Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 58 by telaviv telaviv telaviv telaviv

"Is there a reward for being the best owner?"

A little one.

"I dunno, shouldn't we be upset that you didn't tell Veronica we're the best pets?" Ashley answers with a smirk.

"Shouldn't you be competing to see which of you would be the best of the best?" you shoot back.

"As if. If anything, we'll tie you up and **** the answer out of you."

"Wouldn't be the first time I'm tied up," you say with a wink to Tibby, who surprises you by blushing. Oh right, that was an emotional day for her.

"But seriously, I'm too tired for a big reward. Being a student and a pet has it's downsides."

"Don't blame that, I'm sleepy too," Tibby says with a little yawn.

"So am I," you admit. "But I don't remember asking for a big reward."

"Tell you what, carry me up to the apartment on your back and I'll see what I can do."

"Lazy!" Tibby complains. "Why didn't I think of that?"

"Well I'm not carrying you both," you say firmly.

"It's fine, I can still walk," Tibby admits. "But I feel like I deserve a little reward for that too."

"I'm sure we can come up with something that'll make everyone happy," you reassure the cat as the bus lurches to a stop at the edge of the park outside your apartment. Not the edge you live on, but you're only a brief walk from home now.

Before you start walking, Ashley turns to face you. "You didn't ask for a big reward, but I'm sure you don't want an itty bitty one either. So how about this?"

Taking a big step forward, she comes right up to you and plants a chaste kiss on your cheek. Her lips touch your skin for less than a second, then she backs off and grins at you. "On a scale of one to ten, how much bigger than that would you like your reward to be?"

"You already convinced me to carry you up to our apartment. If I ask for a ten you'll probably have me carry you from here to the apartment as well. And then I'd be too tired for anything! I'm going to play it safe and go with a five."

"Very calculating of you, like a real engineer," Tibby praises. "Right?"

You nod to let her know that engineers do indeed calculate things. "That does remind of something though. We need to take a selfie."

"What? Why, and how did this remind you of that?" Ashley asks.

"Because I don't have any photos where you're both kissing me on the cheek." When you get a skeptical look you add "It's a classic!"

"Oh all right. And it won't even cost you a reward point because I'm feeling generous. But you better hope Tibby feels the same way."

"I don't," the cat says. "If we're doing this, make my reward a six."

"You drive a hard bargain, but so be it," you acknowledge. "Let's sit on that bench over there."

The bench in question is just inside the park, close enough to the edge that it's in a nearby streetlamp's circle of light, and behind it is a fountain. There's no water in it anymore, but it should still make a nice backdrop. You sit in the middle of the bench and beckon to your girls, who pull their legs up on either side of you. Then, while you hold up your phone and look into its camera, they lean in and kiss your cheeks. You smile for the first selfie, pretend you're stunned for the second, and then laugh as you see Ashley and Tibby making obscene gestures behind your head.

"Ok, enough of that. Let's go home."

Your pets give you one more kiss each before they hop off the bench, dragging you with them. You cross the street and walk over to your apartment building. Once inside, you wait for Ashley to climb on your back and begin to ascend the stairs.

If your feet didn't hurt and you weren't getting tired this would be fun, you think as you plod up the stairs. And if I didn't have a whole flight of stairs ahead of me. But you persevere, encouraged by the sound of Ashley's warm breath in your ear... and the ability to peek up Tibby's dress as she rushes ahead so she can open the door for you.

Soon you reach your floor and put Ashley down outside your apartment's door. After a quick bathroom break, everyone storms into the bedroom and hops on the bed. "You really earned your reward master," Ashley giggles with a bounce. "Carrying me up all those steps without complaint."

"I thought about it," you admit. "But feeling your boobs on my back made it worth it."

"Liked that, did you?" Ashley giggles. "You want to feel them without my dress in the way?"

Instead of answering, you tackle the bunny and attack her dress, working it up her body while she shrieks with delight. Pulling the dress over Ashley's hips reveals a little white pair of panties, but you keep pulling and suddenly her tits pop free with nothing to hide them from your eyes. "You're not wearing a bra?"

"That's right!" she says, already grabbing your hands and putting then on her boobs. "Makes them easier to fondle."

Tibby watches, amused, as you go quiet and just sit there squeezing Ashley's boobs gently. "Those things are almost as magical as booty, huh? Want to see mine too?"

"Yes!" Ashley says at the same time you do, and you both laugh. Tibby just grins as she peels off her dress, pausing to show off the purple panties you caught a glimpse of on the stairs before continuing to reveal a matching bralette.

"Can't believe I'm dressed more conservatively than Ashley, but not for long." She takes off her bra and throws it aside, letting her breasts fall free. "Now only John is overdressed, let's get him out of those clothes!"

Your pets turn on you, working together to undo all your buttons while your hands roam their bodies freely. Your arms are **** up when they take your shirt off, but you get right back to it while they get to work on your pants. You're pushed onto your back as they pull your pants down your legs. Moments later your boxers follow suit, leaving you naked and erect.

The girls coo delightedly and wrap one hand each around your erection, slowly stroking it to full hardness. As their hands move together, their heads come down and kiss their way along your chest until they reach your face.

"This is a great start to my reward," you moan. "But Tibby earned one too. And you expect it to be a six out of ten, don't you kitty?"

Tibby just nods smugly.

"Then why don't you take those panties off and have a seat right here?" You point at your face, and Tibby scrambles to comply. Soon your head is between her thighs and you're probing her vag with your tongue, while she leans forward to lick your dick. A few seconds later Ashley adds her mouth to the mix, giving your shaft a tongue bath from both sides.

For a while Ashley and Tibby take turns sucking your cock. Ashley's sucking is slow and steady, while Tibby's is more erratic as you distract her with your own tonguework. But then both mouths leave you, you feel a weight shift, and suddenly your cock is inside something hotter and tighter. It slides down your length, pushing further and further down until you feel Ashley's legs rest on your hips. She just sat on your cock!

Tibby says something you can't understand with your head beneath her, but it sounds like she's scolding Ashley. Rightly so since this reward is supposed to be for you and Tibby! Undeterred, Ashley plants her hands on your chest and starts rocking her hips, which grinds her clit against the base of your dick.

When you reach back to smack her ass, Ashley just laughs and speeds up. Tibby says something else, then begins to rock as well, which makes you realize you've stopped licking her pussy. You make up for it by plunging your tongue up into her and wiggling it around inside her, after which she settles down again. As you keep eating Tibby out, you smack Ashley's ass a few more times.

Ashley yelps, and really starts bouncing on you. Wasn't she tired earlier? Perks of letting you carry her around, you guess. It doesn't last long though. After less than a minute of riding you like this, she sits down hard and her pussy clamps shut around you, milking your cock for all it's got while Ashley groans loudly. You moan too, your balls twitching as you unload inside her.

Ashley remains seated like that for a while, her vagina pulsing gently as it holds onto your shaft while one of her hands caresses your chest. Then she lifts up and rolls herself off you, landing on her back by your side. You keep licking Tibby's cunt for a few minutes, until she orgasms as well and crawls off you.

Your head finally free, you can talk to Ashley. "Stealing rewards you haven't earned, Ashley? Don't you know what happens to pets who misbehave?"

She smirks at you from your left. "Around here? They have a lot of fun with their tied-up master, or so I hear."

Tibby snorts. "You had your fun. Now can you handle being made to edge for hours as punishment?"

"Hours!?" Ashley exclaims. "I heard what you two did on your second day together but there's no way it took hours. John isn't that patient."

"Guess you'll find out tomorrow," you tell Ash with an evil grin. "Now go to sleep."

What awaits tomorrow?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)