Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 11 by AltUAuthor AltUAuthor

What happens next?

Allie goes all in

Allison's heart was pounding. She'd made out with a few girls in her college days, but never gone any further than that. She had a feeling that if she accepted this dare, things were going to go much further than making out. She'd never been so nervous... or excited. She'd kept telling herself she need to do more exciting things, but she'd never pictured anything like this. But this feeling, this nervous thrill... it felt great. Allison reasoned she had nothing to hide from Becky & Maya -- they had to have noticed her arousal, there was no way she could hide it. Every part of her mind urged her to accept the dare.

"All right, Maya, you're on," Allison said, anxious but enthusiastic at the same time. Becky & Maya's smiles widened in utter delight, and Becky gestured to Allison with a "come hither" motion with her hand. Becky sat back as Allison moved over her, and she smiled invitingly.

"We'll start with an easy one. First, I want you to kiss Becky's cheek," Maya instructed. Allison quickly complied, pressing her lips against the other woman's cheek. This feels good, Allison thought. Becky let out a tiny moan, heightening Allison's arousal even more.

"Nicely done. Now, her lips," Maya requested, a mischievous look in her eyes. Allison looked into Becky's eyes as she smiled in eager anticipation, and kissed her -- the kiss was tentative at first, then got deeper and more intense. It wasn't long before they were making out, Becky having snaked her hand around Allie's back.

She's an amazing kisser, Allie thought after Becky introduced her tongue. In fact, this is the best kiss I've ever had. Allison was now extremely curious to know if Maya was as good a kisser as her girlfriend; she had a feeling she'd find out very soon, though.

After the kiss ended, Allison & Becky turned to look at Maya, who had her hand between her legs, gently rubbing her clit. "That was fire, Allie. Love the enthusiasm! Now, kiss Becky's neck."

Allison eagerly granted Maya's request, planting kisses up and down the side of Becky's neck. Becky closed her eyes and moaned in appreciation, her hands beginning to explore Allison's body a little more.

"Wow. I know that moan," Maya said, extremely impressed. "Becky's hot now... You're doing an amazing job, Allie. OK, now kiss her breasts."

Becky eagerly undid her towel, leaving her completely nude once again in front of Allison. Allison lowered her head to Becky's chest, kissing her way around Becky's left nipple before planting a kiss directly on it, then doing the same thing to the right breast.

"Mmmm... that's so good, Allie," Becky cooed.

Still teasing her clit, Maya smirked smugly watching the scene in front of her. "You're a natural, Allie. You're so close to a perfect score -- all that's left now is to kiss my loving girlfriend's slit."

Allison's pulse went into overdrive, as her mind was overwhelmed with anxiety, excitement, and lust all at once. She'd never envisioned her mouth near another woman's pussy before... but the idea thrilled her. And she'd loved every moment of this dare so far. Making Becky & Maya so hot was intoxicating, like nothing she'd ever felt before.

With that mindset, Allie sunk down between Becky's legs, planting kisses up and down her slit. As she did, she noticed just how excited Becky was -- her pussy was soaked. This turned Allison on even more -- clearly both women found her appealing, which was such a welcome change from her last relationship. Allison heard Becky's encouraging moans, and entertained the thought of introducing her tongue to the mix.

No. Not yet, anyway. That wasn't part of the dare. But Allison knew it wouldn't be long.

Allison emerged from between Becky's thighs, grinning as she looked at Becky. Becky responded by pulling her in for a deep kiss, which Allison was more than happy to return.

"That was an A+ performance, Allie," Maya grinned lustfully, obviously delighted that Allison had accepted her dare so enthusiastically. "I think you've more than satisfied my girlfriend."

Becky sat forward and chuckled, "That's an understatement, babe. She's an incredible kisser. Wow."

"Now you've got me all curious," Maya teasingly pouted.

"Oh, you'll get your turn soon enough, I'm sure," Allison told Maya with a teasing smile.

"I'm gonna hold you to that," Maya said back, anticipation in her voice. "Right now, though, I'm pretty sure it's your turn. So, who's it gonna be, Allie?"

A thousand possibilities raced through Allison's mind...

Becky or Maya? Truth or Dare?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)