Refuse to pick

"No." Even with my head still spinning, there was no way I was about to let this happen. "No, we're not going to have sex in front of you guys, and absolutely no you're not going to!"

Just thinking about any of them having sex with Sarah shot my heart rate up, and I wasn't about to succumb to their stupid game and ruin the perfect night we had planned.

"How could you think I would allow-"

"Settle down now little man, there's no need for a tantrum." Callum interrupted me with a smug condescension. "Nobody said anything about fucking your girl."

Sarah stood behind me and began rubbing my back like she always did to help me calm down. I haven't even realised but I was standing now, with my fingers digging into the palm of my hands.

"You said-!"

"Shhhh, shhhh. It's ok." Sarah whispered into my ear in a sweet low voice. "Nothing is going to happen that you won't enjoy. Now let's just hear him out, alright Liam?"

It's a little shameful to admit the effect her touch and voice had on me. Even with my outrage, I still couldn't help but be turned on. I wasn't normally this easy to set off, but all the teasing tonight must have been keeping me on edge.

I relaxed my palm and tried to control my breathing, Callum taking this a sign he should continue.

"Two fingers." He wiggled them in front of me, like a taunt. "Two fingers and two minutes to get a nice feel of her. Either you man up and do it or we all get a turn."

Two fingers? We'd fooled around a bit with our hands before in the brief moments we had alone, this wouldn't be taking things too much further. I didn't like doing this in such a non-intimate way, but after being called little man one too many times I was ready to prove myself to the group.

"I-"

"Liam doesn't have anything to prove to you guys, isn't that right!" Sarah said, her hands changing from the soft rubbing to a tighter grip of my shoulders.

"I, I guess. Umm. Yes." I stumbled regaining my mental footing from Sarah's interruption.

"See, he doesn't need to lower himself to your level." She was right, I got so caught up with Callum's childish taunting I forgot I shouldn't be engaging with it.

"The first time he feels inside me will be a magical moment, and we're not going to let you guys ruin that!"

"Yeah!" Sarah moved in front of me and stood defiantly, hands on her waist with her chest out.

"And he's ready to prove it by watching you all finger me!"

"Yeah- uhh." My mind didn't quite believe what my ears were hearing. It wasn't until my eyes reported the sight of Sarah bending over to pull down and step out of her stockings and thong.

From behind I was blessed with a view of her bare ass, but from the front with her legs apart everyone would have a clear view of her now exposed pussy. She had left the fishnets on the ground, but grabbed her thong into her hand.

"How about we start with... you!" With both her hands she stretched the tiny thong and shot it like a slingshot, hitting her mark right in the face.

Steven grabbed the pair, clearly taking a deep sniff of them before balling them up and putting them in his pocket.

"Well, never keep a lady waiting I always say."

"Wait umm, I-" I tried to move forward and block the muscular blond from approaching, but Sarah put her hand on my chest stopping me.

"Stay there Liam, I need your support for this." She glanced back at me and flashed a quick genuine smile, before returning to watch Steven crouch down below her. A very similar look in her eyes now, to the looks she'd been on the receiving end of.

"Mmm wow." Steven said, his hands slowly running up her thighs while his face was inches away from her most intimate area. "So smooth and wet, I love a clean shaven girl."

I didn't know she'd shaven down there. She must have done it in preparation for what was supposed to be our special night. Now, instead, this stranger moved his hands between her legs and I could feel Sarah tremble as he must have made contact with her.

"Should I be gentle baby?" He asked. His eyes staring up at her while his fingers teased her skin.

"Noo." Came Sarah's reply. Her tone was needy, **** even, in a way that seemed to surprise herself. She cleared her voice and composed herself before adding. "S-slow and gentle is for lovers. This is just you feeling how good my 'tight pussy' feels."

She broke her gaze with Steven and looked back at me, the hand on my chest slowly moving lower.

"Isn't that right Liam? They're just fingering me to see how it feels. Nothing more."

My throat felt bone dry and clogged. Like there was so much I wanted to say all the words were blocking me from saying anything. Sarah's hand skillfully slid under the band of my pants resting once again on the twitching bulge I had that wouldn't go away.

She bit her lip and gave a sly smile, taking a silent answer to an unspoken question. "So go as hard as you'd like. I can take it."

A man of his words, Steven didn't wait a moment more to begin his onslaught. The wet noise of his fingers violently entering her revealing how fast he must have been thrusting then into her. Her hand gripped me tight in response to the sudden and intense penetration, and small grunts and moans escaped her lips.

"S-so Does.. Does it feEL gOod?" She asked, clearly fighting to even remain standing.

"It feels amazing baby, but I'm thinking you feel even better right now." He seemed to enjoy making her squirm, quickening his pace in response to every moan that escaped her lips.

"Mmnngh, This- ahhh, t-this is NOthing.

"Is that so?" Callum said, leaning back in his seat as he watched the show. "What do you think Liam?"

"It- it's just a little feel." I wasn't sure why I said the words, there was no pretending this wasn't something more. I couldn't see directly what was happening, but Steven clearly was doing more than just feeling inside Sarah. He was giving her a finger fucking and with Sarah's hand griped tight on me and beginning to shake, I wasn't sure how much longer either of us could last.

"That's right." Callum smirked. "So let's make it a little more interesting. If Sarah makes it through the punishment without breaking down and cumming like a slut, we agree to admit you're more man than all of us."

Even as Callum laid out his new bet, Steven didn't let up. One hand relentlessly working her pussy with the other gripped her plump ass. Her breaths were getting quicker and shorter with every passing moment.

"But when ginger tits does cum. Whoever pushed her over the edge gets to taste her fuck hole."

The bet was ridiculous. The reward wasn't even close in worth to letting one if them take another of Sarah's first from me. And the odds were ridiculous stacked against us! No one had even been timing Steven so far and it must have been more that two minutes already! Sarah was clearly already close to the edge, and there were three more rounds to go.

I knew all of this, but still the words came out of my mouth. Sourced not from my brain, but from a need buried so deep inside me I'd never known it was there.

"You're on."