Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 15 by Ray Charles Ray Charles

Who is it?

[Vote] Lucy his other cousin

Opening the door, Ben is immediately thrown, or rather shoved, to the ground as his better-looking and acting cousin-in-law, Lucy, had once again acted just like a cat and pounced on Ben the second he had opened the door like she was a tiger or something, and that wasn't even the worst of it, as the worst came when the two of them somehow managed to start rolling into the house like giant wheels of stupidity!

Only when they both crashed into Ben's bed did Ben stop hating his cousin once more... although in his defense it would be kind of hard to be angered at someone who was pressing both her pussy and tits on your crotch even if they were both covered by clothes... it also helped that Lucy seemed to be more than a little out of it given her constant panting.

After about five minutes of Ben trying to make sure his cousin was okay, not get a fat boner in front of her face, and ignore what appeared to be an invitation for some fun. But he knew better than to do so since Lucy was the type of girl that'd tell you she loved you and that she's never stopped loving you since that time you first danced, and then suddenly BAM! There's about fifty people all around laughing and making fun of you on your own birthday! Lucy finally begins waking up as she lets out a somewhat sexy groan, "Ugh, sorry about that, Benny boy!" Lucy says as she then sits up on top of Ben's face, showing no real signs of either caring who's at the bottom or seeming to have any attempts at stopping this.

Heck, in fact, it honestly seems like Lucy full-on knew for a fact Ben was underneath her giant skirt dress thing and was loving every second of having him there given how much she was rocking her hips back and forth as she very obviously tried to hold back her moans or hold them in as she began talking about her reason for doing all of this in the first place.

"So I was in the neighbooorhoood and I noticed that Sunny seemed awfully angry... well, angrier than, like, usual anyway, and after hearing how much you seemed to trigger her, I was like wondering if you wanted to hang out sometime?" She said as she finally turned back and finally got off Ben's face as he gasped for air and just as he was about to say no she pulled out her phone (where honestly who knows as her dress didn't have any sort of pockets and only seemed to exist to show off her figure.) Which at first didn't seem like much; that was, however, up until the point she showed off Sunny's number listed directly on the screen of the phone, meaning this wasn't a question but in fact ****!

Which honestly wasn't above Lucy's style in any sense of the word, as she once made some random girl cry a river just so she could win a prize, and not some important kind, as it was the prize of getting the poor girl's order for herself since Lucy either didn't have any money or felt like giving it up for some coffee and treats.

So after getting changed real quick into another pair of clothes, this time just a straight-up green and black shirt with ten on it and cargo pants that he wore through the rest of his high school life, he walked out the door with Lucy hanging onto his arm, who Ben swears had a star twinkle in her eye or something for a split second before the door to his house closed as they began their little (****) date.

Their first destination was of course at Ben's favorite Burger Shack that made his favorite Chili Cheese fries that Lucy also got which was very weird since almost no one to Ben's knowledge really like Chili fries that much or rather almost no one he knew about liked Chili fries enough to order them along with Ben as they'd all usually just take some or all from Ben's plate while he wasn't paying attention like his mother/wife and all his other girlfriends including oddly enough Gwen.

However, she was probably just trying to figure out how to make it for Ben, as after she ate enough Chili fries, she seemed to be able to make them good enough or similar enough to the dish from this Burger Shack whenever he was craving it, as apparently Ben didn't like it when her master ate something that unhealthy for multiple days of the week or even at one point wanted it every day for an entire month.

Anyway, back to the (****) date: everything is mostly fine other than Lucy making Ben's life hell by constantly asking him about his college life, what kind of girls he likes, and if he actually has a girlfriend or not, and while that itself isn't bad, the fact that she was slowly pulling apart her buttons to her shirt dress to the point of almost ripping it open in order to show off her breasts is what made it fucking HORRIFYING to Ben.

Because you see, while Lucy herself is skilled enough to absolutely destroy any poor bastard that even attempts to do anything she doesn't want to do and probably turn them into a girl in the process, she was still somewhat of a girl at the end of it all and liked to be complimented and looked at. However, her parents seemed to have this sixth sense whenever their daughter was doing something and would get after her by either FaceTiming her or running off towards her location.

