Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 16 by Darthinteresting Darthinteresting

What's next?

Menage A Trois or whatever

Two hours into his Date with Felicia, Peter decided to go back to serious topics.

"Felicia, can we be very honest for a few moments?" Peter asked.

"Of course," Felicia said. "What's on your mind, Peter?"

"I guess my main concern is that this place is going to **** me to have a harem," Peter said. "I've noticed you skirt around the topic, but I still don't know how you felt about me in your universe. So, my question is how would you feel about getting with me while knowing that I'll be with other people?"

Felicia blushed. "I never really saw that as a problem. I mean, yeah, it kinda is a problem, but I'm bisexual, so I see this as a win."

300 Dollars Earned: Patrol Completed: Come out to Peter Parker!

"Oh," Peter blushed. "So..."

"Ok, I'll just put it all out there," Felicia said. "I'm interested in getting to know everyone well, as long as everyone else is interested in that as well, or something similar."

"That makes sense," Peter said. "I just want to say that our Date has been great Felicia, and I really think I can fall in love with you, and I look forward to a lifetime with you."

4 Webs Earned: Get Peter Parker to a point where he thinks he can fall in love with you.

Felicia looked at Peter in confusion. "What was that about?"

"It's something I found out," Peter said. "If I genuinely mean it, you earn 4 Webs. I just wanted to help you out, so I said it."

"Don't do that again, please," Felicia frowned. "I understand that this place demands something out of us, but I don't want to unnaturally progress our relationship because of that. You'd have admitted that anyways sometime today, it kind of ruins how genuine you are, you know?"

"I understand," Peter said. "I'm sorry for ruining that for us."

"All's forgiven," Felicia said. "I understand why you did it, you are Spider-Man after all."

"I guess I am," Peter said. "I don't think I am a good one, though."

"Peter, like I told you earlier today, I think you have to be the best," Felicia said.

"Spider-Man saves everyone, doesn't he?" Peter asked. "Yet here I am, letting Anne get turned into some perverted symbiote."

"You don't have to," Felicia said. "Why do you think she has to lose?"

"Our date went to shit," Peter admitted. "Then she tried coming on to me in bed, and it was just awful."

Felicia winced. "I can see how that can stop you from starting a relationship, but Peter, I don't think that's reason enough."

"What do you mean?" Peter asked.

"Peter, how do you think you reacted when I found out you were Spider-Man?" Felicia asked. "All you knew about me was that I was Liz's best friend, and I hated you. Safe to say, our friendship started as shit. Before the spell, you and I used to go on patrols together! Just because it opens up badly, doesn't mean we can't make this work."

"You're right," Peter said. "But it doesn't seem plausible."

"After the spell, my Peter and I still went on patrols occasionally," Felicia told Peter. "Because I forgot about our whole relationship outside of the masks, I asked him why he did what he did. Do you know what he told me? He said 'Spider-Man can't save everyone, but he damn well will try. And Yoda said that do or do not, there is no try, so I give my A Game, all the time.'"

"Emma would disagree with you," Peter said. "Personally, I agree with you, but Emma thinks that attitude is futile, and I kind of agree."

"Emma wants to sabotage Anne during the Challenge," Felicia said. "I think she should, Anne knows it's coming too, so the battlefield is fair. I think that you should be Spider-Man, and we should be who we are."

"I kind of understand what you're saying," Peter said. "I'll think about it."

"You do that," Felicia said, standing up. "I have some preparation to do for our night together, so I'll see you at dinner, ok, Spider?"

"Of course," Peter said, standing up as well. "See you tonight, Felicia."

Felicia hesitated for a second, then she gave Peter a French kiss.

50 Dollars Earned: French kiss Peter Parker!

"See you tonight, Spider!" Felicia waved as she left a shocked Peter behind.


As soon as she left the Date Floor, Felicia turned into a woman on a mission.

"Edith, where's Anne?" Felicia asked.

"Ms. Weying is on the entertainment floor, Ms. Hardy," Edith informed Felicia.

"Take me there, please," Felicia asked.

"Certainly, Ms. Hardy," Edith said as the elevator started to rise.

At the entertainment floor, Felicia found Anne sitting in front of the TV and watching Bridge To Terebithia.

"So," Felicia said as she sat on the couch. "You have one bad day and you just give up and watch sad movies, is that how it is?"

