Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 45 by legolus legolus

What's next?

2 Truths and a Lie

They moved the half circle couch a bit closer to the large table in the center and spread it around so that it formed more of a full circle. All got comfy on the large couch, with plenty of room for everyone. From the twelve o’clock position going clockwise the order was: Mary, Merida, Allie, Sam, Ellen, Flora, Chloe, Aubrey, Talia, Laura, Hilde, Freya.

“Mary, I had an idea I wasn’t going to suggest it but since we removed the no sexual stuff rule, I’d now like to suggest it.”

“Okay… but realize that I’m already leaning towards no.”

“Fair enough. I was thinking you boost my Fairy Godmother TF right now and then I ask for Cassandra to make things more interesting by adding some magic to the game. But anything that happens in the game will be dispelled tomorrow morning. No lasting stuff.”

“Ummm… what would that even look like I mean? That seems a rather nonspecific suggestion like just add magic is pretty broad.”

“Well it would obviously have to change based upon what we’re doing, I figured maybe Cassandra could allow you to set the rules and they apply to everyone as long as we all agree to them.”

Mary was conflicted, I mean that does sound fun. But also like it could get out of hand, real fast. “What does everyone think about that show of hands, who likes the idea.” Everyone except Hilde, and Aubrey raised their hands. “Okay Hilde, Aubrey, are either of you so opposed to the idea that you wouldn’t want to join, or are you just hesitant.”

“I just think it has quite a bit of potential for things to go wrong and there be hurt feelings later.” Aubrey said.

“I’m not sure I would be up for it, especially since you lifted the sexual rule.” Hilde said meekly.

“Hilde what if, assuming Cassandra can do this mind you, I made one of the rules that everyone will be unable to do anything that would result in hurt feelings later? Not that we wouldn’t have hurt feelings but like if you wouldn’t be comfortable kissing someone here no one will do that.”

She considered for a minute, looked at her sister receiving a smile in return “I guess I would be on board then.”

“Okay Chloe, we’ll do it. Let’s Give It a Boost!” She stuck her hand out towards Chloe in a pose like a magical girl, “Okay that was a little weird I actually felt like I had to say that I really hope that isn’t going to become a thing, but it probably will.” Mary sighed.

Fairy Godmother: Cassandra becomes Chloe’s Fairy Godmother, once per round Chloe can make one request to Cassandra and she will do her best to fulfill it, though she can only bend the rules of the show not break them. [Cinderella][Boon] Boosted 1/3: Chloe may now either make two additional requests or combine all three requests into one large request, which can’t break the rules but can come pretty darn close.

Chloe got out her phone and messaged Cassandra.

~Pop~

“Oh sweet child, you rang. Thank you, it is such a treat. To. Be. Called.” She glared at Mary. “How can I help you?”

“I assume you were listening, do I really have to explain it again.”

“I was, but you do actually have to make it a formal request with the exact wording for your boon dear. I get your idea, and this isn’t some monkey’s paw situation. I will do my best to fulfill the intent of your request.”

“Okay, can you give Mary the ability to make magically binding rules for games so long as everyone playing consents.”

“I can, if that is what you want. But I’ll say two things first, Mary will have to consent to this as she is the Mistress, second it will use all three of your favors, not that I think you care about that since you would lose two of them in twenty-four hours when the boost expires. I also am feeling particularly generous about this one, I really like your new style by the way.”

“Then, assuming Mary consents, that is my request?”

“Mary, are you okay with me fulfilling her request?”

“Mary, wait!” Talia exclaimed. Everyone turned to her. “I’m not saying that this is a problem per se but I just realized something. Chloe didn’t ask for you to get the ability for that tonight, you would get it permanently that is why Cassandra needs your consent. Because it’s technically a permanent transformation and you’re the Mistress.”

“That true, Cassandra?” Mary asked.

“Yes, it is, like I said I am feeling particularly generous, and Chloe left wiggle room to be so. It isn’t like you have to put magical rules on games you can, and only if everyone consents to the rules. So there isn’t any downside, it is just a boon. It’s why I didn’t bother telling you, I wanted it to be a surprise gift.”

“Okay, I consent.”

Magical-Girl Fun Times: Mary is becoming a proper magical girl, she can already give her ladies a boost, let's give her something for some simple fun. Mary can now create binding magical rules on a game or contest, so long as everyone involved is told the rules and consents to them beforehand.

“Okay that feels good. I guess I have magic now. Um, how powerful is this effect?” Mary question.

“Hmm, that’s hard to explain, something might seem like they are simpler than others but they aren’t. Any specific questions?”

“Well, not that I’m going to but can there be permanent or longer term consequences. Like I assume I can make some temporary transformations with the rules but if I wanted could I have some things last, or give the winner a reward or losers a penalty?”

