No other option

“Here” you announced, holding the phone in Lucy’s direction for her to take.

She seemed cautious to take the phone given that she hadn’t confirmed who you were talking to but she still picked it up from your hand and brought it to her ear. With Lucy having your phone, you realised how reliant you were on it and now that you didn’t have the KDK on hand in case anything went wrong, you felt more **** than you had first expected.

“Hello?” you heard Lucy greet, not managing to make out what Emma was saying on the other end of the line.

You could see Lucy relax when she heard who it was that you had called and it seemed she trusted your girlfriend more than she trusted you as she lowered her guard even further. You weren’t sure what Emma had planned either but she didn’t seem to be lucid enough to explain even if you would have had the time to ask.

“Really but I saw him…” Lucy started to say, stopping mid-sentence as you assumed she got cut off.

Lucy gave you a raised eyebrow at whatever Emma was saying but she turned around and headed to the corner of your room, whispering down the phone and making it so both sides of the conversation were now unknown to you. Lucy would occasionally send glances your way as if she couldn’t believe what she was hearing and the snippets you did here when she raised her voice weren’t very helpful.

“But he was looking at…”

“Why would you…”

“He never mentioned…”

All short phrases that made you gain a bit of confidence as you saw Lucy continually get interrupted. You hadn’t said this to Emma but given that it sounded like she was half asleep, you hadn’t had the highest confidence in her ability to convince your sister but it looked like your worries ended up being unfounded.

The conversation went on a little longer until Lucy seemed to have finished interrogating Emma, with Lucy handing you back your phone and you looking down to see that the call had ended before she returned it.

“So is that all sorted?” you asked, trying not to say anything specific in case you said anything that conflicted with what Emma had said.

Lucy surprisingly sat at the side of you on the bed and held the bridge of her nose, looking like she was trying to make sense of whatever she had heard.

“You really are one lucky bastard aren’t you” Lucy asked rhetorically, instantly making you lose all confidence in whatever story Emma had somehow concocted.

“...W-What do you mean?” you couldn’t help but ask.

What followed was Lucy explaining what Emma had said which ended up being mostly the truth. She hadn’t made up anything to try and deceive Lucy like you had expected and there was nothing you could say in response as Lucy talked about what she had heard. There was no mention of the KDK either or any mention of what the two of you had done with Sarah thankfully but Emma had gone into a bit more detail than she probably should have.

She had explained her kink and how she had been the one to first suggest going after her mother. You, on the other hand, had suggested everyone else which was as close to the truth as you could get without bringing up the KDK. Lucy did blush when she had to repeat that Emma was aware of what me and Lucy had done together and you couldn’t but smile when you saw Lucy acting embarrassed at that confession.

You weren’t sure if it had been Lucy continuing to ask her questions while interrogating Emma or if she decided to spill her guts just so that she could go back to sleep but Lucy was now in the loop about Emma’s fetish a lot sooner than you had planned. You had to admit, Emma had said she would get it all sorted out and from the reaction Lucy was now showing, she had done just that.

Some of your plans for the future would now need to be tweaked and the ones for making sure Lucy didn’t freak out at the cuckquean revelation could now be scrapped. You could say that Emma had now done the hard part in telling Lucy the truth so it was now up to yourself to make sure Lucy didn’t react too negatively. You also made a note to yourself to never ask Emma for help with your schemes if she was even remotely tired.

“So now that you’ve heard from Emma, do you wanna ask me anything?” you started, wanting to give her an opportunity to question you as well as Emma.

Lucy raised her head as she thought about what to ask, giving you a chance to look at her without being spotted. Despite all your arguments you couldn’t help but be attracted to her when you weren’t at each other's throats. She wasn’t dressed to impress or anything like that but the casual clothes she wore before she went to bed were loose enough for you to catch a glimpse at her bra every so often.

She wore an oversized t-shirt that just barely covered the black denim booty shorts that she had on and if you hadn’t seen her wearing something similar beforehand then you would have assumed she was wearing nothing underneath that t-shirt. Her outfits had always been on the risky side and that was doubly so when she was relaxing at home, giving you glimpses underneath her clothes that she’d then tease you for when she caught you staring.

“When did you find out about Emma’s…” Lucy started to ask, breaking you out of your thoughts

“Fetish? Kink?” you interrupted, finishing her sentence when she seemed too embarrassed to finish it before getting a nod from her.

“I think it was the same day that you came back from college. I asked her out and she told me about it after that. Granted it worked out the best for me but it seems she didn’t want to reveal it before as it wasn’t something she needed to tell me until then” you explained, twisting the truth a little to avoid mentioning the KDK.

Lucy seemed to accept that response but she still continued to stare at you, seemingly watching your every move to see if you were telling the truth.

“I still think you are hiding something. The two of you that is” she responded, her intuition correct but you weren’t planning on telling her just yet.

“Of course we’re gonna be hiding something. I’m not gonna tell you about every little detail of our relationship and I don’t expect you to do the same with your boyfriend” you replied, hinting about the fact that you were still keeping one of her secrets.

She seemed to actually agree with you for once as she nodded her head regarding the secrets that you and Emma may share. Plus it seemed that she didn’t want you mentioning her boyfriend again and decided to just end the conversation and get up from the bed. You could have ended it just like that after everything Lucy had brought up but a part of you wanted to push things a little bit more as you although you had stopped the worst from happening, you hadn’t actually made much progress with Lucy in terms of getting her on your side, not even managing to add even one more second to her KDK total.

Still, as she got up to go to the door, you found yourself wondering if you should call out to her