Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 17 by thecommanderis thecommanderis

What happens as the others return to the cabin?

A moment of weakness

Ashley felt the heat rise in her cheeks. She was pretty sure Zack had noticed her glances. She turned away quickly, pretending to be busy with a dusty bookshelf. The smell of his cologne lingered in the air, making it harder to focus. Her thoughts were a tangled mess, full of "what ifs" and "should I say somethings."

Zack, equally flustered, took a deep breath and tried to concentrate on his task. The memory of last night's encounter with Victoria was still fresh in his mind, the way she had looked up at him, her eyes wide with lust. And now, here was Brandon's girlfriend, her eyes filled with a similar hunger. It was confusing, but there was no denying the attraction. He tried to push it aside, telling himself it was just a fluke, but the way she had moaned his name in the shower this morning echoed through his mind, making his cock twitch in his pants.

As they worked together in the living room, the tension grew thicker than the dust bunnies they were trying to vanquish. The occasional accidental touch sent sparks of electricity through their bodies, leaving them both breathless. Zack's heart raced as he reached for the same cushion Ashley had grabbed, their fingers brushing against each other. He felt a sudden urge to pull her into a passionate kiss, but he held back, remembering their friendship and the potential consequences.

Ashley, on the other hand, was fighting a losing battle with her own desires. Her body hummed with the need to be touched, to feel the heat of his skin against hers. Every time they were close, she could feel her panties getting wetter.

The kitchen was the last room to be cleaned. As Zack washed the dishes, Ashley took the opportunity to lean against the counter, watching him. She couldn't help but imagine him naked, his muscles flexing as he moved, the water running down his body. Her hand drifted down to her thigh, her fingertips grazing the fabric of her shorts. She bit her lip to stifle a gasp when Zack's gaze met hers in the reflection of the kitchen window.

Zack felt a jolt of arousal at the sight of her. He knew he shouldn't be feeling this way about Brandon's girlfriend, but he couldn't help it. He turned off the faucet and dried his hands, the silence between them stretching like a tightly drawn bowstring. "Ashley..." he began, his voice thick with desire.

Ashley took a step closer, her eyes never leaving his. "I know," she murmured, "I know what you're thinking." She took another step, closing the distance between them.

Zack's cock grew hard in his jeans as he met her gaze. "What are you doing?" he asked, his voice barely above a whisper.

Ashley didn't answer with words. Instead, she reached out and placed a hand on his chest, her touch burning through the fabric of his shirt. She could feel the rapid beat of his heart beneath her palm. "I'm not sorry for what happened this morning," she said, her eyes searching his. "It was... amazing."

Zack's breath caught in his throat. He didn't know what to say. He was torn between his friendship with Brandon and the desire that was now raging through him like a wildfire. He swallowed hard. "It was," he admitted, his voice hoarse. "But, we can't..."

Ashley stepped closer, pressing herself against him. Her breasts pushed against his chest, and he could feel her nipples, hard and eager. "Why not?" she whispered, her hand sliding down to grip his hardening cock through his pants. "It's just us here. And I want you so badly."

Zack's resolve was crumbling. He knew it was wrong, but the way she was looking at him, the feel of her hand on his body... it was too much to resist. He leaned in, capturing her mouth in a fierce kiss, his tongue exploring her mouth.

Her hands roamed over his body, unbuttoning his shirt and sliding it off his shoulders. He groaned into the kiss as her nails dug into his back, pulling him closer. He could feel her breasts pressing into his chest, her nipples erect and begging for attention. He cupped them through her thin t-shirt, feeling them respond to his touch.

The kitchen counter was cold against Ashley's back as Zack's hands slid up her thighs, lifting her onto it. He stepped between her legs, her skirt riding up as she wrapped them around his waist. They broke the kiss for a moment to catch their breath, their eyes locked in silent understanding. This was happening. They both knew it was wrong, but they couldn't stop themselves.

Ashley's hands moved to unbuckle Zack's belt, her movements swift and sure. She pulled his jeans down just enough to free his cock, which sprang out, thick and eager. She took it in her hand, marveling at its size and heat. Her thumb circled the head, spreading the precum that had gathered there. Zack's eyes closed and his head fell back, a low growl escaping his throat.

He reached under her shirt and unhooked her bra, letting it fall to the floor. He took her breasts in his hands, feeling their weight and warmth, rolling her nipples between his thumbs and forefingers. Ashley's breath hitched, and she leaned back on the counter, her hands moving to Zack's shoulders to balance herself. He bent down, capturing one nipple in his mouth, sucking and biting gently, making her gasp.

