” said Brian.

He didn’t look up from his phone. He didn’t raise his voice. It was just one word, low, in the middle of the pancakes, and the pot in her hands stopped moving.

“Move your bag. Then pour Val’s coffee.”

Her jaw worked. For a second I thought she might say something. I watched her think of it, and swallow it. She lifted the bag off my chair and hung it on her own. Then she came around the table with all the color gone from her knuckles and poured, steadily, into the cup in front of me.

“Thanks, Mom,” I said, politely.

“You’re welcome.”

It was the coldest word I’ve ever heard in my life.

A stair creaked. Steph came in, in her long gray T-shirt and a pair of sweatpants that I recognized from my own closet, with her hair twisted into a knot, looking like she’d slept about four hours. She stopped when she saw us all.

“Morning,” she said. Her ears went pink. “I, um. Sorry. I overslept.”

“Sit,” said Brian. “Eat.”

She sat. She sat at the far end, beside Dad’s empty seat, and ate with her head down, like she was on a first date with a plate of pancakes. Every few seconds she looked up at him and away again. He ignored it, which was the cruelest thing he could have done.

“I have to go to my place today,” she said, finally, to her syrup. “Get some clothes. My laptop. The, um, charger.”

“Take your time,” said Brian. “Bring everything.”

“Thanks.” She hesitated. “You don’t mind?”

“It’s your home, Steph.”

She blushed so hard I thought she’d catch fire. Mom’s fork scraped her plate.

Brian reached for his juice. As his hand came back, his knuckles brushed my knee under the table, once.

“You have a day today,” he said, mildly, to the table. “Don’t you, Val?”

“Yeah.”

“Busy?”

“I have class. Then I’m having people over.”

“Good. Take the car.”

I turned to my brother, and my eyes nearly popped out of my head.

Did I hear him right?

“Can I? Are you sure, Brian?”

“Yes, absolutely. You deserved it.”

“Thank you, Brian,” I said, and hugged him. He looked down at me, and for a second I felt like kissing him.

What am I thinking?

I went back to my chair and took a sip of coffee. I felt Mom’s eyes hot on the side of my face. I put my cup down very carefully, because my hand wasn’t quite steady, and I was smiling.

Being the queen might not be that bad.

“Okay, you’re being weird,” said Chloe.

It was almost noon, between Anatomy and lunch, in the hallway of the science building, where there’s a vending machine that never has what it says. Chloe had her arms crossed. Yasmin was leaning against the wall with her backpack over one shoulder, picking at the ends of her hair. Neither of them had said a word about the mall. Neither of them had said a word about Brian.

They’d both been looking at their phones all morning.

“I’m not weird,” I said.

“You’re smiling at nothing.”

“I got a lot of stuff yesterday,” I said. “Like, a lot. Primer, the contour palette, the whole eye set. And I was thinking we could do the tutorial. For real. At my place. After class.”

Chloe’s head snapped up.

“Today?”

“Yeah.”

“At your place,” said Yasmin. She touched her hair. Her voice was perfectly dry. “At your house.”

“My room.”

They looked at each other. Just for a second. Not a long look. But I saw it: the flash across both faces, quick and bright, and gone, like two kids hearing a bell.

“Sure,” said Chloe, too fast. “Yeah. Fine. Whatever. I mean, I have a lot to do, but.” She shrugged. “Is your brother going to be there?”

“What?”

“I’m just asking.” She uncrossed her arms and crossed them again. “Because it’s weird. If he’s lurking. He’s creepy.”

“He’s always home,” I said. “He doesn’t really go anywhere.”

“Ah,” said Yasmin.

“Okay,” said Chloe.

“Okay,” I said.

I watched them go off to lunch together, not talking, walking just slightly too far apart, each carefully not looking at the other. I stood in the hallway with a bottle of water I’d forgotten to open.

Don’t tell them anything. That’s what he’d said. Just get them in this room.

I didn’t know what he was going to do. I only knew that he’d asked.

They got to my house at four.

I’d tidied up. I had set out the whole haul on the bed: the palettes, the brushes, the little sponges in their wrappers, a mirror leaned against the headboard. I had put on a soft pink sweater and a short skirt, and no bra, and nobody had said a word about it, because nobody else was home. Mom and Dad were at work. Steph’s car was gone. Chloe came in first, in her usual hoodie, with her red hair loose. Yasmin followed her, in black, with her boots in her hand. She’d taken them off at the door, which she never does.

“Your room’s so clean,” said Chloe.

“Yeah, I—” I stopped. I cleaned it. “I was in a mood.”

“Sit down,” I said. “I’ll show you the thing.”

It was nice, for a little while.

It was actually nice. That’s what I keep thinking about. For about forty minutes, it was just me and my best friends, in my room, with the radio on low, trying to blend a highlight into Yasmin’s cheekbone while Chloe sat cross-legged on the carpet and read the eyeshadow names out loud in a voice. “Burnt Mango.” “Midnight Regret.” “Sad Girl Summer.” Yasmin said it was a perfect name for her entire personality. We laughed. I sat on the bed with my legs folded and a brush in my hand, and I thought, for God’s sake. Be normal. Just for an hour.

But they didn’t quite look at each other. And every few minutes, one of them looked at the door.

It was almost five when it opened.

No knock. It just opened, slowly, with a little click of the latch, and Brian was standing in the doorway.

He was naked.

Not exactly. He had a towel around his hips, a white one, low, knotted at the side, and his hair was wet and pushed back and he wasn’t wearing his glasses. A line of water ran down his chest. He leaned on the frame with one arm up over his head and looked at the three of us with an easy, lazy, sleepy smile, like a man who’d walked into the wrong room and wasn’t sorry.