Most of the time it was almost always a combo move on their part, and while most of Ben and his family get along, even in this universe, given how many time sheets his mother still has from how many people had attended Thanksgiving the year before and who RSVP'd what they'd like in advance this year. He wasn't really willing to risk getting shot at by some old gay couple that's seen one too many bounty hunter and old-timey western movies and are more than willing to reenact their favorite scenes from said movies.

Thankfully, or rather unthankfully, it seemed like Lucy didn't like the fact Ben said he was currently seeing someone, as he tried to hide the fact he was in fact seeing far more than one person, with three of them being actual blood relatives of his. Once Lucy seemed displeased, she quickly rebuttoned up her shirt dress as best she could, forcing Ben to stitch it up even further like they were still kids or something.

However, what Ben didn't see as he was focused on his cousin's somewhat revealed bra and tits was that Lucy was breathing a bit harder as she was filled with a bit more lust than she knew what to do with since the person she's loved ever since she was a kid was right there playing with her breast (really just fixing her torn dress)!

Lucy was trying her best to hold back as much as she could since she didn't want to freak Ben out, as apparently in this new timeline Lucy was still mostly the same bitch of a cousin she's always been, but since Gwen has now been Ben's **** since day fucking one of their lives, she's seen the two doing things together that weren't exactly normal for even their twisted relationship.

Which made things all the worse for Lucy's life, as after that happened, and she experienced what masturbating felt like for the first time, her little baby crush on Ben started growing more and more to the point that she almost always chats with Gwen with updates on everything she and Ben do, along with how Lucy could win Ben over, not really knowing that Gwen herself was a bit jealous that Lucy could be openly dating Ben and not her.

But over the course of their lives, Gwen started to feel bad, and only recently did she try and unfuck the situation she had made involving her cousins either dating or, at the very least, having fun with one another like she does with Ben at least once every day and night.

Which is what currently led to Lucy trying her best to flirt and attract Ben as best she could, all while failing miserably at doing so as she A) got jealous when he said he was seeing another girl, even though she knew he was technically right as he was probably still fucking Gwen, given their little shared messages, and B) even in this universe, she still did the same prank that knows her old version did to him.

But that wasn't going to stop Lucy from having fun and getting with the guy of her dreams especially when she still had the ability to **** him into continuing on their date for however long she wanted. And right after some Chili Fries she wanted to taste what her future man's favorite smoothie flavor, if any, might have been, as she wanted to know everything he liked and become his perfect wife!

At Mr. Smoothies, Ben is very hesitant to continue this **** date with Lucy as every alarm bell inside him was ringing like there was another world war about to commence or something. Meanwhile Lucy was just on cloud nine drinking and actually enjoying the smoothie Ben said he liked a whole lot more than she thought she would, especially after eating an entire tray of Chili Fries that she tried so hard to like for Ben.

Nothing really noteworthy happened at the Mr. Smoothies for Ben to get too hurt about, but for Lucy, she basically wrote an entire damn chapter about every small thing Ben did that day in her little journal before they eventually left it as well in order to get to one of Ben's many homes, as Lucy wanted to have some fun of her own with Ben before the night finished.

All while a girl with long, silverish hair watched in rage while three of her friends tried their best not to calm her down. What, are you crazy? They're a bunch of little shits that instead fan the flames like it's Dark Souls or something and try their best to rile their friend up further and further to the point that while she wasn't going to do anything right now as she "wanted his last moments to be peaceful and happy."

Going to what was basically the sex house, as it was the first and last place he went with all the girls to record a giant orgy sex tape, and before they entered, Ben did his little knock in order to make sure that Julie and her mother were fine and everything as they borrowed one of the rooms for a bit to talk and "talk." What shocked Ben however was the fact that when the door opened Julie seemed to be wearing her Tennis outfit along with her mother and given that the A/C was on and yet these two were sweaty enough for their clothes to be somewhat see through let Ben know something was up.

