"I wish I was Natalie's walking wet dream."

"Fine, if I'm still not good enough for Nat, then I wish I was her walking wet dream!" Jake says with a bit of ****.

"Well, you're the boss!" Jean snaps her fingers, and Jake closes his eyes. For a moment his whole body goes cold and numb, before immediately gaining feeling again. Though when his senses return to him he notices that everything feels different.

"What the hell?" He looks down, expecting to look like some roided out jock, since that's what he thought Nat was into. But seeing his body, he's barely gained more muscles mass than he had before, still causing him to look big, but not nearly as big as some guys in school.

He walks over to a mirror and looks at himself, seeing a familiar face that's not really his own... "Why do I look like... Jack?!" Jake's face has become that of the school's opposite to Ruby, the man with a body count higher than his IQ. Jack's sole goal in life is to fuck as many girls as possible, and apparently he's close to what Nat sees as perfection.

Jake turns to Jean angrily. "What the fuck? I didn't want to turn into Jack!"

With a sigh, she gives him an annoyed look. "Do you still not understand how these wishes work? Obviously this is what Natalie sees as perfection."

Jake remembers earlier in the day when he saw Jack talking to her and Holly, he saw the look of lust on her face. The realization starts to sink in that his wish did come true, in a way. He's now Natalie's walking wet dream.

He dejectedly examines himself further, noting that while he looks similar to Jack. His body and face is obviously enhanced a bit further, probably matching what fantasy Nat has of him in her mind. "Shit, I can't just go back to Nat now, she'll think I'm just Jack at this point."

Jean floats around, pretending to lay down in the air with her hands behind her head. "Sorry dude, I don't know what to tell you."

Jake looks at his personal Genie, suddenly feeling something strange. His cock starts to stand on end as his eyes become glued to her tits. "Woah... Did you always have those?" He asks in awe.

"Huh? Oh right... Jack has a crazy high libido, and Natalie's ideal version of him has an even higher one. Have fun with that..."

Jake's face flushes red, he feels a throbbing in his pants while just staring at the curvy Genie in front of him. His mind clouds over a bit, his rational thinking going out the window. "You seriously do look pretty fucking hot..."

Jean giggles. "As hot as Nat?"

"...Nat?" Jake thinks to the girl he originally tried to fuck. Suddenly her original allure has quadrupled itself in his head.

"You should be finding her way hotter now, it's what she would want."

The girl in his sister's room... Just down the hall. She's perfect, in every possible way. Her neck length black hair, her above average tits, they all look perfect in his head. "I think I'll go talk to her after all..."

Let me know how you feel about the story, and feel free to add your own chapters or give suggestions. You can also vote for what happens next here: https://strawpoll.com/polls/poy9R54b3nJ