“Oh my God,” said Chloe.

“Brian!” I said.

“Hey, ladies.” He yawned. “Am I interrupting?”

“What the hell,” said Chloe. She was on her feet, red to the hair. “What the hell are you doing? Get out! Oh my God, you’re such a perv, put some clothes on!”

“Seriously,” said Yasmin, dryly, with her hand in her hair. “This is a house with a lot of women in it.”

“It’s my house,” said Brian.

“It’s my room.” But I couldn’t find the rest.

He looked at Chloe, and then at Yasmin, and then, very briefly, at me. And he took hold of the knot at his hip, and pulled.

The towel fell.

“Are you insane?” I said. It came out as a shriek. “Brian! What are you doing?”

He didn’t answer me. He stood there, completely bare in the doorway, and didn’t even look at his towel on the floor.

“Look at your friends, Val,” he said.

I looked.

Chloe had stopped talking. She’d stopped in the middle of a word, with her mouth still shaped around it, and her arms had come uncrossed and gone limp at her sides. Yasmin’s hand was frozen in her hair. Neither of them was blinking. They were looking at him, at the middle of him, and their faces had gone strange and smooth and empty, like two girls in a church.

I had never seen anyone look like that. I knew exactly what it was.

They were gone.

It was my brother’s cock. I looked at it, too, because there was nowhere else for my eyes to go. Thick, and heavy, and half hard, curved a little to one side, as if it didn’t even have to try. It was just there. And my two best friends, who had spent the last four years telling me what a loser he was, stared at it like it was the only thing in the world.

“What’s the matter?” said Brian, gently. “Chloe. Cat got your tongue?”

“You’re such a—” Her voice cracked. “A creep.”

“Am I?” he said. “I’m the creep? Who’s the one staring at her best friend’s brother’s cock and can’t look away? Is it me?”

I saw how Chloe’s face went completely red.

“And you, Yasmin? Still think I’m a loser?”

There was a very long silence.

“Unfortunately,” said Yasmin, faintly, “no.”

He came in. He pushed the door shut behind him with one hand, and the latch clicked, and he walked into the middle of my room, slowly, with his cock swaying, and stood in front of the two of them. He took it in his hand. He stroked it, once, lazily. They followed it with their eyes like they were being hypnotized.

“So what is it?” he said. “What’s so interesting? I’m just curious. I thought I was the creepy loser brother of Valerie.”

“I—” said Chloe.

“What?”

“Can I—” She was breathing like she’d been running. Her hands had started to shake. “Can I touch it?”

“Please,” said Yasmin, at the same time, low and fast and ragged. “Please, Brian, I’ll— at least let me kiss it. Just once.”

They looked at each other, appalled, both of them, as if they’d been caught eating out of the same dish. Then they looked back at him.

“Can I suck it?” said Chloe. “Please. Please. I’ve thought about it all day. I thought I was losing my mind.”

I was sitting on my bed with my back against the headboard and my knees up. I couldn’t move. My hand had gone down between my legs, under the skirt, all on its own, and I didn’t stop it. I didn’t have to ask anymore.

They’re my friends.

It didn’t help.

Nobody was looking at me. They had forgotten that I was here. I sat in the corner of my own bed, in my own room, with my fingers on my own clit, and I watched my friends beg, and my heart was banging against my ribs, and my head was full of noise.

Look at them. They’re so desperate. That’s what I looked like. Yesterday, at the table. That’s how I looked when I asked him.

Is that how I look?

“I can’t give it to both of you,” said Brian, kindly. “You know that, right?”

“What?” they said, at the same time.

“It’s a very precious cock. It’s very rare. I don’t just give it away.” He tilted his head. “There’s only one. So. If you want it, you’re going to have to compete.”

I’d been expecting that. I’d known, somewhere. But the look on their faces was something else.

It was like watching a switch turn. Both of them stopped. They turned and looked at each other, and something came over them, a new, cold, bright thing, and I watched it spread.

“Obviously me,” said Chloe.

“Excuse me?”

“Obviously.” She flipped her hair, which only made it fall back over her face. “Look at me, Yas. I’m fun. I’m easy to be around. I laugh at things. A guy like Brian doesn’t need somebody sitting there with her arms crossed, judging his game collection.”

“I don’t judge his game collection.”

“You called it a shrine to arrested development.”

“It is.” Yasmin didn’t raise her voice. She never does. She lowered it. “But I’d sit next to him while he played. That’s the difference. He doesn’t need an audience, Chloe. He needs somebody who can sit in a room with him, in the quiet, and not need the radio on.”

“Oh my God, you’re so pretentious.”

“And you’re loud.”

“Boys like loud!”

“Boys like loud for about a week.”

They had stopped looking at him. They stood toe to toe in the middle of my rug, like two cats in a hallway, and my brother, naked, with one hand lazily around himself, watched them with the face of a man who’d bought a ticket.

“Don’t mind me,” said Brian. “Please. Go on. I’m learning so much.”

Four years of sleepovers. Four years of face masks and movie nights, and the two of them had been keeping score the whole time.

“He’s looked at me before,” said Chloe. “You know that. At Val’s birthday, last summer. I wore the yellow bikini, and he stood at that grill for an hour and burned two burgers.”

“He burned them because he can’t cook.”

“He burned them looking at me!”

“Eleven seconds,” said Yasmin.

Chloe blinked. “What?”