Her hand stroked his cock, her other hand playing with his balls, feeling their heavy weight. Zack's breath was hot on her neck as he kissed and nibbled his way down her body. His hand slid under her skirt, finding her wetness. He teased her clit with his thumb, feeling it swell and harden under his touch.

Ashley's breathing grew ragged as she panted, "Oh God, Zack, please..."

out of her with a primal rhythm that seemed to shake the very foundation of the house. The sound of skin slapping against skin filled the room, mingling with their gasps and moans.

It was as if a dam had broken inside Ashley. Every stroke of his cock sent waves of pleasure crashing through her body, more intense than anything she had ever felt with Brandon. He reached so much deeper, filling her in a way she hadn't known was possible. She could feel every inch of him, stretching her, hitting spots that made her toes curl and her eyes roll back in her head.

Her legs tightened around his waist, urging him deeper, faster. She threw her head back, her long hair cascading over the kitchen counter as she lost herself in the feeling of his powerful thrusts. Her moans grew louder, echoing through the empty house. Zack's hand slid up to cover her mouth, muffling the sounds, but the passion in her eyes never wavered.

Their bodies moved in perfect sync, as if they had been doing this for years. Ashley's hips met every one of his thrusts, her pussy clenching around his cock like a glove. He could feel her getting closer to the edge, her muscles tightening around him, her breath coming in short, sharp gasps.

Zack's own orgasm was building, his balls drawing up tight against his body. He knew he couldn't hold out much longer. He reached down and pinched her nipples, hard enough to make her eyes widen in surprise and pleasure. She responded by grinding herself against him, her hips moving in a way that sent shockwaves through his body.

He felt her pussy start to quiver around him, her walls tightening even more. He knew she was about to come, and he wasn't far behind. He picked up the pace, driving into her with everything he had. "I'm gonna cum," he groaned into her ear. "I'm gonna fill you up."

The words were like a trigger for Ashley. Her body convulsed, and she came hard, her orgasm ripping through her like a storm. She bit down on his hand to keep from screaming out loud, her eyes squeezed shut. Her pussy clamped down on his cock, milking him, and he followed her over the edge, shooting his cum deep inside her.

They stayed like that for a moment, bodies entwined, breathing heavily. The only sounds were the distant calls of birds outside and the water still dripping from the faucet. Slowly, Zack pulled out of her, and she slid off the counter, her legs wobbly. They stared at each other, the reality of what they had just done crashing down on them.

"We can't let this happen again," Zack finally said, his voice tight with tension.

Ashley nodded, still trying to catch her breath. "I know," she whispered, even though she didn't fully believe the words herself. The way she felt right now, she wasn't sure she could ever get enough of him.

"Look, we can't deny that there's something here," Zack began, trying to keep his voice steady. "But we can't let this ruin our friendship. So, let's lay down some rules."

Ashley nodded, her cheeks still flushed with passion. "First rule," she said, "We never talk about this to anyone. Not Brandon, not Victoria."

Zack nodded in agreement. "Second rule," he continued, "We keep this strictly between us. No flirting or hinting around others. It's like it never happened."

Ashley's eyes searched his, the hunger still present, but a hint of sadness in her voice as she replied, "I can live with that." She stepped closer, her hand reaching up to caress his cheek. "But what about us? What happens when we're alone?"

Zack sighed heavily, his own desires warring with his conscience. He knew he couldn't deny the intense connection they had just shared, but he also didn't want to lose Brandon's friendship. "We'll... we'll figure it out," he said, his voice wavering slightly. "We'll keep it under control."

Ashley stepped back, nodding solemnly. "Okay," she said, though her eyes betrayed the doubt in her voice. "But I can't promise I won't think about this every time I look at you." She picked up her bra and shirt, slipping them on quickly, trying to cover the evidence of their indiscretion.

Zack pulled his jeans up and buckled his belt, his shirt still open. "We're adults," he said, trying to convince himself as much as her. "We can handle this. It was just... a moment of weakness."

Ashley nodded, her eyes lingering on his bare chest before she turned away to fix her own clothing. "Right," she murmured. "A moment of weakness." But as she tugged her skirt down, she couldn't help but feel the emptiness where he had just been.

What happens when everyone else returns?

  • No further chapters
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)