“Nothing Permanent. At least not at your current power. Probably two weeks would be your limit for duration right now. And yes you can put magical stakes but it has to be clear what those stakes are, and again a time limit. Also you might run into not being able to change something because of the rules of the show.”

“Okay thank you, Cassandra… I was wondering,” Mary was trying to be delicate here, “I’m not suggesting anything by this but would you like to join us?” I want to try to repair this relationship but I kind of hope she turns me down.

“No, for two reasons. First I think it would go better without me here as a bonding opportunity for those bound to you to bond. Second I have decided I am going to open a mid-week poll and give out rewards to those who the audience finds most entertaining tonight. And yes that includes you Freya, Hilde, and Mary not just the contestants. I’ll find something for you, if any of you place high in the poll. First place will be a particularly special reward catered to you specifically too. So have fun and have a good night.”

~Pop~

“Well that was a bit unusual” Laura said, “I mean Cassandra is fairly nice but I thought she wasn’t happy with quite a few of us.”

“Maybe this is her olive branch?” Aubrey suggested, “Trying to mend fences. Like yeah we upset her and vice versa, we could keep being mad or we could try to move past the issues. Anyway, Marry what first?”

“Well, First blanket game rule for the evening, that supersedes all other game rules. You can’t suggest, dare, do, ask, insinuate or anything else similar that is going to make another player overly uncomfortable or would cause them to have hurt feelings or for you to regret doing that to them later because of the game. That doesn’t mean you can’t do those things on your own but that’s on you, not the game. If a game effect, would cause you to do it when you normally wouldn’t you won’t be able to either. So if you do something and regret it, that is because you did it you can’t use the game as an excuse. Everyone agrees?”

A chorus of sures, and yes echoed out. “Um Hilde I need your verbal consent apparently. Everyone else’s I have.”

“Oh, yea sure.” Hilde replied.

“Okay good. Second blanket rule: all effects from tonight will be gone after twenty-four hours from now or less if specified by a subsequent rule. Now I was thinking two truths and a lie first, a way to get to know people here. Though here are my modifications. If the majority of us guess the lie it becomes the truth for the twenty-four hour period. If the person tricks the majority of us they can pick one of the people they tricked and share one of their truths with them. Everyone who guesses the lie gets a point and the person gets a point for everyone they trick. Person with the most points wins, I want to give some sort of prize for first but don’t know what it should be so suggestions?”

“How about we can request how you use a TF boost” suggested Freya.

“I’m okay with that as long as it still follows the previous rule that you can’t request it on someone else if they would be upset because of it. Does that work for everyone? We’ll do one full round, around the circle.”

“Wait, that won’t work.” Allie said. “You have to have a prize for winning too, Mary. Otherwise it isn’t fair. You’re putting up a prize that is already yours.”

“How about this then. I get to go into my closet and pick out outfits for let’s say the bottom three place holders and they can’t wear anything else for the entire time duration win or lose and If I win I get to keep the Boost to distribute myself. Does that work for everyone?” Mary got confirmation from everyone. “Okay does anyone want to start us off or should I go first and we go clockwise?”

“I’ll do it.” Aubrey said “I suggested the party, so it’s only fair.”

Speaker: Aubrey

I am a twin.

I have a set of siblings who are quadruplets.

I have never had sex.

“Okay first,” Laura began, “I request that we can have the person clarify ambiguous terms, like what do you mean by sex. Because some people don’t count blow jobs as sex, others do. I think it is only fair we know what you are actually claiming one way or another.”

Aubrey responded, “That’s fair, I mean vaginal intercourse, satisfied?” Laura just nodded.

“Well, I know the answer but you aren’t getting it out of me” Chloe said jokingly.

“Same, here.” Mary replied.

“Wait really?” Aubrey asked.

“Yes, but I’m not going to sabotage your chance of tricking the others.”

“Well I find it suspicious she has two answers about her siblings, So I think she is probably a virgin, and either one is an outright lie or there are a set of twins or triplets or something instead.” Talia mused.

“Yea, Aubrey seems like the kind of gal to want to find mister right not mister right now. She wants kids, so she would probably wait. Then again… maybe she’s tried to baby trap a guy.” Hilde speculated

“I WOULD NEVER!” Aubrey exclaimed.

“Then, she’s a virgin.” Sam said, “Actually I have a question Freya, you aren’t essentially at an unfair advantage because you know everything about us or anything right?”

“Fair question but no, I have some info on each of you but not a lot. Mary on the other hand is screwed, because I know her intentions, so I will know what her lie is no matter what.”

“Hey!” Mary shouted “Not cool.”

“Too bad, I don’t see anyone complaining that Talia got enhanced intellect a little bit ago and is going to wipe the floor with everyone here, I’m going to use my advantages where I can.”

“She does have a point.” Talia chuckled.

“Was that a laugh? Did Talia just laugh?” Allie was astonished. “It’s really nice, I’m glad Mary could help you Talia.”

