Offer a new role

“Hey, just one more thing” you announced, stopping Lucy in her tracks before she could reach the door.

“What? This better not be another attempt at blackmailing me again as you know that isn’t going to work” Lucy replied, turning back towards you with a slightly annoyed look.

“No nothing like that. It’s nearly the opposite actually but come here and sit down first” you said, patting the side of the bed next to you to get her to join you.

She tutted at you but still did as you asked, sitting back on the bed but closer than she had been before.

You hadn’t actually put much thought into what you were about to suggest yet but both Mom and Lucy had both said you were bound to get into trouble sooner or later if you didn’t be more careful in what you were doing. Sure you had Emma there as she knew the entire truth but given that she wanted to take things just as far as you, if not further, you decided you should at least have someone there to keep you grounded in reality.

A part of you did want to see how much you could get away with before things went wrong but that was part of the problem. Emma wasn’t going to stop you and the only one who hadn’t actually given in to your advances so far was Lucy. You still wanted her to fall under your spell but if you could get her to believe that she was still in control, then hopefully she wouldn’t react as badly when you took things further. To do that though, you needed to give her some power, or at least the illusion of power over you.

“You mentioned that I need to be careful about what I’m doing earlier in the hallway and I’m trying to take that to heart. I’m not planning on stopping what I’m doing with everyone but I think I need someone to stop me if I ever take things too far” you explained, hoping Lucy would take the bait.

“And you think that ‘someone’ should be me? Why not just have Emma do it?” Lucy asked back.

“Well Emma can get just as excited as me. I mean just this afternoon she spread some of my cum on Grace’s pillow just so that she would be able to smell it later on. Can you believe that?” you asked.

“Y-Yeah that’s a bit…ummm” Lucy responded, her cheeks flushed as she imagined the scenario.

You knew you could hopefully tempt her using her own kink as an incentive and from her reaction just now, you carried on.

“Mom also isn’t a good fit as you know she's not gonna disagree with everyone else in the room. So, you're the best person for the role in my opinion” you continued, waiting to see how Lucy would respond.

“And what would you actually want me to do? There's no point in saying I should be stopping you without you actually listening to me when the time comes” she replied, making a valid point.

“Well I could come to you when I think something might be crossing the line or maybe we could test some things to see if they would be an issue. Like the pillow thing for instance. I don’t think Grace is going to notice but it would be useful if I could know for certain” you said, once again trying to lure her in with her own fetish but getting a cautious look in return.

“You’re gonna have to give up more than just that if you think I’ll be able to help you. S-sure I can help you test some stuff but without something to actually hold you back then there's not much point. It has to actually be something that would make you reconsider following through with your plan if I decide against it” Lucy outlined, making you consider something you could give her without putting yourself at too much of a disadvantage.

You carefully considered your options while Lucy waited for you to answer, happy to sit there once she realised you were taking this seriously. The only thing that came to your mind without being too debilitating would be information. Giving her something that she could then use as **** sounded like an utterly stupid idea but it was better than giving her access to your phone or something like that.

At first the information you thought to give her was something about yourself but an idea struck you that seemed perfect for the situation.

“Hold on one second. And no peeking” you said to Lucy before getting up and heading to your desk, searching through your drawers to find what you were looking for.

You had bits of stationery lying around and you picked up a stack of envelopes that had been sitting there for who knows how long, taking 6 out of the pack and placing them on your desk. You made sure Lucy couldn’t see what you were writing and slipped a piece of paper into each one of them, sealing them shut and putting a name of each before returning to your sister.

“So each one of these contains what I believe to be that person's kink or fetish. I’m 99% on these so I think they are accurate but if you were to show them what was inside then they would likely lose some of the trust they have in me. Both because I’ve shown you and because I’ve actually written it down. I don’t want you to open them but the fact that you could open them or pass them to the person in question, should be enough to stop me in most situation” you explained, passing the envelopes to Lucy as she read the names.

She saw her own and gave you a knowing look but it seemed she had other questions on her mind.

“Who’s Rebecca?” she asked, picking up the envelope at the bottom of the pile and showing you the name you had written.

“She's someone from school” you replied, giving a plain answer.

“I’m gonna need more than that if this is gonna be of any use” Lucy responded, shaking the letter as she spoke.

“She’s… one of my teachers” you found yourself admitting, watching Lucy’s eyes widen at your admission.

“Your teacher?! I mean, how did you.. You know, nevermind. I don’t think I even want to know” Lucy responded, stopping herself from asking.

She would have normally asked you every question under the sun just to get as much information out of you as possible but it seemed that even this was too much for her to take in all at once. The rest of the envelopes seemed to be names she expected and after telling Mom the same six names earlier, that left only Grace and Rebecca out of the loop. Maybe Sarah as well, considering she wasn’t aware of all your current subjects but you didn’t expect her to freak out like Lucy did so she wasn’t much of an issue.

Lucy still had the envelopes in her hands as she flicked through them but you were still waiting on an answer.

“So do we have a deal? Are those enough for you to consider taking up the role?” you asked, waiting to see how she would respond.

Author's note: Spoiler chapter will be updated shortly :)