Anya shows up

Then the basement door opened again and Anya started walking down the basement stairs.

"Hi, Hallie," said Anya. "Hi, Buffy. Hi, er -- Willow."

"That's Mistress Willow," said Dark Willow. "But you can call me Dark."

"Whatever," said Anya. "Anyway, I'm glad you're here, Hallie, because -- What the hell!"

Anya pointed at the rabbit that used to be Willow Rosenberg and asked, "What's a rabbit doing in here?"

"I think that rabbit used to be human," said Halfrek.

"Well, whatever it used to be, I wish it was that instead of a rabbit," said Anya.

Then she glanced at Halfrek and said, "Sorry."

Halfrek just gave Anya a dirty look and said, "Wish granted."

And just like that, Willow Rosenberg was no longer a rabbit but a human being. A naked human being.

"Er, guys, can I please have some clothes?" asked regular Willow.

"No," said Dark Willow.

"Er, wait a minute," said Willow. "My own demonic self is going to deny me clothing?"

"If you have to ask..." said Dark Willow.

"You're a demon?" asked Anya. "I thought there was something I liked about you. That and the whole not being a bunny thing."

"I'm not really a demon," said Dark Willow. "I just find pentagrams to be a convenient way to travel. Especially since you don't have to get undressed like you do with the usual magical portals."

"I hear you," said Anya. "That's one reason I used to be a vengeance demon. So that I could travel by magic from place to place without having to undress all the time."

"No, it isn't, Anyanka," said Halfrek. "You told me --"

"Quiet, Hallie," said Anya. "I'm talking to Dark Willow."

"Why are you here -- er -- Anya, is it?" asked Buffy.

"Yes, it is Anya," said Anya. "Anyway, how did it go with that wish, Buffy? The one that you were complaining to Willow -- er, the other Willow -- about."

"Wish?" asked Buffy. "What wish? Everyone keeps talking about this wish and I don't remember a thing."

"Ah, poor thing," said Anya.

"Wait a minute," said regular Willow. "Now you're showing her empathy? You never do that, Anya. As for that wish, that really needs to be reversed right now. In fact, I wish that --"

"Oh, I wish you'd just shut up and not say another word until I tell you to," said Dark Willow.

"Wish granted," said Halfrek despite herself.

And just like that, regular Willow found herself not just naked but mute as well.