Entering the room, Ben honestly had no idea what Lucy wanted since this honestly wasn't even breaking the top ten list of weird shit Lucy has done to Ben to the point that this is the reason that he has so much PTSD that he honestly didn't even comprehend that Lucy may have liked him and wanted to fuck him even as she stripped off all her clothes and tried to sexily pose for him.

Seeing this pissed Lucy rightfully the fuck off, and she **** Ben onto the bed as she kissed him lovingly and began crying a bit, "Why? Why do you love Gwen and not me!?" She cried out as she slowly began just bawling as hard as she could onto Ben's chest as he let her cry everything out (which took about twenty minutes) before he pulled her up and kissed her on the lips just as passionately as she did before.

"Well, for one thing, Gwen never pantsed me in front of the whole family before or tricked me into wearing my best suit knowing it was going to rain in the coldest weather." Lucy just giggles at this statement and tries her best to act all cute and innocent as Ben takes off her bra and panties as best he could while he makes sure to caress each and every point of arousal on her body.

Which wasn't that hard since Lucy had been holding back since she opened the damn door about three hours ago, and it certainly didn't help when Julie and her mother were watching the two in the doorway, sort of like how Lucy did with Ben and Gwen, just replace the slightly open door with a window and Lucy being outside to get a scene-to-scene reenactment.

Ben began to slowly caress Lucy's nipple as he sucked the other one, causing her to cry out in great pleasure even before he actually began pleasing her with his other free hand. This, of course, went on for about five minutes with Ben shifting between the two tits and his hands every so often as he wanted to make Lucy feel as loved as all his other girls since there's no way someone who was practically ready to **** him wouldn't be in need of some good clean fun, right?

Of course Ben didn't let Lucy climax, as what would be the fun in that? Lucy wanted to feel like how he treated all the other girls in his harem, and Ben was going to give her the full course meal with all the bullshit specials she could ever ask for. So once Ben was finished teasing the poor girl and amping her up, he finally began to fuck her like the eager bitch in heat she was, which was also the same point in time when Julie and her mom began cumming as well.

"So how does it feel to be like all the other girls?" Ben whispered in her ear as he flicked and twisted her nipples a little bit before he grabbed her by the ass and began ramming into her as hard as he could to the point it didn't take long for Ben to realize that Lucy wasn't going to be able to walk for quite a while after this but continued on anyway as she had the biggest smile on her face that was full of lust and bliss almost like she was high.

In fact, Lucy was so out of her mind that she could only babble like a damn baby as Julie and her mother kept going at it; this time, however, they began helping the other out, as their own touch just wasn't doing it as much anymore for either of them. Ben pulled Lucy up for a quick kiss on the lips before he eventually bit down on her neck, giving her a hickey that would last quite a long time, making Julie and, for some reason, her mother very jealous.

Getting tired of just ramming into Lucy over and over again, Ben picked up the poor, barely conscious girl and slapped her ass a bit and groped her breast in order to wake her up since he wasn't about to continue if she was passed out as he didn't feel too comfortable with the laws of consent if he did that. Thankfully, she did, and Ben kissed her as hard as either of them could ever want as he fell on the bed with her in his arms, acting the most romantic he could while his dick was still inside her.

"I've always loved you, BENNNN!" She tried to say it lovingly, but Ben had to ruin it by moving as he continued fucking her to the best of his abilities while they hugged and kissed like lovers until eventually they both came, but since Ben wasn't sharing or had any other plans, he continued on with Lucy, "Hey, you two can come out now. I mean, I don't think Lucy can keep me all to herself if she is this tired." Ben said jokingly as Lucy surprisingly stood up and even more surprisingly somehow pulled out Ben's toy blaster.

"Oh, yeah! Well... I don't think so!" She screamed out as she then pulled the trigger without any real warning or chance for Ben to try and calm her down, as Ben barely had enough time to close his eyes as tight and as hard as he could....

A/n: That is it for now tune in next week and I won't be doing a poll for this but would love your thoughts on what happened anyways. Also here is an actual poll link for some stuff I've been thinking about and would like some help deciding: https://strawpoll.com/eJnvV4BjEnv

What's next?

More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)