"You have no idea how bad it went," Anne grumbled. "Leave me alone, Cat."

"Nice to know that you know a version of me," Felicia said. "And no, I won't leave you alone. I actually have a chance for you to work with Peter, and I can guarantee a chance of success above 40%."

"And why would I want to bet on such low odds?" Anne asked.

"It's better than your current odds," Felicia said.

Anne paused the movie with a sigh. "I suppose you're right, I might as well hear you out. So, what's your grand plan?"


Peter sat down for dinner and cleared his throat.

"Guys, I wanna make an announcement," Peter said hesitantly. "My conversations today with both Emma and Felicia made me realize that my demand of not using the Gift Shop is more problematic than beneficial, because I am demanding you to be what I want, and that's not how a relationship works. So, I realized that I can't really enforce that, and I shouldn't attempt to. Obviously, if one of you buys something that hurts someone else without reason I'm just not going to like you, but I recognize the necessity of the game, especially considering how Olivia would have just been a supervillain without her TF."

"How does that align with your morals?" Olivia asked.

"It doesn't," Peter said. "But lording over you and taking advantage of the authority the Directors gave me isn't right either."

"I see," Olivia said. "You're choosing your moral standpoint, and allowing us to choose our own morals as well. That is rather humble of you, Parker."

"Will this realization affect our agreements?" Emma asked.

"Honestly, not really," Peter said. "Felicia pointed out to me that Spider-Man can't save everyone, but he damn well will try."

"I understand, darling," Emma said. "You know that I cannot promise to you not to use the Shop, but I can promise you to try to find the best options available."

"You know that I'll try my best to understand," Peter said.

"That is a remarkably healthier conversation than yesterday," Felicia commented. "I'm happy for you two."

"I'm sure you are," Emma said, then she winked at Felicia flirtatiously.

Felicia looked back and forth between Peter and Emma with a blush.

"Uhh, what's that about?" MJ asked, noticing the interaction.

"Well, I might as well go all out," Felicia muttered. "I'm bi."

"That's good for you, dear," May said.

"Huh?" Ava said.

"Wasn't it a known fact?" Natasha asked.

"What do you mean, known?" Felicia asked.

"You haven't been discreet about admiring everyone's bodies," Natasha said with a smile. "I knew since day 1, and I align with you, to be honest. Live as a spy for over 80 years, and you learn to enjoy a lot."

"I've known since the first day as well," Emma grinned. "So did Peter, he just let you tell him."

Felicia glared at Peter. "You acted like you didn't know!"

"Sorry," Peter said. "How was I supposed to tell you that Emma caught you staring at her chest?"

Felicia blushed. "Was I that obvious?"

"I didn't know," MJ offered.

"I didn't either," Ava said, then she blushed. "Wait, so other you from my universe was actually flirting with Peter and I at the same time? I thought she was just riling us up while trying to escape!"

"Ok, I don't know other me's sexuality," Felicia blushed. "But why was I trying to escape from you guys?"

"You were robbing the Triskelion," Ava said.

"What the fuck?" Felicia said.

"Don't ask me," Ava said. "I think you were a kleptomaniac, to be honest. Peter met you while you were robbing Kingpin; you two had a weird relationship in my universe."

"Ok, robbing Kingpin is something I did," Felicia admitted. "But I am NOT a kleptomaniac."

"You just admitted to robbing the biggest crime boss in New York," Natasha said.

"Yeah, because he had a drive with information on every superhero," Felicia said. "I couldn't let him keep that. And if he was a couple hundred thousand dollars poorer when I left his office, well, it wouldn't hurt him, he's a crime boss."

"Wait, you steal money?" MJ asked.

"Only from crime bosses," Felicia said. "Not to sound bigger than I am, but it's kind of like what SHIELD or any other government organization would do. I take their money and use it for new equipment, or I donate it. I do admit that I live a lavish lifestyle, but that's from my family money, and none of the money I steal gets mixed with that."

"She's right," Natasha said. "It is a rather normal concept."

"Don't you feel wrong?" Peter asked curiously.

"That is your failing," Olivia said. "It is your right to take advantage of your enemy's defeat. I have lived as you, your webs and tech aren't inexpensive, and you typically sacrifice most of your paycheck towards webfluid. If you used Kingpin's money, you would be able to be less frugal, therefore you'd advance your technology at a faster rate, and stop crime faster."