“Thanks Allie, me too.”

“Okay everyone, voting time,” Mary began, “Okay addendum to the rules, you can’t lie about your vote. Everyone good with that?” Nods, “Perfect alright everyone think of what you want and then in ten seconds Aubrey tell us the lie.”

“Okay, so the lie is that I have a set of siblings who are quadruplets, I have a pair of identical twin sisters and a Twin brother. Well okay Chloe obviously knew that but how did you Mary? I’m a little surprised that only four of you guessed that.”

“Oh, I knew because your twin brother hit on me a few times during college. Also Cassandra mentioned them when threatening you.”

“He WHAT!”

“Yeah, shortly after my ex-girlfriend and I ended things, actually I think you had also broken up with your boyfriend at the time, too.”

“That PRICK! He did it again. Let me guess, he came on real strong, you told him you were straight and he offered to set you up with me didn’t he.”

Mary squinted at Aubrey “Yesss… How did you know that.”

“Freya, please set a reminder for me to punch my brother when the show ends. Chloe, could you help too? I don't want to forget.”

“Certainly miss.” Freya pulled out her phone to put it on Aubrey’s TODO list.

“I take it he has done that multiple times then.” Mary inquired

“Just about anytime I’m single, and show interest in a guy. He has scared a bunch of people off because of it. Alright next up, I don’t want to talk about this more.”

“Who are you sharing, a truth with?” Ellen inquired.

“Oh, hmmm. Well I don’t want to give anyone a twin for twenty-four hours, that would just be wrong.”

“Actually, if you chose that it would permanently give them a twin” Freya stated.

“Wait what!” Everyone shouted in unison.

“Uh, so making a twin is easy but the rules of the show very very explicitly forbid killing people, so if you gave someone a twin we couldn’t undo that. You also couldn’t give Hilde it because she is already a sextuplet, which would require getting rid of four of us, to make her a twin.”

“So yea definitely make someone a virgin then.” Aubrey stated “Now who. Oh that would be funny.”

“Hey Aubrey? I’m no' sayin' you have tae or whatever but I wouldnae mind havin' a sibling.” Merida piped up. “But I get if daein' that would flap you oot.”

Everyone looked at Merida, Mary went ahead and questioned her, “Really? I mean that’s a lot, and we don’t know how that would work out. It could be retroactive, It could essentially just be a brand new person from nowhere. It seems risky, I mean I won’t stop you from asking but think carefully. Also I just realized Freya, what would have happened if she had lied in a way that would have gotten rid of one of her siblings.”

Everyone looked on in horror. “She wouldn’t have been able to.” Relief washed over everyone.

“Aubrey, it’s up tae you. I’ve aye wanted a sibling growin' up but I get that is a scary proposition.” Merida said.

“Sorry, Merida, I don't think I can do that. Laura, I’m sharing with you the fact I’ve never had vaginal sex.”

Laura felt the change come over her immediately, “Oh, you bitch.”

“What? If you're quick about it you might be able to give Mary your virginity. I’m sure we virgins are going to get extra points when we finally give it up to her” Aubrey teased her.

“Hey Mary… Fancy fifteen minutes in heaven?”

“Not now Laura.”

“That wasn’t a no. So I’ll ask again later. Next up?”

“Guess that’s me, for fairness I’m going to go with my current history unless someone objects.” Talia said.

Multiple people objected, “Sorry Talia, I think that you have to count both.” Mary said “Even if you didn’t do them explicitly you still remember doing them right? And you told people here things about yourself, so if it is different because of the change that isn’t fair. I think any inconsistencies should be resolved to your disadvantage, meaning you can’t be like I have a younger sister, unless that is either a lie or truth both before and after the change.”

“I think that is a bit unfair, but I see I’m the only one. Fine.”

Speaker: Talia

I thought Mark was really cute the first time I met him.

I’ve always been rather horny.

I love to figure skate.

“Figure skating is the lie,” Flora said.

“Why do you say that?” Aubrey asked.

“Because, she was obviously attracted to him when we all met him again so I’m going to assume that's true, and she was clearly repressed when we met her, she was wound so tight she was going to blow a fuse. Plus of the things to lie about and make true, that is the least problematic. I think she is going for damage control, because so much is barred because stuff conflicts between her two histories.”

No one really had anything to add to Flora’s reasoning.

“Okay so I guess vote?” Mary said after a moment of silence.

“Flora was right, I never went figure skating before, though it’s weird because I definitely love doing it now. Your turn Laura.”

Speaker: Laura

I really want to go back to school and get an advanced degree.

I’ve never had a serious romantic relationship with someone before.

I’ve started to have romantic feelings towards some of you.

“Well, this just got spicy.” Allie said. “Lets see I don’t think the second one is a lie, myself. You’ve projected that ‘I don’t, get attached’ vibe, so it’s one or three in my opinion not sure which though.”

