Ask Alan if his brother would be willing

All of this is moot, of course, if Alex is unwilling to participate. The mere thought of my boyfriend being in a group sex scene that could be watched by millions is an idea that I hadn’t considered. I mean, it’s not like we’re married or anything, but I’m not sure I like the idea of him screwing someone else while he’s dating me. Then again, it worked for Mom and Dad, so who knows?

I look at Alan and ask, “What do you think? Would Alex even consider it? He’s never said anything to me about wanting to be a porn star. Trust me: the subject usually comes up when guys date me.”

Alan gives me an amused look, and I can tell that he’s choosing his words carefully. “I think he might be open to the idea,” he says. “After all, he’s always been the more adventurous of the two of us in that department.”

“Adventurous?” My curiosity is definitely piqued. “What do you mean?”

“Well, I don’t know how much I should say… Let’s just say that if he agrees to do this, it wouldn’t exactly be our first time playing the twin switch-a-roo game.”

As his words sink in, I feel my jaw drop. “You mean….?”

Alan looks a little embarrassed, but he grins and says, “Yeah… We both started dating at about the same time, and Alex was the one who suggested that it would be fun to see if our dates could tell the difference between us.”

I study his face and say, “Well, there is a difference. It’s not huge, but I can tell the two of you apart.”

Alan responds, “It’s a little harder when the lights are low and we’re doing something other than having a pleasant conversation…. If you know what I mean.”

I ponder this for a moment. “You dogs! You each had sex with the other’s girlfriends? And no one noticed?”

“One time we got busted. And I blame my brother. We brought our dates home, and the plan was to do one round and then take a bathroom break and switch places. It would have worked if Alex hadn’t gotten confused and walked right back into his room just as I was going down on his girlfriend.”

“That’s horrible,” I say, although not entirely sure that I disapproved. For some strange reason, the idea of a double dose of my hot boyfriend really turned me on. “What happened?”

Alan weighs his response and then apparently decides that he’s said too much to hold anything back. “Well, fortunately, after the girls got over their initial shock, they warmed up to the idea, and all four of us ended up together in Alex’s bed.”

A thought suddenly hits you. “Wait a minute… Did you ever do the switch-a-roo with me?”

“Of course not,” Alan answers. His words sound sincere, but I notice that his eyes dart away from mine for a moment. I wonder if he is hiding something from me.