"It would be hot if you sucked my dick and cum leaked out of your cheek."

Okay dude, she said 'anything that you're thinking of', but you weren't supposed to take that literally! She was asking for an honest compliment, not for you to fantasize about her giving you a blowjob! Like, yeah, that would be hot, but you weren't supposed to actually say it out loud! Alena was already dealing with a lot of self-esteem issues and now you've probably made it worse.

'Oh, my biggest insecurity was accidentally shown to a stranger, but don't worry, he said he'd gag me with his cock!'

That's you, man.