Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 25 by Blubel Blubel

What will they do?

A deal?

You regain your senses slowly after Fiona nearly drowned you with her cum and you blacked out. Your woman parts feel really uncomfortable and something wet is dripping out of your Pussy. You remember El fucking you and coming in your petite Pussy. You stay put hearing your Sisters talking and decide to play dead for now maybe they let you alone.

"So El how was it fucking Jesse's nice petite Body? You both really seem to enjoy yourself after a while." Fiona casually asks Elsie.

"I... she... haven't you heard what Chloe said? I can't believe we did this. I feel so horrible" Elsie sobs trying to find any words for the chaotic struggle of her feelings as her eyes wander through the room.

"Ah come on El don't let Chloe's talk get to you. She is defending her Mother and trying to divide us. I think she is hiding something and is planning something on her own as she said. And with the whole Pheromone stuff and how horny she was it was only a matter of time since it would happen anyway." you feel Fiona's hand running down your legs as she gently caresses your inner thighs and lick her lips. "You heard her Jesse will be horny as hell for next days so we can fuck her and have plenty of fun fucking her or she will masturbate like hell. I for sure will go with option number one helping her get off as much as possible she will be such a cute fucktoy don't you think?" Fiona's whispers seductively as she softly caress your smooth skin.

You can't believe what you hear after everything that happened Fiona still wants to **** you more. So part of your condition is to be horny as hell. That would explain why you were so horny during the abusive fuck Elsie had given you and why despite what had happened so far you feel strangely aroused from Fiona's touch. This is all way over your head you haven't even fully adopted to the situation as a girl and Fiona your loved sister and the person you even had a secret crush on now ice-cold stands here planning your degradation to her personal whore. And what was she talking about Chloe defending her Mother? Part of you wanted to just stand up and yell at Fiona or punch her as you clench your fist. But for now your Chances of overpowering or stopping both of them is really slim. Damn this female Body. Your hope is that maybe your Mom or Aunt Peg will come to look after you. So the best is to stay put for now you think.

After what seems like probably hours Elsie puts her head up. "No Fiona it's not right to continue that. I can't do that she is still Jesse even in this new form. As long as she didn't ask us we can't just **** ourselves on her" Elsie replies in broken voice. All the time looking at you with a caring and deeply devastated expression. You don't know what to feel or think on one hand you are relieved that El might have snapped out of it. On the other she has hurt you bad not only physical but more so your soul. She sounds so much more like the old caring El but you can't get your opposite feelings clear. So for the moment hope sparks in you that El might have snapped out of it enough so that it wouldn't get anymore out of Hand.

Fiona sighs "Jeez El. I know you have a crush on Jesse and even now I can see in your eyes that you still have feelings for her but come on you want to fuck her as bad as I do. Think about all the nice stuff you can do now with her that maybe impossible when she is back to her old self she may even like it haven't you seen her going wild during your fuck?"

"I... I haven't. You don't know anything about my feelings and I can't do this any further Fiona." Elsie shouts out and looks down nervously playing with her hands sobbing. She looks over your Body still Cum is leaking from your Pussy down your thighs onto the bed.

"Don't be ridiculous El it is so obvious even Mom is on your trail for quite some time the only one stupid enough not to see it is Jesse. Jesus he is such an imbecile do you really think your feelings for him are mutual?" Fiona stares at Elsie. After she doesn't respond for sometime Fiona grabs Elsie's shoulders "Trust me Elsie you will only get pain out of your feelings if you don't let them go. I love you and I can't stand by when his stupidity and ignorance hurt you. Maybe as a girl she understands it better but do you really think she will love you ever as much as I do? Even now she can't understand anything about your real feelings and problems. I will always be at your side and understand your feelings better than she ever can. He doesn't deserve you or your love."

Your world is shattered. How couldn't you see Elsie's true feelings for you all the time when everybody else seems to have seen them so clear? Every word Fiona speaks is like a hot knife rammed into your heart. You haven't seen Elsie for more than your best Buddy but you can't imagine how hard had it been for her every time you told her about Alison and you or your other crushes. Now you can imagine and understand how Fiona got her to do what she did. There are too many emotions you feel guilty, incredibly angry, hurt and disappointed. You start to shake and can't stop shaking while you try to comprehend what you heard and feel torn apart by your feelings and thoughts. Your mind goes blank as you can't handle anymore thoughts or emotions there is not a single thought as you only stare onto the white Wall and your mind breaks under the pressure of the revelations and the emotional devastation tonight.

"I... I can't change my feelings for him Fiona so please let us stop this. If not for him... for Mom. She will be so utterly destroyed if she finds out what we did already." Elsie looks into Fiona's eyes trying to look as reassuring as possible as she merely whispers to her and caresses Fiona's cheek.

"Ah see who is awake again. Perfect timing Jesse. Fine I accept your feelings even if they will hurt you." Fiona speaks like the words hurt her, pushes El's hand away. "Seems like i can't talk you out of it but don't come to me if she hurts your feelings again and again. So i have an idea and an offer for you." Fiona answers in an absolute cold manner as she releases Elsie's shoulders.

"What for an offer? What do you mean Fiona?" Elsie asks completely confused.

"It should be easy if you really love her so much as you say. I'm willing to promise you I will not lay my hands on Jesse again and even will help you to get Mom out of your way so you can have her if you both want that. But there are conditions. I want you to wholeheartedly say "I love you to her" and confess your feelings to her. If Jesse can say she wholeheartedly loves you too after all we did I will acknowledge that your feelings are true and much stronger than I believe they are. I'll happily admit I am wrong and will not stand between you and help you out as much as I can. But if you can't bring yourself to confess to her, or she can't say it. I will have my way with her what you do to her afterwards is your decision but I would like you to join in and share your feelings with our Sister." she giggles "So do we have a deal?"

You hear everything blurry like your head is under water and your body won't stop shaking or do anything else. It's like you are trapped in your own Body. You can't believe what Fiona proposed how could she do such thing to you and even Elsie? It seems she has completely gone nuts as you're struck by lightning as you see through it. Seemingly she offered an easy way out for you. You only had to say you love EL and the whole nightmare would be over. But if you say it and don't mean it honest with her you would break Elsie's heart and despite everything you start to feel bad only thinking about it. You think again what your options are only to see that Fiona had trapped you if you say you love her and don't mean it you prove her right. If you say you don't, you would be at Fiona's mercy but wouldn't hurt Elsie as much as if you would trick her. You are confused what to do there are so many different thoughts on your mind.

"So Jesse, Elsie what will it be? Only looking onto little Jesse's naked Body makes me horny and maybe I am lucky beating your Sperm in her." Fiona eagerly states stroking her massive cock and looking at Elsie.

[Author's Note] English is not my native Language, so I tried my best to correct all errors, misspellings and so on. If despite my efforts you find any errors inform me so I can correct them.

Decision

  • No further chapters
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)