“I’m going with one personally” Sam offered with no further explanation.

“Ditto” from Flora.

“Oh? Did something happen between you three?” Mary teased knowing full well that something did.

“Can we please just vote?” Laura asked.

“Okay everyone chose” Mary said.

“I’m fine not going back to school, and frankly I’m glad that I tricked most of you because Aubrey turnabout is fair play. I’m giving you the fact I’ve not been in a serious romantic relationship before.” And years of dating experience vanished from Aubrey.

“Crap. Ummm… Chloe, can you take the lead tomorrow?”

“Sure not a problem, sweetheart. Hilde you’re up.”

Speaker: Hilde

I actually really like being small.

As much as I would like to believe we can, I don’t really think we can help Astrid.

I hope Mary figures out a way to take Freya as part of her Harem.

“HILDE!” Freya shouted at her sister. “I don’t know which of those are true but in either case we are having a very long talk later about appropriate things to tell others.”

Hilde looked a little embarrassed but didn’t back down from her sister. “No, Freya. We won't. I'm tired of being talked at and not with. When you actually want to listen, maybe then we can talk.” There was a fierce tension in the room.

“Well… does anyone have ideas?” Ellen broke the silence. “Because I could see all of them being a lie or truth, for different reasons. Freya, your thoughts?”

Freya was mad with Hilde, but giving advice when asked was rather ingrained in her at this point “Well, she’s never complained about being small, so I would guess that is true. I could understand the second being true even if I don’t like it. So I would guess number three. But I don’t want to know what she would do if people guess three and it is a lie. Because I’ve seen what Hilde will do with hope and I’m worried what she could do even with a day of it. So I’m going to ask people to throw this one, but I guess I understand if you won’t.”

“Well, either Freya is playing some mind game on us or we just have to decide if we are going to throw or not. So let’s vote” Chole offered, “Unless someone thinks there is more to offer?”

“Okay the vote in?” Hilde asked, “Okay, I don’t hope that Mary takes Freya as part of her harem. I would be okay with it if it happens though. So who picked it? Hands up. That’s one… three… five… six. Well, darn. I guess I want that now. Pretty badly too. You know Freya. I think you did this on purpose, because I think most people would have gone with the other two, if you had been quiet.”

“I DID NOT!” Freya was getting seriously upset.

“Oh, yeah?” Hilde said snidely, “Well prove it. It’s your turn. Make it your lie. If you can, that is. Honestly that might be for the best, it would stop you from being so self-destructive about Astrid. We all love her and want her back but I’ve never seen an elimination undone after the season is over. During a season rarely, but not after. You need to live your own life, Freya…” Hilde got rather sad, “It feels like we lost you too sometimes.” Silence hung in the air and Hilde finally broke it, “I’m sorry everyone, for bringing down the fun, I think I’m going to go.”

“Hilde, sit back down.” Freya said bitterly. “Even if you want to, you can’t leave anyway. Cassandra locked the door after the game started. And fine I’m going to show you right now.”

Speaker: Freya

I want Mary to add me to her Harem if she can.

I like being a butler and helping people.

At this moment Freya realized something. What the hell? But… but… that can’t be right. No that isn’t true is it? Freya needed to come up with a lie and fast.

I’m straight.

Shit. Why did I say that Hilde knows that isn’t true. I bet Mary thinks that as well.

“Ummm maybe we should stop…” Aubrey suggested

Thank you Aubrey! Freya shouted in her mind.

“Aubrey, I wish we could…” Mary began. “But, remember when I laid out the rules. I said we would do a full round around the circle. I can feel it. We’re doing the full round like it or not.”

CRAP! Freya was not happy. I don’t understand. I DON'T want that. Why would I want that sure Mark is nice, sweet, caring, thoughtful if a bit dense sometimes and rather attractive and... I like Mary’s appearance... even more… crap.

Mary hesitated but went forward. “I’m going to ask what Freya did last time. Please don’t pick the Harem option. If it’s true that might be embarrassing enough, to admit. But if it isn't, I don't want her doing something tomorrow to actually get added when she doesn’t want to. Personally I don’t think she is straight but I’m not sure.” Not one person spoke up. “Okay then everyone vote. Freya? We need your answer.”

“I—I’m bisexual… Mary I don’t know why that wasn’t a lie but please don’t. Please don’t add me unless it can help Astrid.”

“I would never do that willingly without your explicit permission, Freya. Ever.”

“Thank you, I guess, it’s your turn Miss.” Freya seemed like she was about to cry. Hilde, despite her frustration with her sister, put an arm around her and patted her shoulder.