“At Christmas. By the stairs, when I took my coat off. Eleven seconds.” She said it flatly, with her chin up. “I counted. I told myself it was anthropology.”

Chloe’s mouth had fallen open. Brian was smiling at the ceiling.

Eleven seconds. I’d been in the room. I hadn’t seen a single one of them.

“Okay, so he looked at you,” said Chloe, recovering. “He looks at everyone. And anyway, it’s not about looking. It’s about what he’d want. In bed. He’d want someone who actually enjoys it, who gets into it, who isn’t just there taking notes. No guy wants a girl who treats sex like a seminar.”

“I know how to fuck, Chloe.”

She said it so quietly. She didn’t even blush.

“I know exactly how to fuck. I’ve done it. A lot. I know what to do with my hands, and my mouth, and the rest of me. I know how to make it last, and how to make it stop. If he wanted to be careful, I’d be careful. If he didn’t, I wouldn’t need telling.” She turned her head, finally, and looked at Brian. “He wouldn’t have to teach me anything. So if this is about who’s better for him, it’s me.”

Silence. My brother’s hand had stopped moving.

Wow. That was a lot I didn’t know.

“Fine,” said Chloe.

Her voice shook. She’d gone red from the collar up, and her hands had balled into fists at her sides, and I saw her do the thing she does at the edge of a pool, a little breath, a little lift of the chin, before she jumps.

“Fine. Okay. I haven’t.” She wasn’t looking at Yasmin. She was looking at Brian. “I haven’t done it. I’m a virgin. I’ve never— with anyone. Ever.”

Yasmin looked at her, confused.

“You told me about Dan,” said Yasmin faintly. “You told me, in Bio.”

She told me too.

“I made him up! I made up Dan, in Bio, on spring break, I made up all of it. I thought you’d think I was... I don’t know, not mature enough, if I was still a virgin. But that’s—” She swallowed.

“That’s better. Isn’t it? For you? That nobody’s ever touched me. That it’d be you. Only you, first and last. I’d be all yours, Brian. Guys like that. I know they do. You’d like that, wouldn’t you?”

She stood there waiting, like a girl waiting to be handed back her test.

“Chloe,” said Yasmin.

“I don’t care! I don’t care that you know!” She was nearly crying, but her eyes never left him. “Tell her. Tell her it’s better.”

Brian looked at her for a long, long time. He let it stretch. Then he smiled, slow and warm.

“I do like that,” he said.

I watched it go into her. Her shoulders dropped, and her whole face opened, like she’d been given a gold star in front of the entire school.

I even won at this.

I almost laughed at myself.

Don’t be so mean, Val. She’s just like you were two days ago. Remember that.

Honestly, I didn’t know which of them I was more surprised by.

“Not a skill, though,” said Yasmin, dry and cold. “Never having done anything isn’t a skill.”

“It’s not supposed to be a skill! It’s—”

“A reason to pity you. Not to pick you.”

“Shut up, Yasmin.”

“I didn’t say anything.”

“You were going to.”

They both turned, helplessly, back to Brian, who had been watching with the face of a man at a really good play. He tilted his head. He looked at Yasmin. Then at Chloe. Then at both of them, one after the other, pleased.

“Wow,” he said. “This is going to be fun.”

I sat there with my hand in my underwear and my mouth open. I’d known Chloe since we were babies. I had never, in my life, known that. And Yasmin. Quiet Yasmin, with her dry voice and her boots, who had never said one word about anyone in two years.

“Okay,” said Brian. “That’s enough. Both of you, shut up.”

They shut up.

“If this is going to work, we’re going to do it properly.” He strolled over to the desk chair, turned it to face the rug, and sat down in it, bare, with his legs spread and his cock standing up against his stomach. “I’m going to give you instructions. You follow them. I score every round, one point each, and whoever’s ahead at the end gets to go first.”

“Score,” said Yasmin. “Like a rubric.”

“Exactly like a rubric.” He smiled. “Don’t worry. I’ll be fair. I just won’t be nice.”

“Round one. Say it.”

“Say what?”

“I’m a pervert, and I want Brian Hartley’s cock.”

“No,” said Chloe, immediately. “No way. I’m not saying that to you.”

“Okay.”

He didn’t move. He took himself in one hand and gave it a slow, deliberate squeeze, and it jerked once against his palm, and the two of them made the same small sound.

“I’m a pervert,” said Chloe, “and—”

“And I want Brian Hartley’s cock,” said Yasmin, at the same time, pale and tight-lipped. “Happy?”

“Louder.”

“I’m a pervert, and I want Brian Hartley’s cock.”

“Louder. Look at it while you say it.”

“I’M A PERVERT, AND I WANT BRIAN HARTLEY’S COCK!”

They were practically screaming this time, and they were looking at his cock with so much devotion that it was like watching people pray. Their god was a cock. My brother’s cock.

“Better. Now tell me what else you are. Specifically.” He stroked himself, slowly, and his eyes went to Chloe. “You first.”

“What... what else?”

“The truth. You’ve been pretending for years, haven’t you?”

“I-I don’t— I don’t know what to say. Wh-what am I supposed to answer?” Chloe was red from head to toe, a mix of embarrassment and horniness. If I knew Chloe, her ego wouldn’t let her say what Brian was asking.

“What are you?”

Chloe’s face crumpled. She looked down at Brian’s cock again. Her ego was crumbling in front of a cock.

“I’m a liar,” she whispered. “I lied about all of it. I act like I’ve done everything, and I’m—” Her voice cracked. “I’m so wet I can feel it. I’m embarrassed, and I’m so wet, and I’d do anything.”

