Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 5 by Coy-toy Coy-toy

What’s the surprise?

A girl opens the door

To your surprise, the person who opened the door for you wasn’t Nathan, but a drop dead stunner of a woman. Standing over a head taller than you, wearing a thin black dress that ended just above her knees, and wavy brown hair that flowed past her shoulders, she certainly would stand out in any crowd.

“Hello!” She says, reaching out a hand in greeting. “You must be Scott! Nate has told me so much! I’m Beth, his girlfriend.” You shake her hand, surprised at her strength that causes you to wince slightly. “Nate had invited me and my friend over for game night, I hope you don’t mind!”

You greeted her and said you were happy, wondering slightly when he started dating her, and if she knew about the photos you had seen last week. She led you in, where you saw Nathan in his tiny kitchen getting snacks and drinks ready, and another girl in his living room on his couch. She was a looker as well, though contrasting Beth. While Beth was conventionally beautiful, Anna, as she was introduced, was an Alt beauty. She wore a black tank top which showed off her colorful half sleeve tattoo and large cleavage, her skirt was a parody of a schoolgirl skirt that likely reveal much of her legs weren’t crossed, and her boots were rockers with three thick leather clasps. She gave you a wink as you sat next to her, and everyone else joined around the center coffee table.

Nathan had come and put snacks and drinks for everyone, and you noticed that while his clothes were normal, his cooking apron was a parody of a French maid one, one you hadn’t seen before, and around his throat was a solid silver ring necklace.

“Thanks baby” Beth said to him, kissing his cheek as he finally sat down next to her. He blushed, and Beth continued. “So game night! Now that’s everyone’s here, I have an idea for a fun night...”

What’s her idea?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)