Mary wrapped Freya in a hug. “Just because we have to keep playing doesn’t mean we can’t take a short break. Use the bathroom if you need to. I’m going to order us all some hot cocoa with marshmallows and whipped cream. Also pizza.” They all moved around the room to stretch, use the restroom and grab some pizza. Mary stayed with Freya though. When everyone got back with pizza and cocoa in front of them Mary checked in with Freya. “Are you okay to keep doing stuff or should we make this as fast as possible and end the night?”

“Please don’t end the night, it was my fault for getting mad with my sister. And I guess I didn’t realize… Anyway I’ll be fine being straight for a day isn’t a big deal. Please go ahead Mary.”

“Okay, let’s see… this is hard… ummm…”

Speaker: Mary

I really want to use the last five words for Talia on things I find hot.

I really like the dress I’m wearing.

I want to have an orgy right now.

Fuck, I did what Freya did. Open my big fat mouth without thinking well, at least wanting something doesn’t mean I’m going to pursue it.

“Okay so it’s the orgy right guys?” Laura said.

“I must agree.” Freya added, “Though I’m not sure how wise it is to select that option. Then again the fact she was able to say it at all is interesting.”

“I must agree.” Talia said “Not that it’s the orgy but the interesting part Freya said.”

“Why?” Sam asked.

“Well the first rule.” Talia started to explain. “Eh, it's not really important, except for me. Just interesting. I do think it's the orgy option, though.”

“Yep.” Everyone agreed.

“Okay well, guess the votes are cast… yeah I wasn’t interested in having an orgy. I am now.”

“Perfect! Alright ladies, speed round time.” Laura stated matter of factly.

“We are not having an orgy no matter how much I may want one. Freya, that's an order. Gag anyone else who mentions it again. Lock it on if you have to.”

“You’re no fun.” Laura pouted. “So… what kind of hot things do you want to do to our precious Talia.”

“Merida, I believe it is your turn to go.” Mary said pointedly ignoring the question and mouthed sorry to Talia, receiving a smile back.

“I see what you mean Mary… I don’t want to be boring but it’s hard to come up with something that doesn’t mess with you by revealing something you don’t want revealed.”

Speaker: Merida

“I ain a successful yoga studio.”

“I’m envious o' Ellen’s breasts.”

“I would like it if Mary made me permanently bisexual.”

No one really commented. “Pure nothin'? Nane o' ye have anythin' tae say aboot ma statements? Really?” Merida complained.

“I mean it seems sort of obvious which is the lie.” Laura chimed in.

“Yeah, I got to agree with Laura here, like it might seem like weeks but it was only a couple days ago we got here and all this info was stated during the intro and the intermission.” Ellen chimed in. “You explicitly stated that you thought your breasts were fine, so you wouldn’t mind being bisexual, which makes sense, that could just be the magic of the spring.”

“What no.” Laura said “She’s clearly envious of your boobs. She’s been staring at them all night.”

“Duh,” Ellen retorted, “She is currently bisexual. Of course she is staring at a large rack.”

“Well I guess we’ll see which of you is wrong in a moment.” Mary chuckled. “Alright, votes in? Good.”

“Ma yoga studio is actually pure strugglin'. I barely make enough tae keep a roof ower ma heid and the lichts on.”

“I… I’m sorry to hear that.” Ellen sympathetically told Merida, “Would it make you feel better if I went up a cup size or just more envious… Sorry, clearly not helping.”

“So let’s see… Mary…”

“Don’t you dare give me the bisexual one! I don’t want that. Merida, if you do, I AM GOING TO BE PISSED. LIKE REALLY FUCKING PISSED.” Mary went hysterical.

“Pure, ye have that muckle an issue makin' me bisexual? You made Talia pansexual.” Merida grimaced.

“Merida…” Mary growled in frustration “It wouldn’t make me want to make you permanently bisexual it would make me want to make me permanently bisexual. And I’m so sexually frustrated right now that I might give in and purchase that. Because I am young, horny, have a fuckton of hormones and I have been distracting myself trying not to think about men at the moment because I know how I will feel when I go back to being male. Which is grossed the fuck out. Now if you want to be bisexual permanently talk to me after the spring wears off, I’ll do that for you. Got no problem there. Aubrey already found an option I can use to do that. So now who were you going to share one of your truths with…” glaring at Merida.

“Ummm, okay, glad you cleared that up. Dinnae think you needed tae yell at me though. Could have just told me. So I’m givin' you breast envy. Also Ellen, aye it would cheer me up if you went up a couple sizes tae make Mary mair envious.”

“Sure thing lassie.” Ellen bumped up her breasts up two more cup sizes up to and I-Cup

Ellen 2775 BP -> 2925BP

“Fuck, Merida, Ellen that was rather mean.” Mary complained. “Like I’ve been a woman for a few hours and have small breasts and you give me this… wait… Okay well two can play at this Merida. I’m not going to do it now but you should be prepared to be at least a DD-cup eventually after all if this is how you feel… looking at Ellen’s magnificent cleavage I would HATE to let you suffer like this.” Mary said a little menacingly.