“So what are you?”

I saw her stop breathing for a second. It was costing her something to say it.

“I’m just a horny virgin who acts like a slut.”

“Good girl. Yasmin.”

Yasmin was looking at the carpet. Her hand was in her hair.

“I read Camus so nobody will notice I’m soaked through my jeans,” she said. Her voice didn’t wobble. That was the horrible part. “I act like I don’t care, because if I cared I’d look like her. Like this. On my knees. I’m exactly like her.”

“So what are you?” Brian asked her, the same question again.

“I pretend to be a stuck-up bitch but I’m actually a slut.”

Chloe turned her head slowly and stared at her.

“Point to Yasmin,” said Brian. “Steadier. And I didn’t have to ask her twice.”

“That’s not fair,” whispered Chloe. “She didn’t even blush.”

“That’s the point.”

I was sitting against my headboard with my knees up, and the mirror I’d leaned there for the tutorial was tipped just enough to show me all of it from behind: the two of them kneeling on my rug, the curve of their backs, the pale strip of Yasmin’s neck where her hair had fallen forward, and in the middle, Brian’s hand, moving like a metronome. My fingers had found the same rhythm. I hadn’t decided that. It was just the only speed in the room.

“Round two,” said Brian. “Come here.”

They started to get up.

“No.” His voice was mild. “On your hands and knees.”

Chloe’s head came up. “You can’t seriously—”

He lifted one finger off his cock. She went down so fast her palms slapped the floor.

They crawled. Across my rug, side by side, elbows bumping, past the jar of brushes, which Chloe’s knee sent skittering. Yasmin’s hair fell in a black curtain across her face. It was four feet. It looked like a mile. I watched the black jeans sway over Yasmin’s hips, and Chloe’s hoodie ride up her back, and I watched Chloe realize, halfway across, that she was ahead, and speed up.

“First one to my foot kisses it,” said Brian. “The second one watches.”

Chloe’s competitive streak really showed in this one. She was on his foot the moment he gave the signal.

She kissed his foot, hard and fast and so eagerly that she nearly toppled over.

“Someone seems to be enjoying this more than I expected,” said Brian.

That made Chloe even redder, if that was possible.

But he hadn’t told her to stop, so she kept going, again and again, up the arch, over the knob of his ankle, her lips shining, a thin whine in the back of her throat.

I knew this Chloe. This was the Chloe from the swimming club, the one who hates losing more than anything.

Yasmin knelt beside her with her fists on her thighs and her jaw so tight that a muscle jumped in it.

“Beg for the other one,” said Brian.

“What?”

“My other foot. If you want it, ask.”

Yasmin shut her eyes. “Please,” she said, stiffly. “May I kiss your other foot.”

“Do you think you deserve my foot, asking like that?”

Yasmin looked surprised, and sorry, like somebody who had hurt a friend without meaning to.

“Please, Brian. Please. Let me kiss your foot. I’ll do it better than her.”

“I’m doing it fine!” said Chloe, into his ankle.

“Lick it,” said Brian, to Chloe. She did, from heel to toes, with her tongue flat and her eyes rolled up to find his, glassy and grateful. “Good. Say thank you.”

“Thank you,” said Chloe. “Thank you, Brian. Thank you for letting me.”

“Point to Chloe. One to one.” He lifted his other foot and set it against Yasmin’s mouth, and she kissed it, finally, with her eyes closed and her cheeks scarlet, slowly and carefully and furiously. “Don’t worry, Yas. You’ll get to kiss my feet again another day.”

“Th-thank you, Brian,” said Yas, between licks.

I bit down on my lip. One hand was moving under my skirt, and the other had a fistful of quilt, and I was breathing through my teeth. I could feel how wet I was. I could feel it on my fingers. I’d watched my best friend lick my brother’s foot and thank him for it, and I was soaked.

“Round three,” said Brian. “Stand up. Strip.”

“All of it?” said Yasmin.

“All of it. I want to know what’s up for grabs.”

Chloe’s hands were shaking so badly she couldn’t get her jeans open. Yasmin stood the way she does everything, unhurried, as if she were alone. She pulled her black top over her head, folded it, and set it on the desk.

“Folding,” said Brian. “Cute.”

She dropped it on the floor.

They stood side by side on my rug in their underwear: Chloe in white cotton, with a little bow on the hip, and Yasmin in black lace I’d never have guessed she owned. Chloe’s arms went across her chest, and she bent forward a little, trying to disappear into herself.

“Arms.”

“I—”

“Arms, Chloe.”

She dropped them. She was crying, a little, without sound, and her nipples were hard under the cotton, and she didn’t make a single move to hide it. Yasmin stood with her hands at her sides. She didn’t look at him. She didn’t cover anything.

“Everything,” said Brian. “Off.”

The bras went first. Then the rest. Chloe stepped out of her panties like she was stepping out of a pool, and she stood there, pale and freckled, with her red hair all over her shoulders and her thighs pressed tight together, and a dark shine already on the inside of one of them. Yasmin was longer, darker, almost severe, and perfectly still. Two naked girls in the middle of my room, in the orange light, and I’d known them for years, and I’d never once seen them.

Brian got up. He walked around them slowly, the way you walk around a car you’re thinking of buying. He didn’t touch them. Not yet.

“Hands behind your heads. Elbows back. Stick your chests out.” They did. “Chloe. Look at that. All that red hair on your head and not a hair anywhere else. You planned for this, didn’t you? Every morning in the shower, in case someone ever looked.”