"I thought that about my world's Peter as well," Natasha said. "I should've told him."

"Well, we're telling this Peter what he needs to hear," Anne said. "And frankly, none of us are going to see the Peters from our old universes again, so don't get stuck on that. This is our new universe, and we are each other's only versions or variants or whatever. So let's let go of the past, and work together to a better future, a better Peter, a better Anne, a better Emma, a better everyone."

1 Web earned: Push Peter Parker 1 step to accepting the reality of the Show.

Once everyone finished dinner, Felicia pulled Peter to the side.

"Peter, before we head upstairs to your room, I wanna run something by you," Felicia said hesitantly.

"Ok?" Peter asked.

"The idea came to me during our Date, to be honest," Felicia said. "I'm not sure if you'll say yes, but I want you to consider it, so —"

Peter put his hands on Felicia's shoulders. "Just tell me what you're thinking, and I'll give it an honest thought and give you an honest answer."

"How would you feel about sharing the night with Anne and I?" Felicia blurted out.

"Were you afraid that I'd say no?" Peter asked. "Don't you remember the first night that I slept with Emma and Natasha?"

"Yeah, but you guys didn't fuck," Felicia said. "I kind of assumed that you didn't want to do something like that."

"That's not why I didn't want to do it," Peter said. "Emma and Natasha were very angry at each other that night, and I just didn't want to start anything because of that."

"Ohh," Felicia said. "Well, Anne and I share a bed every night, and we haven't had problems, so... Are you cool with a threesome?"

"Yeah," Peter said. "But, I want to fix things with Anne before we get to the fun parts."

"Of course," Felicia said, kissing Peter on the cheek. "I promise you won't regret this!"

Peter laughed as Felicia excitedly ran to go call Anne.


Ten minutes later, Peter was in his room sitting on his bed.

Felicia had told him to go to his room and wait for them, and so Peter listened.

The elevator doors opened, and Felicia and Anne entered.

Peter raised an eyebrow at them, and they grinned.

"What's wrong, Peter?" Felicia asked. "You expected us to wear something else?"

"Uhh, kind of," Peter admitted with a blush. "Hoodies and pajamas are nice, though."

Please log in to view the image

Please log in to view the image

"Don't worry," Anne teased. "We're wearing more risque outfits under this, I just wanted to get the serious out of the way first."

"Oh, that makes sense," Peter admitted embarrassedly, then he went to his mini fridge and grabbed everyone some soft drinks. "Here you guys go."

"Thanks, Peter," Anne said as she opened her can and took a sip.

"Well, are you two going to avoid the elephant in the room, or should I do it all?" Felicia asked. "Damn, you two are so awkward."

"You try finding something to say to the dude you came onto two days ago and he rejected you," Anne countered.

"Ok, focusing on the other night won't work," Peter said. "It ended in shit, we can move on."

"Actually, I don't think you should," Felicia said. "Let's talk about why your Date was shit. Both of you guys made one big mistake, you focused on the aspect of the Hotel. Peter, out of all your dates that went well in this place, were any of them focused on the objectives of the Hotel?"

"No," Peter realized. "We usually focused on stories from our universes or common interests."

"Exactly," Felicia said.

"Well, I don't have another option to redo our Date," Anne said.

"No, you do," Felicia said. "Just spend some time with Peter tomorrow or the day after while he's not on a date!"

"That's actually a good idea," Anne turned to Peter. "Peter, can we go on a nonofficial date tomorrow, whenever you're free?"

"Definitely," Peter said.

"I'll expect an orgasm from each of you as payment for fixing your relationship," Felicia said. "Anyways, I wanted to comment on how I hate that all of our clothing is themed. Like, can't I just wear a simple white pair of pajamas, does it need black cats?"

"I just wear whatever I tell Venom to create," Anne admitted. "Venom prefers themed clothing or black and white colors, so I entertain her."

Peter and Felicia shared a look of realization.

"Wait, you're basically always naked?" Felicia asked.

"No!" Anne exclaimed, then she blushed. "I mean, it might seem like that, but I've never really thought of it like that, nor have we ever considered it nudity. If Peter ever had the symbiote, he'd agree with me."

"Mmm, I would pay for that," Felicia said. "Spider, you mind getting a symbiote? I'd love to think of ways to get you naked. Venom, you think I'd be able to convince a symbiote to reveal their host?"