“Miss… didn’t you say it would be up to me if you punished the girls until a system was put in place.” Freya question.

“I did but is it a punishment to relieve her suffering because this feels awful, like really awful. Like I want to open up the store right now and buy myself an upgrade, but I literally can’t because I know I would regret it. But fine. You’re right it would still be a **** transformation.”

Merida let out a sigh of relief, until Freya spoke, “Well glad you are sticking by your word my lady. Now as far as how big you should make Merida I feel like it would only be fair for her to go to an G-cup at least maybe all the way to match Ellen now at an I-Cup.”

“Woah, woah, woah, haud up! I’m sorry, jist messin' aboot. Nae need tae get that drastic. No' sayin' I wouldnae mind a wee upgrade though. Can we please move on?”

“Guess I’m up,” Allie said.

Speaker: Allie

I would Fuck/Marry/Enslave Laura/Sam/Ellen.

I’m glad that I was brought to the Harem Hotel.

I think it would be hot if Mary stayed as Mary permanently.

“Allie…” Mary hissed.

“Oh so, it’s wrong for us to get off on you being transformed?” She teased. “It could be a lie too, you don’t know.”

“Well? Any guesses?” Flora spoke up “I personally think it is the third one.”

“I don’t know, I haven't really gotten the sense that Allie is into me.” Laura said, “But yea I think she would miss Mark’s dick.”

No one else seemed to have anything to say.

“Okay, vote.”

“Yeah, I would miss your dick, way too much for me finding you trapped like this hot, but I do find you hot like this. I think we are definitely going for a dip in the spring again some time. Now who to give the truth to. Mary…”

“Allie, I would think very carefully about wanting to make me want to marry Sam. Especially right now with my emotions all messed up. Because I can buy an item to make that happen right now, not to mention enslaving Ellen. So please, don’t.”

“Fine… it’s just it would be really hot for you and Sam to get married. Stupid transformation.” Allied thought, Stupid Mary, just marry Sam. “Plus I can’t give it to you, remember you guessed right. So I’m going to give Talia, Fuck/Marry/Enslave.”

“Okay that’s a lot to deal with, is this how you really feel about them? Damn, lucky Sam.” Sam blushed.

“Earth to Sam. Sam you’re up.” Mary said.

Speaker Sam:

I am happy with my current breast size

I’m on track to become an astronaut or at least was before being brought on the show.

I want nothing more right now than to take Mary into the closet and show her how appreciative I can be.

“The first one.” Flora commented, “Sorry, Sam but I want to win. She’s been grumbling about it the past couple nights. And it’s clear she finds Mary hot, there are only three here that haven’t been checking her out all night, and that’s Ellen, Hilde and Mary herself. Though Freya stopped when she became straight. And fighter pilots from both the Air **** and Navy are top candidates for being an astronaut and add in her degree, that she’s short and a woman, she is like perfect to be selected for an extended space mission. So it is definitely her breast size she’s lying about.”

“You traitor, see if I don’t rat you out on your turn.” Sam stuck out her tongue at Flora.

“Okay vote. Sam what is it?” Mary asked.

“I’m not interested in going to space at all. Love flying but I firmly want to stay in atmo. Thanks Flora.” She winked at the little lioness. That was nine to two, okay. So, Mary…”

“Me… Again?”

“Well I was thinking about the breast size for you, it’s actually why I chose it hoping you would guess wrong. That way it would counter out the breast envy you have for Ellen’s breasts.”

“Oh, thank you.” Mary beamed at Sam.

“Not a problem. If you’re feeling rewarding…”

“Maybe later… but probably not. Also it didn’t work like you thought it would. It’s better, don’t get me wrong but I still very much want I-Cups at the moment. I just don’t think my current breasts are horrible in comparison anymore. Ellen, let's wrap this up. Down to the last three.”

Speaker Ellen:

I’m really enjoying playing these games and really want to play more of these after this one.

I truly want nothing more than to be Mary’s wife, and Allie’s wife/pet

I think Cassandra is a nice person just trying to do her best and we all need to lighten up on her.

“Are we sure there wasn’t more brain damage than we thought?” Chloe joked.

“DON’T JOKE ABOUT THAT!” Flora yelled, “It… it isn’t funny.”

“You’re right Flora, Ellen, I’m sorry.”

“It was a little funny, Flora.” Ellen quipped.

“I honestly have no idea.” Aubrey said. “These are actually really good statements.”

“I think it’s the thing about Cassandra, or being Allie’s pet.” Talia added. Followed by silence.

“Okay since no one is adding anything, vote.”

“I want more than being their wife and Allie pet. And by one vote I tricked the majority. So Mary… You really need to learn more things about your ladies. So let’s play more games after this.”