“I—” She made a choked noise. “Yes.”

“A virgin who shaves for a man who doesn’t exist.” He flicked one of her nipples with his finger, lightly, and she gasped and nearly came off her heels. “And now he exists. Isn’t that lucky?”

“Yes, Brian. Thank you.”

“Yasmin.” He stopped behind her. He put one hand flat on the small of her back and pushed, just slightly, until she arched. “You stand like you’re waiting to be told where to put yourself. Do you know that? You’ve been standing like that for years.”

Her breath caught. It was the first sound she’d made that wasn’t a word.

“Now show me how much you want it. Both of you. Spread yourselves with your fingers. I want to see.”

“Brian—” said Chloe.

“Do it.”

They did. Chloe first, with her eyes squeezed shut and her face burning, two fingers pulling herself apart. Yasmin, a moment later, slower, her hand moving down her own flat stomach and her eyes locked on the wall. He crouched in front of them. He looked. He put two fingers against Chloe, and she let out a sound like she’d been stabbed, and he drew them away, wet, and held them up to the light.

“Soaked. You are dripping down your legs. Do you like this? Answer me honestly.”

Silence.

“I-I really don’t—”

Brian leaned in and put his face close to Chloe’s.

“Are you sure? Because this—” He slid his cock against her stomach, and then lower, between her thighs, right where she was wet.

Chloe started moving against his cock.

“—is saying otherwise.”

I watched Chloe’s face, and I could swear I saw her mask crumble.

“Y-yes. I-I love this.”

From where I sat, I could see that even her butt had gone red.

“That’s what I wanted to hear,” said Brian, finally stepping away from Chloe.

“You really are a pervert.”

Chloe kept grinding against nothing for a few seconds after Brian moved.

“Now you, Yasmin.”

He touched Yasmin the same way, and she shuddered all the way up her spine.

“You’re wet too.”

“Thank you, Brian,” she said, in a really sultry voice, one I didn’t know she could make. “I really like it when you touch me.”

Brian smiled and stared at her for a second.

“Are you pretending?”

“No.” She said it with total confidence.

“Are you sure?”

“Because I think you said you know how to fuck. And maybe, just maybe, you think that a girl who knows how to fuck will tell me whatever I want to hear.”

In the mirror I saw the panic on Yas’s face.

Was she really pretending? She was good at it.

“But it always works,” said Yas, “and, and it’s only because I want you to feel that you’re making me enjoy it.”

Brian got closer to Yas.

“That was because you were with lesser men,” said Brian, walking around her.

“When you’re with me, you don’t need to pretend. Are we clear?”

Brian stepped closer, and from where I sat I could only see his back, but I was pretty sure he was grinding his cock against her ass.

“I have this,” said Brian, sliding his cock between her cheeks.

Yas started grinding against him, and in the mirror the pleasure on her face was unmistakable. She moaned as Brian held her tits.

“Are you pretending right now?”

“Noooo,” said Yas, between moans.

“Exactly,” said Brian, and stepped away from Yas.

She dropped to her knees instantly.

He walked around and stood in front of her, his cock right above her head.

“Will you lie to me again in the future?”

“No, Brian. I won’t,” said Yas, from the floor. “I’ll do better.”

“What are you?”

“A slut,” said Yas, in a tiny voice. “I’m your slut, Brian. A slut who lied to you.”

“Point to Chloe,” said Brian, mildly. “She answered honestly the first time. Two to one. Round four.”

He went back to the chair and sat. His cock was standing straight up, flushed dark, a small bright bead at the tip, and neither of them could stop looking at it. Yas got to her feet, and I could still hear her breathing. I could hear the radio, still playing, very low, something about summer.

“Kiss each other.”

Nobody moved.

“Not a peck. Properly. Yasmin leads. Whoever moans louder gets the point.”

“But I’m not gay!” said Chloe.

“And that is important because...?” Brian asked, smiling.

“Please, Brian,” she pleaded. “Anything else.”

“So… kissing my feet is okay, letting me pet your pretty little pussy is okay, but kissing your friend a little is where you draw the line?”

He got her, I thought, as I teased my clit.

Chloe was already turning. She didn’t argue.

She was trembling, from her shoulders down to her knees. She stood in front of Yasmin with her face turned up and her mouth open a little, like she was waiting for a pill, and Yasmin looked at her, for a long moment, with an expression I couldn’t read. Then she put a hand in Chloe’s red hair and kissed her.

It wasn’t gentle. Yasmin kissed like she did everything, with total concentration, her head tilted, her tongue slow and sure, and Chloe whimpered into her mouth and went onto her toes. Yasmin’s other hand slid down Chloe’s back, over the curve of her ass, between her thighs, from behind, and Chloe’s whole body jerked. The moan that came out of her was long and cracked and shameless. It filled my room. It was the loudest thing I’d ever heard, and she didn’t even try to stop it.

Yasmin didn’t make a sound. She kept her mouth on Chloe’s, and her fingers moved, and Chloe sagged against her, a boneless, shaking weight, saying oh and oh and please into her mouth. In the mirror I could see the two of them from behind: the long dark back, the white one, their two heads fused together. Yasmin’s fingers, glistening.

“Enough,” said Brian.

Neither of them stopped.

“Enough.”

Yasmin took her hand away. She did it slowly, and Chloe nearly fell. She held her up by the elbows. Her own lips were red and a little swollen, and for the first time her eyes were unfocused, the way they’d been when she’d first seen him. She looked at her fingers. She put them in her mouth, without thinking. Chloe watched her do it, and made another sound.

