Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)
Chapter 24
by
triangletoast
Can Sarah hold out?
She tries her hardest
"That's enough Steven." Callum began taking command now that he'd raised the stakes here. "Daniel, Lacy. Which one of you wants to go next?"
The siblings gave each other a knowing look and then both approached Sarah together.
"We'll take our turn at the same time." Lacy said, biting the right side of her lips as she waited for Steven to get out of their way.
"Works for me." Callum shrugged. "I think our girl can hold out long enough to let me claim the prize."
"But, that's not.... that's four fingers....she...she can't!" Lacy's fingers may have been small and slender, but Daniel's hands were bigger than anyone else here. The thought of those fingers deep inside Sarah coincided with her own finger tracing across the tip of my cock through the fabric of my underwear. My whole body was twitching as I stayed hopelessly on edge, always just one more touch away from splattering in my pants.
They either didn't hear me, or ignored my comments. Steven standing up and raising his two glistening fingers to his face. I can't imagine how wet she must have been, because the fingers were completely covered and dripping in her sweet nectar. Steven opened his mouth and was moments away from getting to taste them, when Callum grabbed his forearm.
"Come on man, only the winner gets to taste her." They were staring each other down, until flashed his eyes at me. "Now go wipe them off."
Steven was visibly disappointed, but did as he was told and used my shirt as a towel to wipe off on. I should have been angry at how they were treating me, but instead my mind was busy unraveling the hollow dissatisfaction. I was feeling. Disappointment? Was I also disappointed he didn't get to taste Sarah?
I pushed the thought out of my mind. No, no I was just on edge from her hand rubbing my crotch. I needed to calm down and support her if we were going to win this. Because I, I didn't want to win... I needed to prove to these guys I was just as manly as they are.
Finished wiping off my girlfriend's juices on my shirt, Steven sat back down and the siblings began taking their turn with her.
"I know you like it hard, but I like to take things slow baby." Daniel told her.
"OhhhHhhhHh, thaa, that's ooookkaay." Sarah said as her eyes began to roll back in pleasure. It wasn't long before the two had her squirming more than Steven had, her sensual drawn out moans filling the room.
Daniel was crouched down low, one hand inside her while another gripped her thighs. Lacy was leaning up against her, her other hand lightly teasing her body as she whispered into her ear just loud enough for me to hear.
"You still think our touch can't compare to your little man's?" She asked Sarah but her eyes stared right at me. "You think he could make you feel anywhere near this good?"
I could feel the waves of pleasure pulsating throughout her body as the pair brought her closer and closer to orgasim. Sarah didn't answer but it also didn't seem like the question was even for her. The look in Lacy's eyes told me that she was talking to me, asking if I had what it took to really pleasure a girl like Sarah.
I didn't answer her either, not verbally at least. I couldn't see myself, but I knew that the answer to her question was plastered all over my face.
"Mmmhhhhhhaha." She ran a finger up Sarah's soft waist as she giggled. Caressing higher and higher until she reached her breast, circling the stickers Sarah had covering them. "These are a bit trashy, don't you think Liam? Why don't we just take them off...."
Her fingers grabbed the corner of the heart shaped sticker, slowly peeling it off as my heart raced faster and faster. It wouldn't be a perfect view from my angle, but Lacy was about to give me my first look at Sarah's fully exposed chest.
"I..ahhh... I can't keep myself up." Sarah moaned out. I need to lean against your back Liam, or..ahh.. or there's no way I'll make it."
Her head was back as she looked at me in the corner of her eye. One hand still caressing me while the other was held up to her mouth. She was biting the tip of her thumb, looking at me with a desperation she rarely had. I couldn't say no to her like that, even as a certain part of me was aching to see more of her.
I hesitated for a moment trying to get even a glimpse of naked nipples but Lacy had stopped, clearly waiting for me to turn around before she would reveal them. My back now pressed against Sarah's, I could feel her body shake as the pasties were pulled off one by one.
"Ohh these are so cute!" I could hear Lacy say. "Don't you think so Daniel?"
"Mmmm definitely." He said back. "I can see why you're obsessed with the sluts tits Callum."
"Stare all you like." Sarah said between breaths. "Even if you take a picture, they'll still won't belong to you!"
It almost seemed like she was trying to give them ideas now. But, but Sarah just wasn't that kind of girl. She had both hands caressing me now, no longer taking it slow but clearly trying to push me over the edge. Her hands pumping up and down my throbbing cock through that one layer layer of clothing.
I tried my best to hold on. To block out her soft moans, the wet slapping noises of her pussy being fingered by two hands, the amazing feeling of her hands rubbing against me. It was all so much but what did it say about me if I came right here, as a group of strangers used my girlfriend.
Through clenched hands and scrunched toes I held on, and maybe I might have even made it if that was all I had to endure. But then, for the briefest moment a bright flash filled the room.
I came before I realised what it meant, or maybe it was simultaneous. Biting my tongue, I stifled any moan as rope after rope of my cum was pumped straight into my underwear. Sarah could feel I was cumming, and was determined to mild every last drop out of me as it began to seep through.
I hoped nothing about us had given it away, that everyone was too focused on Sarah to notice me. Because if they'd known I'd just cum as a naked picture of Sarah was taken the last shred of respect they have for me would be gone.
"Alright times up." Callum put his hands on the siblings shoulders.
"You've done to make it this far ginger tits, but do you really think you can handle me?"
Can she?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)
Can't we let him stay?
It'll only be for a day or two, right?
Finally moving in with his long time girlfriend, their first night together is interrupted by a familiar face who needs a place to stay...
Updated on Jun 1, 2026
by Decadent Empire
Created on May 29, 2023
by triangletoast
- 14,384 Likes
- 2,594,539 Views
- 2,306 Favorites
- 1,822 Bookmarks
- 306 Chapters
- 42 Chapters Deep
- All Comments
- Chapter Comments