A New Head of the Household

(Okay, I don't know how frequent the updates to this path will be...but I'm in a mood today and I really wanted to do this one right now. Just another reminder to those parachuting in that this is a unique story thread that plays by its own rules. Needless to say this will almost certainly be one of the "bad endings" to this choose your own adventure story.)

You lie there stunned.

What the hell had just happened? What was going on with your daughter? She'd taken the fucking pill!!! This just couldn't be happening. This couldn't be real. Your familiar family life was crumbling to pieces around you. What was this insane new reality you'd entered? With your lust completely slaked suddenly things didn't seem as fun as they once did. Doubt and regret began to rise within you. And what Penny had just done...it was madness! This was not just bedroom fun anymore, Penny had taken this way too far.

Elsie continues to clutch and kiss your hand as she lay curled up beside, her body kept apart from you though by her daughter's leg. She had your left hand in both of hers, her face resting against the back of your hand. It was as close to you as she could get.

Penelope still lies on top of you cooing and purring in contentment, her big wet cock pinned between you. "Ohhhh Daddy...ohhhh Daddy..." She sits up and begins stroking your sweaty chest and abdomen, her wide beautiful blue eyes admiring you. Her chiseled body and big firm breasts glisten with perspiration of her own. "Ohhhh my Daddy loves me sooooo much. I love you too Daddy. I love you too. More than anything." Her blue eyes shone with a mad energy.

"Penelope..." You start to say.

She plants a finger over your lips. "Shhhh, don't ruin this moment." She looks down to her exhausted mother lying beside you. "Daddy looks thirsty, go get us something to drink." She orders brusquely as she nudges El roughly. "Get up! Get us something to drink! Daddy's thirsty!"

This was way past sexual role play now, she was straight up giving her mother orders. You yank your head to the side forcing Penny's finger from your mouth. "Penny! What has gotten into you!? Don't talk to your mother like that. This has gone too...mmmph!"

Penelope clamps her hand over your mouth and shoots you an angry stare...that swiftly melts into a gaze of pure infatuated love. You struggle against her but it was no use. Her legs still wrapped around yours and her other hand now pinning you down by the chest she watches you try to push her off. Your muscular daughter was quickly learning just how much stronger she was than you and she seemed intent on letting you know it as well. She lets you struggle for a time just to demonstrate the futility of it. What had been annoyance soon turns to amusement. She holds your head still by the hand clasped over your mouth and leans down to kiss your forehead. "Shhhhhh. It's okay Daddy, she wants to do what I say. Don't you Mommy?"

El slowly sits up. Her daughter's cum was still streaked through her hair and drying in the little patches on her face and chest that she'd missed during her hasty clean up. She was still half out of it in the dizzying afterglow of her brutal fuck session with Penny. "Huh?"

Penny smiles the most strangely creepy smile you had ever seen on her. "I said...you want to listen to me, don't you Mommy?"

"Umm..." Elsie looks between you confused. "...Penny, this is just bedroom stuff..."

"Ha! Not anymore it's not. If you ever want this big cock again you'd better start listening. You're my slut now, you said so, that's full time Mama. I don't want no part time slut." Penelope tells her flatly. "You listen or you'll have to go back to just having Daddy. You wouldn't want that, would you?" Penelope lets out a most wicked sounding laugh. "Ha ha ha ha! Is that what you want Mommy? Do you want to go back to just fucking only Daddy? Can Daddy fuck you like I can Mommy?"

Elsie is very quiet for a long moment, her eyes glance briefly toward you. After these past two days you both knew damn well the answer to that question. She says in a soft concerned voice. "Penny...sweetie...don't..."

Penny glares at her mother. "Stop. I'm Daddy's sweetie, not yours! Daddy loves his little girl like you never could! You call me Ma'am now, or Miss Penelope."

"Pen..."

"You want this big dick, don't you Mama? You want a lover that can go as long as you want, don't you Mama? You want a lover that'll treat you like the dirty slut you are, isn't that right Mama? You think you could find a better lover? Even in the family? I doubt it." Penny was buffeting poor exhausted El with questions you all knew the answers to. "You're mine now Mama, you said so yourself."

"But...but Penny...I...but...but..." Elsie stammers. "Oh...oh Penny..."

Her body language was changing toward Penny. More uncertain, more deferential, less maternal. You are stunned...that nervous yet unwavering look in Elsie's deep expressive eyes...you knew her better than anyone in this world and you could see that she was seriously considering this! Was she really about to let her own daughter boss her around? El, just like you, had always had a meek and passive side to her. Both of you quite liked it when the other would take charge. Neither of you were natural Alpha personalities like your older sister. Or, evidently, like your buff daughter.