“I thought you weren’t gay, Chloe?” said Brian. “Were you always secretly a lesbian?”

Chloe was on the floor, panting.

“Point to Yasmin,” said Brian. “I liked how she handled our little ‘I’m not gay’ girl. Two to two.”

Silence.

Then he stood up and looked at me.

“Val,” he said. “What should be next?”

Everything stopped.

It was the very worst moment of my life. And the best.

Both heads turned. Both. Slowly, with their mouths open, like people in a horror movie who have just heard the floor creak. Chloe’s eyes went wide. Yasmin’s went to my hand.

“Valerie?”

“Val?” said Chloe. Her voice cracked. “You’re— you were— oh my God. You’ve been there? The entire—”

They’d forgotten me. That was all it was. They had been so busy, so focused, so absolutely hungry, that they had forgotten they weren’t alone in the room. And now they were looking, at my hand under my skirt, at my flushed face, at me sitting there on my own bed, wet and wide-eyed, with my lipstick smeared, like something they’d never seen.

Chloe’s hands flew to her chest. Yasmin took a step back.

“Relax,” said Brian.

They froze.

“Relax. It’s fine.” His voice was warm. “Val’s here because I want her here. She’s my servant. And she’s my queen.” He smiled at me. “She does everything I tell her. And you do what she says.”

“Your queen?” Chloe said. It came out as a strangled laugh.

“Mm-hm.”

I waited for them to argue. I waited for Chloe’s arms to cross.

They didn’t. They stayed where they were, naked on my rug, with their faces open and strange, and then, one at a time, I watched them relax. Slowly, like someone letting out a breath. Chloe’s hands came down. Yasmin’s shoulders dropped. They looked at me not like I was Val, their friend, but like I’d turned into a thing in a story. A queen. A girl with a crown on.

It’s hard to explain what that felt like.

“So,” said Brian. “What do you think, Val? What would you like to see?”

My mouth was dry. I couldn’t think. I could only think of Mom this morning, and the handbag, and Steph last night in the hall. I thought of the staircase. I thought of every stair. Everyone in my life who had ever told me what I could and couldn’t do. My right hand.

What do I want?

It was so easy. I didn’t even have to think. It came up from somewhere low and hot, the part of me that had begged in the doorway on Saturday.

“I want one of you to lick my ass,” I said. “And the other one my pussy.”

Silence.

Then Chloe said, “What?”

“Oh my God,” said Yasmin.

“Val. That’s disgusting.” Chloe was staring at me, scarlet. “I can’t believe you— I never— I never thought you had— Ew. Oh my God. You’re sick.”

“I thought you were normal,” said Yasmin faintly.

“You can say no,” said Brian. He said it very gently. “Of course you can. But then there’s no cock.”

Nobody moved.

It was the longest ten seconds of my life.

Yasmin moved first.

She crossed my room naked and unhurried, with her hair hanging down her back, and got onto the bed. She knelt in front of me and looked up, once, with her dark, steady, unreadable eyes.

“Take it off, Val,” said Brian, from the chair. “Let them see their queen.”

My hands were clumsy. I pulled the pink sweater over my head and dropped it off the side of the bed. I pushed down the skirt, and my underwear with it, and kicked them away. I hadn’t been naked in front of either of them since we were nine and ran through a sprinkler. Now I sat against my own headboard with my knees apart, and my best friend in front of me, and Chloe on the rug, staring up at me with a face I couldn’t read, white and wide-eyed and trembling.

“Wait,” said Chloe. “Wait, I—”

Yasmin lowered her head.

I gasped. I couldn’t help it. Her mouth was warm and soft and sure, nothing like I’d have guessed from Yasmin, and her tongue went right to the place I needed it, without hesitation, like she’d done this a hundred times. My back arched. My hand went into her hair.

“That’s not fair,” said Chloe, from the floor. She was white. “Wait. That means I have to— I get the ass? She got the— That’s completely unfair!”

“It’s your fault for starting late,” said Brian.

“That is not—”

“Chloe.”

He didn’t even look at her. He just moved his hand, and she shut her mouth.

“Two to two,” he said, to me. “Which makes you the judge, Val. You break the tie. Tell them how.”

It went through me like a current. The judge. I looked down at the dark head moving between my legs. I looked at Chloe, kneeling at the foot of my bed with her arms wrapped around herself, naked and shivering, with her red hair in her face.

“Come up here,” I said.

My voice shook. It came out steadier than I’d expected.

She came. She crawled up the mattress on her hands and knees, past my feet, and I hooked my hands behind my knees and pulled them toward my chest, so I was open to both of them. Chloe knelt there, with her face level with the lowest part of me, and her breath came out in short, ragged puffs. She didn’t touch me. She just looked.

“I can’t,” she whispered.

“Ask,” said Brian.

“Please, Val.” She was crying again, quietly, her eyes huge. “Please let me. Please.”

“Let you what?”

“Let me—” Her voice caught. “Let me lick your ass.”

“Louder.”

“Let me lick your ass. Please.”

“Okay,” I said.

Her tongue was tentative, at first, hesitant, a flick, then a long hot swipe, and she made a high, mortified, helpless little sound, like it hurt her to want it this much. And she kept going. I pushed back against her mouth, and Yasmin hummed against me in front, and the two of them, together, from two sides, with their hair spread across my thighs, did something to me I didn’t have a name for.

“Slower, Yas,” I said, and she slowed. I heard myself say it. I heard my own voice, low and breathless and sure, and I couldn’t believe it was mine. “Chloe. Use your whole tongue. Don’t stop. Don’t you stop.”

