Back Together for Debrief

“You smell like Shane,” Rhia laughed, burying her face in the back of Elyse’s hair and taking a big whiff.

“Well, I only had my soap and shampoo upstairs,” I said. “I keep the lady stuff down here in case a guest needs it.”

“I like it,” Elyse said with a grin, pulling a lock of her hair around and giving it a sniff. “It’s like wearing his sweater and smelling him on it, except I’m not stealing his clothes.”

The girls had brought a vegan lasagna this week, along with homemade sourdough bread and a chocolate pudding for dessert. The funny thing about the whole dinner was that the state of undress around the table had felt totally natural. Elyse and I had headed upstairs completely naked and sweaty, so she’d come down equally naked after I’d dried her with a fluffy towel upstairs. She’d slipped on her ‘robe’ from her Renee costume but hadn’t even bothered to tie the belt, the silky black material frequently slipping to reveal a nipple or peek lower as we sat at the table.

Rhia had put on a bra and thong panties, but both of them were half see-through so she wasn’t exactly covering up. Tori, still surprising me with how cavalier and daring she could be when she wanted, went topless and just wore her baggy costume pants low on her hips. I’d almost felt overdressed, wearing a pair of athletic shorts.

The casual nudity was even more casual than I’d ever hosted for The Game. Tantalising costumes had occasionally come up, especially for games hosted on Halloween or other holidays. And there was that year I ran a Christmas One-shot and the ladies all dressed up as sexy Christmas Elves. But usually, things were about the game. This all felt… extra.

Good extra, but still extra. Different.

“Are we going back to the game after we clean up?” Tori asked, giving a stretch that had her utterly perfect breasts lifting tantalisingly. Her little hopeful grin and glance towards the backyard were cute as hell. “Or… I’m just saying, the hot tub is right there.”

I chuckled and shook my head. “We can hot tub if you ladies want to hot tub.”

It didn’t take much more than that to have me banished outside to get the hot tub space set up while the girls cleaned up the kitchen. By the time it was up to temp, they were parading out of my house and into the little enclosed area completely in the buff - and I got naked kisses from each of them as they passed me. Elyse was first, setting the precedent, throwing her arms around my neck to pull me down into a quick, close-lipped kiss as she grinned. Then came Rhia, who stuck her tongue out playfully before going on her toes and giving me a peck on the lips while her full, heavy breasts grazed against my chest. Tori was last, biting her lip and smirking a little, and she put two fingers on my jaw to ask me to come down to her. Tori’s kiss was the deepest, a little bit of tongue teasing against my lips before she danced away and climbed up the stairs and into the hot tub.

With a shake of my head, I slipped my shorts down and immediately rolled my eyes as Elyse gave me a wolf whistle.

Once we were all settled under the hot water and had gotten our comfortable groans of appreciation out of the way, Rhia laughed, spreading her arms out wide on the edge of the tub. This brought her chest up, her breasts bobbing in the water as she gave us all a playful smirk. “So what took you guys so long in your shower upstairs?” she asked.

“Just doing our check-in,” I said. “Which I hope you two actually did as well?”

“Oh, we’re good,” Tori said. “I mean, Rhia’s my little bitch now, but-”

“I am so not your bitch,” Rhia snickered. “You’re gonna need to be way better with a strap-on before I take on that role.”

Tori stuck out her tongue at her, making us all laugh.

“Seriously though,” I continued. “Did you get some time to cool down and make sure you’re good?”

“We did, Dr Sex-pert,” Rhia said. “But you’re avoiding the question.”

“Oh, we checked in,” Elyse grinned, then bit her lip and gave me steamy eyes for a moment. “And it was really good.”

“Oh my God, you two totally fucked again,” Tori said.

“What’s shower sex like, I’ve never done it but I feel like it would be hot?” Rhia asked excitedly.

“Well, we didn’t have sex-sex,” Elyse said. “After we did our check-in I might have gotten on my knees and started sucking him off, though.”

“So I’m the only one who hasn’t blown you today?” Rhia asked me with a look in her eye.

“That wasn’t all we did, though,” Elyse said. “Once he covered my face in cum and then washed it off me he had me stand up and kissed me so good while he fingered me. Then he pushed me against the wall of the shower and got behind me and ate me from behind like a fucking demon. I swear, it felt like his tongue was huge. And he even ate my ass a bit.”

“Fuck, that’s hot,” Tori sighed. With the lights on and the jets off I could tell that both she and Rhia had dropped hands down to their pussies underwater and were playing with themselves.

“How hard did he make you come?” Rhia asked.

“Well, I came three times,” Elyse grinned. “The first one was while he was eating me, and then the second one was while he was tonguing my butt and fingering me. The third one…” she blushed, giving me another one of those steamy looks. “Well, let’s just say that our Shaney has a really creative, dirty mind and he knew just what to whisper in my ear while he fingered me with one hand and spanked my ass with the other.”

“That sounds so fucking hot,” Rhia groaned, dropping her other hand beneath the water to join the first between her legs.

“Why not fuck, though?” Tori asked.

“Because shower sex isn’t that great,” I said. “Playing in the shower can be lots of fun, but actual sex? Even if you make sure you’ve got all the best gription and handholds possible, you’re still combating cramped quarters and worrying about slipping. And then there’s the fact that water isn’t that great for natural lubrication and can make it not feel great - and counteracting that with water-resistant lube just makes the ‘slip and hit your head’ risk worse.”

