Ashley Vs. Lisa: Consolation Prize

Shell-shocked, Ashley found herself frozen, unable to act as her boyfriend, whose face she was still sitting on, came deep inside his ex-girlfriend’s ass. He had been licking her pussy but the intense pleasure of Lisa’s asshole bouncing on his cock, drawing out his seed, had made him forget about Ashley’s pussy completely. Had she lost Zack forever? Insensate, she simply watched as Lisa lifted her hips, Zack’s semi-hard cock flopping out of her ass with a sticky, wet pop.

Pensive and consumed with self-pity, Ashley didn’t realise Lisa was moving towards her until the other girl’s hands were upon her chest. Lisa pushed the blonde backwards until she landed flat against the mattress, lying along the bed above Zack. Ashley didn’t even fight her. She felt too numb and heavy to do anything. She simply lay there, staring at the ceiling, replaying the image of Zack cumming in Lisa’s ass over and over in her mind.

Then, the ceiling was gone, and it was dark as a golden, caramel skinned ass hovered over her face. Ashley could see the dark pink lips of Lisa’s pussy, wet with her arousal and dripping onto the blonde’s chest. Just behind those puffy pussy lips was Lisa’s well fucked asshole directly above Ashley’s mouth, flexing and winking at her.

"I know you're sad that you missed out on getting his cum," Lisa mockingly comforted her. "But if you want it, you can eat it out of me."

Ashley opened her mouth to protest but Lisa didn't give her an option, squatting down and shoving her gaping hole right against Ashley's lips. Her muffled protests were unheard against Lisa's asscheeks. She felt Lisa's asshole flex and then with a loud 'PRRRT' a sharp, sour gas hit her tongue, followed by a pouring out of Zack's cum. Globs of it slipped out of Lisa's anus and landed directly in Ashley's mouth. The taste was familiar, salty and manly as she'd come to expect from Zack. But there was a newfound tangy taste to his load that could only be a flavour added by Lisa's bowels.

As more of his cum gushed from her asshole, Ashley did her best to drink it all in. Though she hadn't wanted it, it was better take it willingly than **** on it, she decided. Or maybe it was because some part of her found it intensely hot that she was eating her boyfriend's cum from another woman's hole. Either way, she stuck out her tongue and pressed it against Lisa's asshole, coaxing out even more cum. Ashley was actually amazed at how much cum Zack had apparently sunk into Lisa's butt. The blonde knew her boyfriend was capable of cumming multiple times, the night at the hotel had proved that, but he'd cum so hard down her throat not so long ago that she couldn't believe he had this much in reserve for Lisa's ass.

The cascade of cum on to Ashley's tongue reduced to a dribble but Lisa could still feel remnants of Zack's cum clinging to the inside of her ass. She screwed up her face as she squeezed her insides, pressing the cum out. 'Pppwwwrrrppp' went her asshole again as it blew out air and cum simultaneously. The spew of cum splattered against the inside of Ashley's cheeks, followed by another torrent of the thick, sticky substance running from Lisa's butthole.

At the foot of the bed, Zack finally stirred from his orgasm hangover. His head was still a little fuzzy as he sat up and looked over his shoulder. He was surprised to see Lisa squatting over Ashley's face, more surprised to see that rather than her pussy it was her asshole pressed against his girlfriend's mouth and surprised even still to see that same girlfriend willingly lapping up his cum from her anus. His eyes travelled down Ashley's body, admiring his girlfriend's hot, sexy body, as if he'd ever forgotten. His gaze came to rest between her legs, where her tight, thin pussy lips sparkled with her desire. It was only then that Zack remembered he'd been eating her out when Lisa had taken his cock in her ass. He'd completely neglected Ashley and that hadn't really been fair of him, no matter how mad he was.