She didn’t. She moaned into me, and I felt the vibration all the way up my spine.

The mattress dipped. Brian was kneeling beside my head, hard and flushed, with one hand in my hair, and he turned my face and kissed me, deep and slow, his tongue sliding into my mouth. I moaned into it. I reached for him blindly and took him in my fist, thick and hot and slick against my palm, and he groaned.

“That’s it,” he whispered against my lips. “That’s it, Val. Look at them. Who’s better?”

“I can’t—” My eyes had rolled back. “Both. I can’t tell. They’re both—”

“Good.” He was smiling. I could feel it. “That’s the answer I wanted. Tell them what they are.”

“Mine,” I said. It was out before I’d even thought it. “You’re mine.”

Chloe sobbed. Yasmin made a sound I’d never heard from her, rough and shaken, and her mouth got harder, faster, and Chloe’s tongue pressed deeper, and something rose in me from far below, fast and hot and unstoppable, like a wave with no bottom.

I came with a cry. My hips lifted off the bed. I pulled his cock in my fist, hard, and my other hand fisted in Yasmin’s hair, and I didn’t let go, and they didn’t stop. They kept on going, both of them, through the whole shuddering length of it, until I finally gasped, “Stop,” and they stopped.

I lay there, panting, with my knees still pulled up and the room ringing.

“Look at me,” said Brian.

He wasn’t talking to me.

He knelt up over the two of them, with my hand still wrapped around him, guiding it, and I looked down past my own stomach and saw them. Chloe’s red hair. Yasmin’s black. Two faces, side by side, with their mouths wet and shining, tipped up to him, wide-eyed, desperate, lost.

“Look at me.”

He came.

It hit them both. It went across Chloe’s cheek and her mouth, across Yasmin’s eyelid and her lip, in long hot ropes. One landed on my thigh. Chloe cried out. Yasmin shut her eyes. And then, as if they’d been given a signal, they were licking, the one off her own mouth and the other off her cheek, frantic, whining, their tongues going over each other’s faces in a hurry, the way you’d lick up something spilled before it was gone.

I’m not sure when I came again. It might have been then.

When it was over, there was nothing but breathing.

Brian sat back on his heels, flushed, with his hair in his eyes. He ran a hand through it and looked down at the two of them, kneeling on my bed, naked, with semen on their chins and tears on their cheeks.

“Well,” he said. “That was a good start.”

They stared at him. They looked as if they’d just woken up.

“This isn’t over,” said Brian. “I haven’t decided yet. I’m going to give you a week.” He got up off the bed and bent down for the towel. “A week to convince me. And Val. Which one of you deserves it. Which one is willing to give more.”

“A week,” said Chloe, faintly.

“It’s going to be a fun one.”

He wrapped the towel around his waist. He kissed me on the forehead, once, in front of them, like a prize, and walked out of my room, and shut the door.

Nobody said anything for a long time.

Then Chloe put her hands over her face. “Oh my God,” she said. “Oh my God, oh my God, oh my God.” Yasmin wiped her mouth with the back of her wrist. She was looking at me. She wasn’t angry. It was worse than that.

“Valerie,” said Chloe, through her fingers. “What the fuck.”

“I—”

“You told him that. Your idea! You said— in front of him— you made us—” Her voice broke. “I can’t believe you.”

“I didn’t—”

“Yes you did.” Yasmin’s voice was low and very cool. She’d found her shirt. She was putting it on, slowly, with her back to me. “You did. I’d like to know why.”

I didn’t have an answer.

It was true. That was the thing. It was my idea. It had come out of my mouth, in my own voice, because he’d asked, and it hadn’t even felt like a question. And I sat on my own bed, with my own mess on my own thighs, and looked at my best friends dressing in silence, and it hit me with a slow, sick, clear little lurch that I had done that to them.

I’d wanted to.

That was the worst thing. That I’d wanted to.

“I’m sorry,” I said.

“Don’t.” Chloe wasn’t crying anymore. She yanked her hoodie over her head, and her hair came out in a static halo, and she wouldn’t look at me. “Just. Not right now. We’re not talking about this.”

“Obviously,” said Yasmin.

They picked up their bags. They left the brushes on the carpet. At the door, Yasmin stopped, with her hand on the frame, and for a moment I thought she’d say something. Her fingers were in her hair.

Then she went out, and Chloe went after her, and I heard them go down the stairs, not talking, a foot apart.

I stayed on the bed.

The room smelled like sweat and sex and lip gloss. The light had gone orange again. I lay on my side in the middle of the mess, naked, with the sheet kicked half over my legs, listening to the front door shut, and I felt very small and very old at the same time.

The door opened.

Brian came in, still in the towel, with a glass of water in one hand. He sat down on the edge of the bed and held it out to me, and I drank. It was cold. My hand shook against his.

“They hate me,” I said.

“No, they don’t.”

“Chloe said—”

“Chloe said what she had to.” He took the glass. “It’s a hard thing, Val. It’s the first time. It’s going to feel like that, at first.” He stroked my hair back from my forehead. “You did really well.”

“Did I?”

“You said exactly what I needed.”

I looked at him. “Was that—” I couldn’t say it. “Was that a test?”

He didn’t say anything. He just smiled, a little, and pushed a loose piece of hair behind my ear.

“I want to ask you something,” I said.

“Go ahead.”

I sat up. My heart was going fast, in a different way now, cleaner. Clearer. I’d been thinking it all afternoon, I realized, sitting on that bed. I’d been thinking it while they begged. Some part of me, the old Valerie, the one who ran the relay and the team, had been doing arithmetic.