Mary just closed her eyes and took a deep breath. Okay just something simple. A simple game that won’t get out of hand… Damn it I am enjoying it and I want more, crap… it’s that or the orgy…

“So I just realized something. What happens if Mary is in the bottom three. I don’t think she should go get to choose her own outfit. As that is looking increasingly probable.” Laura asked

“Nothing because that was the cost of me putting up the Booster.” Mary replied.

“Miss, are you a sore loser by chance? I think we should have her try on three outfits for each place below ninth she gets.” Freya chimed in.

“How is that fair?”

“Who said anything about fair?” Freya retorted. At which everyone but Mary laughed. She just grumbled. “Miss Flora, I believe it is your turn.”

Speaker Flora:

I think I deserve to be punished more or still need to do something to make up for my mistake with Ellen.

I am afraid of what is going to happen to me on the show.

I really like my ears and tail.

“Flora…” Mary started sympathetically, as Flora had curled up into a ball on the couch. Chloe moved to comfort her.

“It’s a ploy Mary…” Ellen said. “She does like her ears and tail and they are cute so why wouldn’t she. And we are all afraid of what could happen to us on the show that is just being sane. It’s a sympathy ploy and I’ll be honest I probably would have worked if you didn’t help out Sam like you did.”

“Wait really.” Mary doubted Ellen was right.

“Don’t believe me, if you don’t, want to Mary. But I’m pretty sure no one is going to stop Freya and whoever else wants their very own Mary doll to try on outfits with if you get in the bottom three.”

Mary squinted at the small woman. “Okay thank you Ellen, I think you’re right Flora would have said something otherwise. Anyone else want to add something. Also Flora you brought this on yourself you know. Votes are in.”

“Fine, Crap. Ellen was right. Yes it was a ploy, now I feel like I actually do have to make up for it.” Flora sighed.

“Chloe, finish us off.” Mary for once not intending to make a bad joke.

“Mary, are you simply not capable of not making horrible jokes like is it actually a disorder or something. Because if it is, I'm really sorry for making so much fun of you for it.”

Mary just blinked a few times, “What? I didn’t mean it like that.” Mary went bright red.

“Oh, Mary.” Aubrey purred in delight. “Did anyone tell you that you are just incredibly delightful to fluster?”

“Okay I deserve that.”

Speaker Chloe:

I think that we should play some more and maybe buy some candies from my specialty store tonight.

I think Mary should just go ahead and add Freya to the Harem since they are both clearly into one another.

I would be okay with an open relationship with Aubrey among the other members of the Harem if she is.

Aubrey just stared at Chloe slowly inching towards her girlfriend's face, while squinting.

“I dinnae think Aubrey approves Chloe, or she’s tryin' tae figure oot if you're full o' shite.” Merida said. “Probably baith.”

“Personally I find it hard to believe that she actually thinks Mary should add Freya to the Harem. If it is true I think she owes us an explanation.” Talia said.

“I agree Talia” Mary replied

“I don’t know. I think Chloe might not really want to share Aubrey, then again I think all of them are hard to believe despite knowing her rather well.” Laura said, “Pretty sure even Aubrey is trying to puzzle it out, that isn’t her I’m upset with you face. You can tell because you don’t want to pinch her cheeks.”

“HEY!”

“See like that right there.”

Aubrey just huffed. “Well I WAS, going to share my thoughts but, now I’m not.”

Freya was glaring daggers at Chloe.

Mary, sensing the tension, asked “So… Vote?”

“Okay, huh I mean I expected more of a split really only Aubrey and Laura thought I wouldn’t be willing to share Aubrey because they are right, Mary is an exception. That was the lie.”

“Explain…” Freya gritted her teeth.

“Pretty, sure I already did. You have clearly been interested in Mark and Mary since you showed up. Mary here is clearly interested in you, we can all see it.”

“So you think I should just join the Harem, compete?” Freya glared

“Why shouldn’t you have to compete if you want a piece of the action? Because you clearly do. Why should any of us be okay with Mary or Mark sleeping with you or doing anything with you? I don’t dislike you, but I don’t like that you think you should get to sit on the sidelines. Mary I’ll tell you this, I’m going to hold it against you harshly, if you do anything with Freya, and don’t intend to add her to the harem. So you two need to figure your shit out, because you know the top two complaints that people have voiced here? We are at risk, and we have to share you, Mary. Now I’m not happy about those facts, but another person wouldn’t make that much difference. Freya is a nice person but if she isn’t willing to be our equals, she has no place in your bed.”

Freya’s face softened a bit. “I don’t disagree. Not really.”

“Chloe, I wasn’t going to do anything with Freya.”

“Really Mary? With how much you’ve ogled her in front of all of us you really expect us to believe that. The only ones you’ve ogled so brazenly besides her are Talia, Aubrey, and Merida. We aren’t blind. And are you really telling me that right now if we were to have that orgy, you would order Freya and Hilde to go wait in the closet?”