“Well there goes one sex bucket list item,” Rhia chuckled.

“Not for me,” Tori snickered. “I want the Elyse treatment as soon as I can get it.”

“Hey, it’s my turn, you both got to go,” Rhia grinned, sliding from her seat and starting to cross the hot tube towards me.

“Hold on, Rhiannon,” I said, putting out both my hands to stop her. “Despite the wonders of you three hanging around half and fully naked, I’m still two decades older than you three. I’ve already popped three times tonight and I’ve got to be able to function tomorrow morning. We should try to pace ourselves.”

Rhia blew out a breath that turned into a bit of a raspberry, giving me a pouty look.

“Aw, Rhia not happy,” Elyse said, putting on a cavewoman voice. “Rhia thinking of throwing Shane over shoulder and carrying him into cave for fucky-fucky.”

That made Rhia snort hard and smirk as she rolled her eyes and sat back in her seat. “Maybe I am, but if the old man is giving up for the night, I guess I shouldn’t break him.”

Truth be told, I could have probably gone again. I would have also regretted it in the morning - we’d overdone it plenty of times during extended scenes in The Game and over the years we’d learned our limits and when we were willing to go beyond them. The thing was, despite Rhia being the instigator of all this, and how utterly fucking stunning she was between her body and her sweet, sometimes sarcastic personality, I was still getting hung up on our previous relationship. So far the things we’d done had crossed lines, but not the line. Not penetration.

I just wasn’t sure what would happen, with me and with her, when that came around. And this wasn’t in the game, this wasn’t her character here in front of me in the hot tub, it was just her. That I wasn’t ready for.

“This ‘old man’ will remember that statement,” I replied with a little smirk of my own. “But one thing we all should talk about was how you three feel about the fact that you’ve participated in group sex for the first time.”

“That wasn’t group sex,” Tori said. “That was just… regular sex and lesbian sex within view of each other.”

I smiled a little and chuckled, shaking my head. “You might be surprised, having grown up with porn more accessible than my generation, that for most people that is group sex. Partners who aren’t usually partners having sex close to each other, able to watch and experience each other. Not all group sex is a big orgy where everyone does everything with each other.”

“That makes sense,” Elyse said. “I mean, I definitely was half-watching you girls while you were working through your scene. It actually helped me not get overwhelmed by me getting fucked by a werewolf with a giant cock.”

Tori coughed, covering her mouth with her forearm, and then grinned. “You mean Renee getting fucked by a werewolf?”

Elyse shrugged. “I’m Renee, and Renee is me,” she said. “I dunno, call me method or whatever, but the only reason I wasn’t totally lost in the idea of the scene was getting to watch you guys too.”

“No, I get that,” Rhia said. “Being your character and all. It’s like us talking in character instead of saying ‘Oliva says’ first. We’re improv acting and improv fucking. I know I was trying to be Olivia, even if I had Tori’s pretty face and sexy tits to look at instead of a hairy bandit lieutenant.”

“You’re so sweet,” Tori giggled.

“I liked the group element if that’s what we’re calling it. Knowing you guys could see us, and getting to see Elyse have her mind blown were both big turn-ons. I’m excited for my turn,” Rhia said.

“Well, I have to admit I was nervous getting things started, but nervous in a good way,” Tori said. “And I was more nervous about getting eaten out than I was about sucking your dick, Shane. I dunno why.”

“Because your cooch was out,” Elyse chuckled. “Sucking his dick, it’s his dick that’s on display and you’re just doing stuff to it. Him eating you makes you the centre of attention.”

“That might be it,” Tori blushed and shrugged.

“Well, just to throw it out there - and I feel like it goes without saying, but sometimes it’s important to say this kind of thing because it doesn’t get said enough - all three of you are gorgeous young women,” I said. “And so far the sex has been fantastic.”

“Damn straight,” Elyse grinned.

“What I mean is that I want you all to know I appreciate the bonus eye candy going on, but I feel very privileged to share some intimate moments with you,” I continued, shaking my head and chuckling at Elyse. “Tori, the mutual oral earlier was great. You kept character really well, and you were super sexy taking control of what you wanted. Great job on that. And your pussy is delicious, by the way.”

Tori barked a laugh, covering her mouth as she did it, not knowing how to react to that.

“Elyse… well, we already talked about it,” I said.

“Please, talk some more,” the blonde grinned at me. “Remind me.”

“Little brat,” I chuckled, making her scrunch up her nose and blow me a kiss. “I had a very good time getting my hands and lips all over your sleek, sexy body. And your tight little bratty cunt leaks golden ambrosia when I treat it right.”

“Mmmm,” Elyse moaned softly, closing her eyes. “See, I told you guys he’s got great dirty talk skills.”

“What’s better on the taste scale, ‘delicious’ or ‘golden ambrosia?” Rhia chuckled.

“Sounds like she peed on him to me,” Tori snickered.

“Not what I meant,” I said flatly.

“I did not pee on him,” Elyse stated.

I sighed as Rhia and Tori both broke into giggles, followed shortly by Elyse. The sounds of their laughter, three perfectly comfortable and sexually satisfied college-aged women, wasn’t a chorus I would have thought to ever hear again after my friends and I graduated from college ourselves.

It was really fucking great.

Breakthebar erotica is powered by Patreon,. PM if interested in making a Commission.