But I didn’t say it. Not yet. I didn’t want to feel small anymore. I wanted to feel like the person who had said what I’d said.

I let the sheet slide off me, and I put my hand flat on his chest, and I pushed.

He went back onto his elbows, and then onto the bed, and let me. One eyebrow went up. That was all. He lay across the foot of my bed with the glass on the nightstand, and watched me climb over him, a knee on each side of his hips, naked in the orange light, with Yasmin’s mouth still on me like a handprint and his mess drying on my thigh. I pulled the towel open.

He was already stirring against his stomach, as if it had been listening.

I’m in charge, I thought. It was a strange thought. It didn’t feel borrowed.

I took him in my hand. He was warm and heavy and still slick from earlier, and he hardened in my fist while I watched, with his breath changing. I stroked him slowly, base to tip, and I put my other hand between my own legs, and I looked right at him while I did both. I didn’t have to ask anyone.

“Two years,” I said. My voice came out low. “Chloe told everyone she’d done it. Yasmin told everyone she knew how. And neither of them got this.” I tightened my fist, and he let out a breath. “They begged, Brian. On my floor. And they went home with a mouthful and nothing else.”

“Is that what you’re thinking about?”

“That I’m the one who has it.” I rubbed my thumb over the tip, once, and his stomach jumped. “Out of all of us. The cock that nobody else gets to have. Not Chloe. Not Yasmin. Me.”

“Val.” He was smiling, but his eyes had changed. He put both hands behind his head. “Go on. I’m watching.”

He wasn’t going to help me. I understood that, with my fingers sliding wet against myself and my other hand moving on him. He just lay back and waited, with the same bright, patient look he’d had in the doorway, like a man who had put a ball in play and wanted to see where it landed. He’s letting me. It made me even wetter.

I reached for the nightstand drawer, for the box he’d left there on Sunday. I rolled the condom down him myself, slowly, with both hands, and he made a low sound I’d never heard from him, almost a laugh.

I rose up on my knees. I held him against me, and I lowered myself onto him.

It went in slowly, all of it, inch by inch, and I stopped halfway to breathe. He didn’t push. His hands stayed behind his head. A muscle in his jaw jumped. “Val,” he said, a little unsteadily, and I took the rest of him, and sat on his hips, full to the ribs, with my thighs shaking, and started to move.

Slow at first. Then not slow. One hand flat on his chest and the other between my legs, and nobody telling me what to do. That was the part I couldn’t get over. I picked the angle. I picked the speed. I made him wait, with my hips still, until his breath broke, and then I took him again. I watched his face come apart a little at a time, and every inch of it was mine.

“Brian,” I said, between breaths. “The swim club.”

“Now?” He was laughing, low and ragged. “Okay. Okay. What about it?”

“Amy. And Michaela.” I rolled my hips, and his fingers dug into his own scalp. “They’re the captains. Everyone listens to them. Everyone follows them. Amy’s dad is Mom’s boss.” Another roll. “If we had Amy, we’d have all of them.”

“Keep talking.”

“Amy’s been after me all semester. She keeps saying that, as women, we have to stick together, and she looks at me weird. And Michaela doesn’t like me.” I was panting now, and my voice shook with the rhythm. “She’s jealous. But if you got her first, I think she’d— oh. I think she’d fall apart. They’re right there, Brian. I see them every day. And I thought maybe I could—”

His hands came down at last. Both of them gripped my hips, hard. Not to take over. Only to hold on.

“Don’t stop,” he said. “Val. Don’t stop.”

I didn’t. I rode him, and the words fell out of me with every stroke, mine, mine, mine, and I couldn’t tell anymore whether I meant him or the whole afternoon. My back arched. My fingers worked. It rose in me again, impossibly, a wave on top of a wave, and I came around him with a cry, with my head thrown back and my hair swinging, and he followed me a second later, with a groan I felt all the way up my spine, his hands bruising my hips.

I came down slowly. I folded forward onto his chest, panting, with his heart slamming against my cheek.

After a while, I felt him looking at me.

I lifted my head. He had his head tilted on the pillow, and a strange expression on his face, as though I had handed him something in a box. Not a smirk, not a smile. Something stiller, with a flicker in it that I’d never seen.

“You thought of that?” he said. “By yourself?”

“Yeah.”

“Today?”

“Just now.”

“Huh.” He breathed out through his nose. He started to laugh, softly, and shook his head. “I didn’t see that coming. I’d been thinking about the coach. Not the captains.” He took my face in both hands. “That’s why you’re my queen.”

I felt it in my whole chest. It was a hot, helpless, shining feeling, like the first day I got the captain’s band.

“So I can—”

“Think about how,” said Brian. “Give me a plan, and we’ll do it. You’re the one in the pool every day. You know them so I want something really good and really sexy.” He kissed me, quickly, on the mouth. “Good girl.”

He eased me off him, dealt with the condom, and tied the towel back around his hips. At the door he stopped, with his hand on the knob.

“Clean up, okay?” he said. “It’s a bit of a mess in here.”

Then he was gone.

I sat there on my bed, in the orange light, with the brushes all over the carpet and a jar of sponges rolled under the desk. There was a wet spot on the sheet. A pair of Chloe’s sunglasses had been left on the windowsill, and the mirror was crooked against the headboard. The whole room still smelled like them.

I got up.

I started with the brushes.

Start your own immersive adult AI roleplay story
Ad

What happens next?

Back Start Over View Story Map

0 comments