When She Was Bad

Changes 5

“Did I ever thank you for saving my life?” Buffy said as she danced close to Xander. After all they had done she knew a sexy dance wasn’t going to be enough to drive him away.

“No,” he whispered back to her.

“Have I ever let you fuck my ass?” Buffy whispered in his ear.

“No,” he said again.

“Don’t you wish I would,” Buffy said as she walked away.

Prompt 5

When She Was Bad 29:58

Prompt: Xander says: “Mine’s nothing special, it’s the same size as the ones in the porn I watch with her.”

Impact: +3

Scene: Giles, Xander, and Buffy are talking about what’s wrong with Buffy when she walks up on the group, Xander quickly changes the conversation.

“Mine’s nothing special, it’s the same size as the ones in the porn I watch with her.”

“What?” Giles said, confused.

“What’s going on?” Buffy asked as she came up.

“Oh, yeah, um, porn,” Giles said uncomfortably. “Xander was just saying…uh…”

“I was just telling Giles about how Willow and I got together,” Xander said as he took Willow’s hand.

During the Summer

“So how are you dealing with Buffy not being around?” Willow asked as they hung out watching TV.

“What do you mean?”

“That the two of you were having sex on an almost daily basis, and now she’s in LA for the rest of the summer,” Willow pointed out.

“Well, I’ve still got one of the greatest porn collections known to man,” Xander told her. “That’s getting a pretty daily watch from me.”

“Um…” Willow said as she looked at the TV. “This show is pretty boring, maybe, maybe we should…watch some?”

Xander took a few moments to appraise his friend, “Sure.”

Night 1

“Wow, his penis is huge,” Willow said as the man took his clothes off.

“Eh, it’s a pretty normal size,” Xander said with a shrug.

“For porn?”

“For guys. I mean my dick is about that size. Anyway, I think the camera makes the dick look a little smaller.”

Willow thought the camera did the opposite, but she didn’t say anything as the actors discarded their clothes and got straight to the sex, “Is it always this quick?”

“Usually, we can stop if it makes you uncomfortable.”

Willow stared at the screen, “Maybe just watch this one scene.”

Night 2

“Do you have a favorite?” Willow asked as they watched Flashpoint.

“Not really, there are a lot of girls I like,” Xander said.

“Favorite guy?” Willow asked.

Xander laughed, “Doesn’t really make much of a difference to me. What about you? Favorite guy? Girl?”

“Um…kinda,” Willow said in a meek voice.

Xander barely picked up on it as they went back to the movie.

Night 3

“So in porn lesbians are just kinda everywhere?” Willow asked, they were watching an edition of No Man’s Land.

“I guess. It’s a big guy fantasy.”

Willow watched as the blond and Asian girl played with each other, “Like I get during threesomes, but how many girls are there that just want to have sex with other girls at the drop of a dime?”

Xander shrugged, “No idea, we don’t have to watch this movie.”

“No,” Willow said as she kept her eyes on the screen. “Let’s watch.”

Night 4

“Okay, enough,” Willow said as she looked at Xander.

He quickly paused Debbie Does Dallas, “Is there a problem?”

“Masturbate. I can tell you are uncomfortable watching this. It’s silly for you to hold back.”

“Will, I mean…” Xander began, uncertainly.

“I’ve heard all about your sex times with Buffy, walked in on the two of you twice, I know what you do when you watch alone, it’s silly for you to hold back just because I’m here.”

“If that’s what you want,” Xander said as he pulled out his cock.

Willow suppressed the moan she knew would be coming and put her eyes back on the screen. Patience, she told herself.

Night 6

Willow waited until his breath began to pick up, telling her he was close to orgasm, “Xand?”

“Um…yeah?”

“Is it okay if I touch myself as well?”

“Yeah, of course,” Xander said without hesitation.

Instead of reaching under her skirt, Willow pulled the entire thing off,showing Xander that she wasn’t wearing panties and had a freshly shaved pussy.

“Thanks, I’ve been needing this,” Willow said as she pushed two fingers inside of her pussy.

Night 11

The next step required a bit of time and luck. Each night Willow had moved closer and closer to Xander. She knew she was turning him on, but also knew he was still confused about what to do about this. She wasn’t out of the friendzone yet.

And then finally, when they were sitting next to each other, a shot of his cum landed on her arm. Before he could apologize she brought it to her mouth and licked it clean, “Wow, tasty. Hey…would it be okay if I got some more directly from the source?”

“Me first,” Xander told her.

“What are you…” Willow began as she was suddenly pushed down on the couch and Xander dove her head between her legs.

“Xander! Yes!” she cried as he devoured her pussy.

Night 15

The porn played in the background, but it was now only a minor focus of their night. They still put it on, but they quickly changed to licking and sucking each other to numerous orgasms.

Willow was stroking his cock with one hand as she rubbed it against her pussy, “I want to put it in, Xand. Fuck me, please.”

“Will, your first time should be with someone you love. I love…”

“Shhh,” Willow said as she kissed him. “I love you. I always have. Even if there is someone else for you, I want this.”

“I do love you,” Xander told her. “If you’re sure.”

Willow kissed him again as she sank down on his cock.

Present

Buffy stared at them as Xander finished telling her about how he and Willow had connected over the summer. She watched as he leaned over and took Willow’s hand. “Dating?”

“Yeah,” they both told her.

“Whatever, the Master…” Buffy said as she changed subjects both to discuss the new danger and to hold back her tears.

Changes

• Buffy and Xander in love
• Buffy jealous, realizes she wants Willow and Xander