"If you give me enough chocolate, I'll do it," Venom said.

Anne glared at Venom embarrassedly. "You're supposed to be my partner!"

"Venom," Felicia said, half seriously, half teasingly. "I'll get you a shit ton of chocolate tomorrow, if you get Anne naked except for a strap-on right now."

"Felicia!" Peter and Anne both exclaimed.

"What?" Felicia asked. "Anne, you know it'll be fun, don't act like you're not down."

Anne blushed.

"I'll do it for a pound of chocolate," Venom bargained.

"Venom!" Anne admonished.

"First thing after breakfast, you get your chocolate," Felicia promised.

In a split second, Venom changed Anne's outfit so that she wasn't wearing anything except for a panty that had a dildo strapped on.

Please log in to view the image

"I've always wanted to try Eiffel towering," Felicia breathed with stars in her eyes.

"What the hell is Eiffel towering?" Peter asked.

"It's where she does my butt and you do my pussy, and you guys go to town on me," Felicia said. "Can we please do it?"

Peter stared at Felicia, who turned on her puppy eyes.

"I guess I'll do it if Anne wants to," Peter said.

"Yes!" Felicia turned to Anne. "Can we please Eiffel tower?"

"I'm game," Anne said.

"Oh, I'm so thankful, I'd let you two fuck the shit out of me," Felicia said, then she threw off her pajamas, revealing her lingerie.

Please log in to view the image

"See what I mean by themed?" Felicia asked as she did a little spin. "It's so overdone."

"It is hot though," Peter admitted.

"You still haven't taken your clothes off, mister," Felicia said. "Anne, mind giving me a hand?"

"Not at all," Anne said.

"This wasn't how I thought today would end," Peter noted as Anne and Felicia diligently helped him take his shirt off.

"Felicia, how about we double tag him first?" Anne suggested as she unzipped Peter's pants.

"Oh, I don't have any problem with that," Felicia said, pulling down Peter's pants and his boxers in one go.

"You won't ask for my opinion?" Peter teasingly asked.

"Are you going to say no?" Anne playfully pushed Peter onto the bed.

"Never," Peter said as the two women gave his dick an experimental lick.

Please log in to view the image

After a few awkward licks, Anne and Felicia found a pattern. One of them would lick from the bottom to the top, while the other would lick top to bottom, then they'd suck his tip or his balls, then they'd go the opposite way.

"You two are so good at this," Peter moaned.

"Teamwork makes the dream work," Anne giggled after giving his tip a soft kiss.

"If this is a dream, don't let it stop," Peter said, gripping the sheets as Felicia juggled his balls in her mouth.

"It's not a dream, Spider," Felicia said. "It's the rest of your nights."

Peter's dick twitched at that.

"Oh, you like that thought?" Anne teased.

"Every single night," Felicia licked up his dick.

"At least a woman or two in your bed," Anne sucked his balls.

"Fucking you, loving you," Felicia sucked his tip.

"However you want," Anne licked him.

"Taking your dick," Felicia licked him.

"Having your kids," Anne sucked his tip.

"Fucking after patrols," Felicia sucked his balls.

"Loving after putting the babies to sleep," Anne licked his dick.

"I'm going to cum, you two are painting such a nice picture," Peter grunted.

"How about you paint our faces?" Felicia suggested, then she kissed Anne over Peter's tip.

Please log in to view the image

Peter groaned as they circled their tongues over his dick while interlocking lips, then he came all over their faces.

60 Dollars Earned: Suck That Dick!
60 Dollars Earned: Suck That Dick!

Please log in to view the image

"Mm, tasty," Anne said, then she licked Felicia's face.

Peter watched mesmerized as the women kissed each other, licking the cum off of each other's faces.

Please log in to view the image

"Let's get you back up to speed," Felicia suggested, giving Peter's soft dick a lick. "Anne, could you get to preparing my backdoor?"

"It'd be my pleasure," Anne said, diving between Felicia's asscheeks.

"You guys bring some crazy creativity to sex," Peter grunted.

"We'll get more creative over the years," Felicia promised.

After a few minutes, Peter and Felicia were both ready, and Peter carefully inserted himself into Felicia's pussy.

"Ok, I'm ready," Felicia said to Anne.

"I'll spread her legs for you," Peter said, grabbing Felicia's legs and spreading them.

