Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 4 by archer15 archer15

Whose story to follow?

Cordelia

“So you and I aren’t getting married to Xander in your alternate reality?” I asked as Anya finished explaining everything about the wish.

“My reality is the base reality,” Anya protested, badly. “And I was getting married to Xander, but then he backed out, and I used a wish and…well, here we are.”

“What’s the problem? Let’s just get back to the wedding.”

“Before that happens, I need to know everything that has occurred. Wishes always have a dark side to them.”

“Fine, I kind of like the idea of everyone waiting for me to come down the aisle,” I responded. “Fire away.”

“When did you and Xander start dating?”

I smiled at the memory. “It was after he helped save us all from the frat bros. Reptile demon, was a patron…”

“Yes, Xander regaled me with the story. How he ended up dressed in women’s clothing and…”

“What?” I said with a laugh. “Xander in women’s clothing? I mean, he’s pretty open minded, but I don’t think I’ve ever seen that.”

“In your world, how did he get in?”

“Well, he…Xandered. He marched in, confident, acting like he belonged, you know?”

I watched as Anya took a few deep breaths, “Could you describe Xander for me? Like what traits stand out?”

“Don’t get me wrong, he’s a loser. A loser I love, but his best traits come from me,” I took a few moments to think about how to describe my husband-to-be. “Tries to be funny, takes charge when the chips are down, romantic, doesn’t eat healthy, he…”

“Wait, romantic?” Anya cut in. “Since when?”

“Like always. Well, I guess about the time Buffy showed up. She was trying out for the cheerleading squad and he got her a bracelet.”

“Willow told me this story. It went poorly for him. Tried to act like it was a just friends thing.”

“That’s how Buffy took it, but that girl is blind,” I said. I still remembered the speech Xander had made as he had presented that bracelet to Buffy. “It was the single most romantic thing I ever witnessed. His sincerity was something I’d never seen any guy have. It actually blew me away.”

“But you didn’t start dating him then?”

“No, social circles and all that. I mean, if I knew Buffy was going to cold shoulder him…”

“He and Buffy never got together?” Anya asked.

I glowered at her, which was hard to do with how beautiful I looked, “Oh, they got together.”

“With how you say that…wait, I’m getting ahead of myself,” Anya said as she pulled herself back. “Let’s go back to when the two of you started dating. Describe what happened with Xander at the frat party.”

“So I got Buffy to go with me to the frat party. Ugh, Buffy. Anyway, it wasn’t just a bunch of cute rich frat boys, but a demon worshiping cult. We got **** and then four of us were locked up in the…”

“Four? Who were they?”

“Buffy, Cassie, Dawn, and myself.”

“Dawn?”

“As if Buffy wasn’t bad enough, she had to bring her sister along as well,” I said. It had been a nightmare when the two of them had shown up with Buffy’s Mom insisting she tag along to what was supposed to be a friendly party. I should have known something was wrong when the frat didn’t say anything about another girl. “Anyway, we were locked down in the basement when Xander came marching in. He’d gotten some of the frat boys above to spill the details and knew that we were on the menu for the reptile. Except a big thing was that we had to go unspoiled, so he got to spoiling.”

“What do you mean?”

“How graphic do you want me to be?”

Anya fidgeted, “Spare no details.”

“He took Buffy first. Not sure what he said to her. It all happened so quickly for me. I was freaking out and next thing I knew he was naked with his dick up Buffy’s pussy. He didn’t even take the time to unchain her, just spread her legs and began to fuck her like mad.

“It didn’t take him long to cum, but that didn’t even slow him down. He moved over to Cassie and whispered in her ear. It was a totally different approach than Buffy. Cassie had endured a lot and he took the time to make sure she understood what was going on. It also gave me my first chance to see his dick. Wow.”

Anya nodded her head in understanding. At least that hadn’t changed.

“While Xander fucked Cassie, Buffy ripped her chains out of the wall. She then broke mine and Dawn’s. I could hear a loud commotion upstairs and Buffy went to cover the door. Xander came inside of Cassie and then turned to me.”

Cordelia rubbed her thighs together as she remembered the scene. Xander naked advancing on her, Cassie falling to the ground, exhausted in more ways than one now, Dawn panting beside her. “I was ready for him to fuck me, but instead her told me to get on my knees. I couldn’t even find my voice to retort and followed his command, instinctively opening my mouth. He shoved his cock in and I got a taste of his cum and the two girls he had just fucked.

“I eagerly did everything he asked. He told me to get naked, I did. He told me to finger my cunt, I moaned around his dick as I slammed three fingers inside myself. He told me to beg, I whimpered from my knees about how I needed his dick more than I needed anything else in my life.

“He took me like a dog. Had me on all fours and entered me from behind. I remember how he grabbed my hair and yanked my head up. I was staring…staring at Dawn as she masturbated. Any thoughts of danger had fled her mind and she was fingering herself watching me get fucked like a bitch.”

I stopped talking, but Anya wanted more, “What happened with Dawn?”

I shrugged, “I don’t know. I passed out. I guess Xander fucked her. Not sure how it went, things between him, Buffy, and Dawn were pretty icy for a while.”

What happened after Reptile Boy?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)