“We aren’t having that orgy.”

“See that isn’t your choice actually. Since you know there are enough people here that we could just have one without you. Now answer my question.”

“Probably not.”

“Exactly. Thank you for being honest with us. Also I’m glad you put that rule in about doing something we would regret, because I really wanted to be spiteful for a moment but that would have crossed a line I don’t ever want to cross. But I’m perfectly willing to be mischievous. So Mary, I’m giving you the desire to play more games tonight.”

Mary groaned.

“Mary, it’s okay to be honest.” Allie said.

“Yeah, Mary the others might not notice but Allie and I can.” Flora commented.

“Notice what?” Sam inquired.

Allie answered “Well Sam, remember how Mary here said she was turned on by transformations, what do you think all the stuff we have been hitting her with are? Even if temporary, we messed with her thinking multiple times. Pretty sure if any one of us or even all of us wanted to, we could take her over to that bed and do almost anything to her. She is soaked, we can both smell her juices. That groan she made, that wasn’t frustration, it was one of delight. Think about it. She is now a she, when a few hours ago she was a guy. She can’t stop thinking about having an orgy with everyone, breast envy, breast acceptance, wanting to play more games which will almost certainly lead to more transformations and then doubling down on that and a desire to buy transformation candies. I’m surprised she hasn’t climaxed from this. I'm pretty sure that if Mary stands right now we’ll find a wet spot. Also notice how she hasn’t even bothered telling me to stop. I did tell you all, she is really perverted.”

“OH” Something had suddenly come to Allie, she leaned over and whispered to Sam, “You need to do the closet thing, with her like right now. Don’t ask her permission, just walk over to Mary. You’ll need to tie up Freya. She will try to stop you. Then take Mary’s hand and lead her in there, I’ll stop anyone else who gets in your way. It’s part of the plan”

Well crap. Sorry Freya, guess I’m tying you up. Sam got up and walked over to a dazed Mary. “Hey Marry you, okay?” Sam was not prepared for Mary to kiss her.

“Okay, I think that’s enough of that.” Freya intervened, pulling Mary back off Sam, but not seeming annoyed with Sam herself. “Mary is clearly out of it right now.”

“Yeah, you’re right Freya, maybe we should get her to bed.” Sam said this while undoing the clasp on her belt. Freya stood and Sam made her move quickly, tying Freya's hands behind her back with her belt.

“Let go of me.”

“Sorry, Freya, I'll explain later.” As Sam pushed her down on the couch and grabbed Mary’s hand tugging gently to which she didn’t resist in the slightest following Sam happily.

“Sam, what do you think you’re doing?” Laura exclaimed the loudest but most of the others said something similar and Laura started to move to go after the two.

Allie slammed the table hard, and yelled but with a controlled voice. “Stop, you need to let them go!”

“Explain and fast. Because Mary is clearly not able to think straight.” Laura demanded

“She’s fine, just really horny. Sam and Mary need this. So let them be. I don’t know what they are going to do inside there and I don’t care. It will be a positive thing for them, but if you go after them and stop them it will be a problem for them. So don’t.”

“This is your walkthrough?” Talia asked and got a nod in response. “Laura, you should let this happen.”

“What? Seriously?”

“Laura, tell me do you really think Sam is going to sexually **** Mary?” Talia replied

Laura went quiet for a moment. “No, she wouldn’t do that. Not unless literally compelled to, by magic.”

“Right and there is no way Allie would have told Sam the info if it would trigger that because of how damaging to Sam it would be. So sit down. Freya sorry but even if I wanted to we can’t free you. Sam clearly did it because you have the standing order to stop people from doing what Sam is doing.”

“I get that.” Freya began to reposition herself. “Thank you Allie for your explanation, it apparently freed me from the compulsion to stop Sam, since no one seems to have a serious problem with it anymore.”

“So, did anyone keep track of who won?”

“I did,” Talia chimed in. “It came out as:”

1st: Chloe, Sam (Tie)

3rd: Merida

4th: Laura, Aubrey (Tie)

6th: Ellen, Allie (Tie)

8th: Hilde

9th: Freya, Talia (Tie)

11th: Flora

12th: Mary

“So, we are dressing up Mary tonight right? Once Sam finishes with her.” Aubrey asked.

“Of course, she placed last, she has to face the piper. But I think it’s fair that She gets to dress up, Freya, Talia and Flora too.” Laura chimed in.

“Woah, we said that only those below ninth would have that.” Freya protested.

“No… We said. ‘The bottom three place holders.’ Now Mary makes one, Flora makes two and then you and Talia are in the next lowest spot. So that means you two.” Laura corrected her. “You should really pay attention to the rules.”

Freya realized she was right, Mary would get to dress her up. Hilde started to laugh.

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)