He turned around on the bed and crawled up between Ashley's legs, sliding his knees under hers. Sitting upright, he took his cock in his hand, still quite stiff and rubbed the head along Ashley's labia. With his other hand, he pressed his thumb just above, where the hood of her clit sat. Ashley moaned into Lisa's ass as Zack teased her pussy. With circular strokes, Zack played with Ashley's clit as he took his hardening cock and pressed the tip against her wet pussy. She was so horny, so **** to be fucked, Zack could practically feel her pussy sucking his cock in. With the head inside, he pushed with his hips, his shaft sliding deep into Ashley's little kitty with ease. Once he was sheathed in her pussy to his hilt, ball pressed tight against her ass, he began moving in and out, pumping her pussy with his cock.

The room filled with a mixture of wet, fleshy sounds; the sloshing of Ashley's pussy every time Zack's cock sank deep inside her, her gasping, gargled moans with a mouth full of cum straight from Lisa's bowels caused by Zack's thumb teasing her clit, the wet farting sounds of Lisa's asshole as it released the treasure trove of cum that had been shot deep inside and Lisa's own little moans every time Ashley's tongue slipped too far forward and lapped at the bottom of her pussy lips rather than her asshole all combined into an orchestra of sex and arousal.

“That’s it, ah, fuck, fuck her Zack,” Lisa cooed as Zack began thrusting into Ashley harder and faster. “Shit, you’re fucking her so hard I can feel her moving beneath me.”

Ashley could feel it too, but her mouth was too full of cum to say anything as her face was rubbed up and down Lisa’s ass. She felt Lisa squat down harder, grinding her ass back against Ashley’s face in time with Zack’s thrusting. Her nose squashed against Lisa’s tailbone and then her chin bumped against her pussy as she was pushed up and down the mattress unable to stop Zack and Lisa from using her body. Not that Ashley minded exactly. As hot as it was to eat her boyfriend’s cum from another woman’s ass, it felt even more intense and relieving to feel Zack’s thick cock sliding into her pussy. Her pussy had already been flush with her desire, a low hum leaving her itchy and frustrated. Then came along Zack’s cock to scratch that itch and fuck it felt good. To finally have it back inside her, filling and stretching her again. It was worth eating Lisa’s ass to feel this again, to feel what she thought she’d lost.

“Give it to her, ah, Zack, oh, fuck her nice and hard,” Lisa continued to encourage, as if he needed it. “Fuck her and give her a nice memory of how good your cock feels in her cunt. Cum deep inside her, this one last time.”

Ashley’s eyes went wide, though all she could see was Lisa’s ass rolling back and forth over her face. This couldn’t be the last time. Ashley didn’t want to never feel this cock again. She was still his girlfriend, right? But Zack couldn’t hear her thoughts and at Lisa’s behest, his fucking had become more frantic, more frenzied. And the battering of his cock into her soaking wet pussy sent shivers up her spine. Bolts of pleasure that numbed her to the worries of the status of her relationship and flooded her brain with blissful, blinding happiness. Her skin prickled and her back arched, pushing her pussy hard against Zack’s penetrating member. She gasped and gagged as she struggled to breathe and swallowed as much of Zack’s cum in one gulp as she could.

Above her, while she drowned in her orgasm, Lisa bent over as she reached up and cupped Zack’s face. “This is what your girlfriend wants. Give her what she wants. Cum inside her. One. Last. Time,” Lisa said, echoing her own words from earlier. And just like earlier, Lisa punctuated the statement with a kiss, their mouths meeting as Zack continued fucking his girlfriend who was still convulsing against his cock.

With the encouragement of Lisa, the silky hot feeling of Ashley’s sloppy wet pussy squeezing his cock and the incredible lewd wrongness of the situation, Zack couldn’t not come. The tingling in his balls was already near bursting and after a few more strokes he felt the dam break. His cockhead opened and spewed out cum, the dregs of what was left in his spent body after having cum twice with the two women already. Nevertheless, his cock spurted forth as much of his seed as he could muster deep inside his girlfriend’s unprotected cunt, all the while kissing his ex-girlfriend.