"Ok," Anne said, then she materialized her "strap-on." "I'm going to go in small, then I'll make it a good size when it's inside, ok?"

"Just get to the fun part," Felicia said.

Anne pushed forward.

"Oh, that doesn't feel like a LOT!" Felicia said, her voice rising as Anne expanded in her asshole.

"I told you what I'd do, why are you surprised?" Anne teased.

"That felt like something," Felicia breathed, falling back onto Anne.

"You can back out," Peter said, seeing Felicia's state.

"No," Felicia said. "I feel so great right now, you can't imagine."

"I don't really want to," Peter said drily.

Felicia started humping her hips back and forth experimentally.

"C'mon, get to fucking the shit out of me," Felicia said. "I can't do all the work!"

Anne and Peter shared a look, then Peter slammed hard into Felicia, pushing her into Anne.

Anne slammed back, and within seconds, Felicia was moaning wildly and holding onto Peter for her life as Anne and Peter passed Felicia to each other with pussy shattering slams.

"So much for doing all the work," Peter grunted.

"Her ass is squeezing, if you can call that work," Anne said, grabbing Felicia's nipples and twisting them.

Felicia loudly came, but Peter and Anne continued to fuck her.

"O-o-h m-y-yyy-- Ga-aaaa-aw-d," Felicia moaned.

"Do you think we should keep going?" Peter asked Anne genuinely as he saw Felicia's fucked stupid expression.

"Eee-ey-yyeee ca-an take itttt," Felicia grunted in between slams.

"You heard her," Anne said, thrusting up and grabbing Felicia's asscheeks.

Felicia came three more times before Peter neared his climax.

"I'm close," Peter said.

"Insiiiide," Felicia said barely conscious.

After a few more slams, Peter came inside her, drawing one last orgasm from Felicia as she dropped her head back onto Anne's boobs.

90 Dollars Earned: Fuck The MC!
100 Dollars Earned: Threesome With The MC!
100 Dollars Earned: Threesome With The MC!

"Is she ok?" Peter asked, seeing her half open eyes.

"She's going through a sex coma," Anne noted. "I thought that wasn't real."

"What is that?" Peter asked.

"It means she's been fucked stupid," Anne said simply. "Now let's lay her on the bed."

Anne carefully pulled out of Felicia, then Venom vanished the strap-on. Peter pulled out next, and they layed the semiconscious Felicia on the bed.

Please log in to view the image

"It's my turn now," Anne said with a grin. "You wanna share the work again, or should I do it?"

"Leave the work to me," Peter said, guiding Anne so that she was doggystyle on top of the still semiconscious Felicia.

Please log in to view the image

"Oh!?" Anne said, dropping down and kissing Felicia's nipples.

"Yeah," Peter said, rubbing his dick against Anne's wet pussy.

Within a minute, both of them were ready, and Peter smoothly sheathed himself.

"Well?" Anne said, shooting Peter a teasing grin. "Fuck some babies into me!"

"Oh, it's on," Peter said, shoving his dick all the way in.

"Use your strength," Anne ordered after a minute. "I can handle it."

"Are you sure?" Peter asked.

"I've taken full strength punches from you, I can take a good fuck," Anne said. "Let all that aggression out, Spider."

Peter amped up his thrusts a little, but Anne just laughed at him.

"You're giving me love taps!" Anne exclaimed. "Fuck me like you hate me!"

Peter grunted as he thrusted harder.

"My arms aren't even moving!" Anne said. "Are you that weak?"

"I'll show you weak," Peter grunted, then he slammed into Anne while using nearly all of his strengths.

"That's - the - shit," Anne moaned as Peter fucked her face into Felicia's tits.

Please log in to view the image

For the next ten minutes, Peter and Anne grunted and moaned as they roughly fucked.

"I'm going to cum in you," Peter grunted.

"I'll - take - it, and - I'll - take - your - babies - too," Anne moaned.

Peter came, and as he spurted into her, Anne came as well, leaking some of his cum out.

90 Dollars Earned: Fuck The MC!

Peter pulled out and he dropped to the bed as he lay down. "Oh, I'm spent."

"Me too," Anne grunted, rolling off of Felicia and into Peter's arm.

"We're going to have to talk about your bruised butt," Peter said sleepily.

"Tomorrow," Anne promised as she fell asleep.

Peter fell asleep before he could respond.

Please log in to view the image

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)