More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 55 by grimbous grimbous

What's next?

A Beautiful Friendship Begun

"Ohhhh." El fretted. She pets her hands up and down Casey's swooping back with an instinctual need to comfort her. Elsie didn't know what to do, she knew she was hurting Casey yet Casey refused to get off of her.

"Nnnngh." Casey moans in obvious distress.

"We need to stop."

"No."

"I'm hurting you!"

Casey pulls back and looks at El, wavy strands of red hair swaying over her face and an intense look of focus in her green eyes. "I...mmm...knew you would. Just...shhhh...it's already getting better."

Her backdoor was crying out for mercy but ever so gradually it was adapting. The burning sting was already duller than it had been just a minute ago. She could feel El all the way into her belly, full didn't even come close describing the sensation. She felt like an overstuffed pillow with the stitches straining at the seams. She endures, holding onto the hope that this would get better in time. She kisses Elsie passionately as El explores her body with her soft hands.

After a time Casey finds the courage to move at last. Gripping one of El's shoulders and reaching back to hold her ass with the other hand she rises verrrry slowly. "AUWWW!" It felt nearly as intense going out as it did going in! It felt as if half her guts were being pulled out with it. Feeling around the shaft she knew everything was fine down there but the feeling of being plunged like this was a foreign sensation. Coming up about six inches Casey pauses. Grabbing the lube again she spurts a big wad into her right hand and reaches back to coat El's hard pole and her own stretched hole to make every incredibly slick and slippery.

Down she goes again. "MMMMMM!" Her perfect pearly white teeth clench together in a wide grimace as she stuffed to the max once more. "Hauhhhh!"

"Ohhhhh!" El echoes. "Soooo tight!"

Casey grabs Elsie's breasts, one in each hand, gripping them tighter than she meant to. Elsie peeps but doesn't complain. El's bra was still on, the one side is smeared by Casey's lube covered right hand. Up again...down again. "Mrrrmmm!" Up...down. "Auhhhh!" Rise...fall. "Ohhhhh!"

It wasn't happening as fast as she would like but each long slow stroke was getting just a bit easier and feeling just a bit better.

"Relax baby, you gotta relax."

Casey liked hearing El call her baby. "I'm trying. Ohhhooohh, I'm trying." She hunches down into her, her head resting on her shoulders as her hips rise and fall. Elsie embraces her and holds her like the gentle and compassionate lover that she is.

"You're doing so good baby." El whispers in her ear. "You feel so good. You're so beautiful." She kisses her neck. "That's it, your getting it now. Mmmm, God you feel good baby."

Nobody had ever held Casey like this or whispered such lovely things to her in the middle of love-making. Her gentle touch and gentle voice, her soft embrace and her soft curvaceous body, along with her ass filling cock, were things Casey would very much like to get used to. Casey had stumbled upon a miracle this night and if things went well she hoped never to let it go.

She is starting to ride Elsie with a bit more ease and a LOT more joy. Her sphincter was still protesting, stretched so thin she swore she could have read braille written across El's shaft, but beyond that the overstuffed feeling was ohhhh so lovely.

Sitting up taller again she grips El's shoulders and really begins to ride. Staring down at the stunning Bailey she smiles and breaths heavy. "I like you...Elsie."

El nibbles her plump bottom lip and smiles back. "I like you too Casey."

"I like your body."

"I LOVE your body." Elsie runs her left hand up the lithe torso and grips the flesh of the boy breast. At the same time she grips Casey's stiffy in her other hand. It was still slick from lube but she could also feel a copious dribble of precum trickling steadily from the tip.

"OH!" Casey is over the moon as Elsie begins to thrust up into her while stroking with her hand.

El adored the petite penis gripped almost entirely in her hand. She loved how she could hold it tight, all the way around, with a single hand. She liked how when she stroked it most of it stayed within the span of her hand. She could really...hold...it, not simply grab a side or a tip or a base. She could hold the whole thing, squeeze it tight almost from end to end. Casey's made the Bailey's dicks look like such crude clumsy instruments. She couldn't wait to feel it inside of her, no risk of pain for her tight pussy with this fun sized peen. Elsie firmly believed it was the cutest and best cock in the whole world, none could possibly top it. The perfect cock for the perfect woman.

Casey rode and at last everything was coming together. Even her strained anus was glowing with a warm good feeling now. As the pain receded a wonderful blissful glow took its place. And oh...oh how it filled her. It filled spaces Casey didn't even know she had, satisfied a desire she had never been aware of. For the first time in her life she understood the real magic and toe curling ecstasy of being stuffed with a massive cock. Her prostate sang like it never had! She didn't think she could take any bigger and enjoy it, but feeling herself pushed right to the limit was an intoxicating new high. And for it to be attached to this gorgeous gentle creature beneath her...heaven. Casey firmly believed it was the most magnificent and best cock in the whole world, none could possibly top it. The perfect cock for the perfect woman.

"Nnngh! Nnngh! Nnngh!" Casey gasps as she really starts coming down with ****, El's soft body quaking on each impact.

"Ohhh yessss!" El sighs, her stroking hand picking up the pace.

"Oh! Oh God! OH!"

Casey was close, El could feel it on her cock and in her hand, she could see it the tensing lean body. The slippery wet sound of El's jerking hand fills the air as she goes even faster.

"Cum for me." She says. "Cum for me my beauty!"

"Oh! Oh! Oh!" Casey slams down harder and harder as the pressure building inside.

"Huuhhhhhh" Elsie moans, not far from her own release. "That's it. Ohhhh that' it!"

In an angelic voice high and true Casey lets out her rapture. "OHHHHHHHHH!"

Casey's small cock shoots out a hurtling wad of jizz that blasts Elsie right across the face. Another hits her chin. At third paints a line up between El's breasts. Her ass clenches rhythmically around El's cock as a powerful orgasm rocks Casey front and back.

"AAAAAHHHHH!" Her operatic voice rings pure.

"Ohhh! Ohhh! Ohhh my god I feel you cumming! Ohhh!" Elsie bucks hard and lets out an adorable mewling squeal as she pumps Casey's tight ass full of hot thick jizz. "Mmmeeeeeaaaaaeeee!"

Casey is over the moon as the thick shaft inside of her throbs in time to her own spasming rapture.

The cling to each other and ride out their bliss in a duet of carnal release.

When it is all over they are holding each other, staring face to face as their hot panting breath washes over the others face. They kiss deeply, passionately, and often. Casey's cum smooshing between their lips as the did.

When at last they part Casey lets out a great sigh. "Hoahhhh! Elsie Bailey...I think this might be the beginning of a beautiful friendship."

Elsie giggles. "I think so."

"Elsie. Mmmm"

All her life El had been so sure of things. So sure that she and her brother were meant for each other. But the thing with destiny is when one path is blocked another invariably opens. Sitting now with this scarlet haired, emerald eyed, most beautiful woman in the world on top of her Elsie couldn't have been happier. She was happy, truly happy. Perhaps not in the same way, but in a way just as special. She could not wait to truly get to know Casey Devlin.

'You can have him Fiona.' Elsie thinks, her heart truly at peace with that reality now. 'Jesse is all yours.'

***

And that is where I think I will leave this side trek. Hope you enjoyed seeing how Elsie's night went, or at least began.

What's next?

  • No further chapters
More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)