"He he he." Penny chuckles, bringing exactly what you were thinking to a fine point. "And besides, remember that night last year when you had a few too many glasses of wine. When Auntie Fiona and Grandma were visiting. Remember, our girls night? He he he. Weren't you telling us that you wished Daddy would take charge more and act like a real man? Not act like such a beta wuss all the time?"

El flinches and looks at you guiltily. "Penny...I...I never said that...well...not like that I didn't. Not in those words...I'm sorry Jesse...I didn't...um...oh Penny." She swallows hard and says quietly. "I told you that in confidence."

"Don't worry Mama, my Daddy doesn't need a tired old whore like you. I'll take charge of you now. I'll treat you nice as long as you do what I say. I'll fuck you like you need to be fucked. Just do what you're told Mama and I'll keep your old cunt happy." Penny slowly uncovers your mouth and shoots you a little wink. You were too stunned by this scene to say anything at the moment. "And I'll treat you nice too Daddy, I'll treat you nice all the time. My perfect man. My perfect Daddy." She says those last words with a dreamy distant sigh. Her hands begin to caress your chest and stomach once more. She still sat atop you, your softening manhood still gripped in her clenching pussy. The previously virgin pussy that only you had ever entered.

El reaches out for her daughter in one last feeble attempt to resister her. "P-Penny...please...don't..."

The emotion drains from your daughter as she turns her head slowly toward her mother. She says in a tone that as cold as ice. "I said...my Daddy is thirsty. Go get him a drink. Right now."

There is a long awkward silence that descends on the room as Elsie and Penelope stare each other down. It doesn't take long before it is Elsie's eyes that drop in submission.

You shake yourself from your stupor, you couldn't stay quiet any longer. "El..."

Elsie suddenly speaks up, purposely interrupting whatever you were about to say. She says in a soft but confident voice. "Yes...Miss Penelope. Yes Ma'am." She slowly turns to you, her dark eyes showing both her total willing subservience as well as her deep humiliation. "What do you want to drink...sir?"

You gasp. "Elsie!"

Penelope smiles in triumph. "Sir...I like that. Good slut. Water is good for now. Bring me and my man some water. With ice."

Elsie nods. "Yes Ma'am."

Without another word Elsie gets to her feet. It takes her a moment to steady herself on her rubbery legs. She walks gingerly, her well fucked pussy still tender from her daughter's lengthy reaming. Her head bowed she makes her way toward the door. Just before she exits the room she glances over at you...an ashamed sinful little smile curling up at the corners of her mouth. You share the briefest moment of eye contact. Just long enough for her to tell you that she was okay and loved you as deeply as ever. And then she is gone.

Your Elsie had just given herself to her own daughter while you watched it happen. That twisted smile on Elsie's face just now...you weren't sure you could have stopped this from happening even if you had tried. You had the feeling now that once Elsie had felt Penny's size and power, once she'd experienced Penny's dominance, your fates had been sealed.

Penny lifts up off of you, allowing your slimy cock to squirt from her tight teen slit. She lays down at your side, spooning up next to you. Her blonde head lays on your shoulder as she strokes and pets your cheek and neck. Her love crazed eyes locked on your face with a frightening intensity.

"My Daddy. My perfect perfect Daddy. Everything is going to be just perfect now. You'll see." She snuggles in tight. "Your little girl loves you Daddy." She purrs happily.

You look at her in a mix of confusion and horror. Your daughter had just turned your life upside down. She'd fucked you, she'd cucked you, she'd manhandled you, she'd publicly told strangers of your relationship, she'd made your beloved wife her slut and ****, and she...and she was now surely pregnant with your second child! The words of your older sister rings once more in your ears...you stupid motherfucker.

Stupid motherfucker indeed. Fucking hell...you and Elsie had tried to live a quasi normal life, you really had. And you'd managed it for close to twenty years. But in the end you were Bailey's. In the end you were your mother's children. It seemed a normal life just wasn't in the cards.

"Ohhhh Daddy." You daughter coos. She grips you in her powerful embrace, strong enough to **** the air from your lungs. "Your little girl loves you more than anything. More than ANYTHING Daddy! Tell me you love me Daddy. Tell your little girl you love her." She squeezes you even harder, forcing a grunt from you.

"Ungh...I love you baby girl. Daddy loves his little girl." You say obediently.

Her grip loosens and she relaxes into your body, nuzzling into you like she did when she was little. She starts to pet you once more as she hums in utter bliss. "Mmmmmm....my Daddyyyy...."

You lie there stunned.