Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 8 by BeckyS BeckyS

What's next?

Letting Go

Over the next couple of weeks, for the first time there is a palpable tension in the penthouse. While Smart and Sweet have quickly clicked into a perfect couple, you have found yourself wanting to spend increasing amounts of time with Pichichi. From the moment you first laid eyes on the soccer star, you were smitten. You hadn't expected her to come out quite that perfect for you physically. And she also has a laid back, carefree way about her that you really enjoy being around. In fact, when you are with Pichichi you don't even want to turn the experience into a threesome, you prefer to have her all to yourself.

Please log in to view the image

Which is just as well, as a threesome with her wouldn't be on the cards anyway. Porno is never around, Smart and Sweet will threesome with you, but only with each other and no other girl, and you are the only person Loyal will sleep with. On the subject of Loyal, she has seemed a little off with you recently. The amount of time you have been spending with Pichichi hasn't gone unnoticed, and it feels like you are pushing your girlfriends defining characteristic to its limit.

You are dawdling in the kitchen one afternoon, thinking things through, when Smart walks over to you. You recognise this kind of approach by now. It usually begins with her pitching an idea and ends with you agreeing to it. You decide you need to get in ahead of her this time.

"I know everything is going great Smart, but I promised my girlfriend I wouldn't create any more of you from now on"

"Really? I thought Pichichi was your girlfriend now" Smart smirks mischievously. You shoot her a disapproving glance "Oh come on Master, the whole apartment can see she's your favourite. Don't tell me if she was here it the beginning you wouldn't have picked her over Loyal?"

You neither confirm nor deny that. But she's right.

"Look, there is something you can do that will cause some short term pain but will be the best thing for everyone in the long term" Smart continues, adopting a more sympathetic tone "It's not her fault at all. But Loyal really isn't a good fit for what we are doing here. She's holding everything, including you, back. And you are holding her back too"

"How am I doing that?"

"She is a beautiful and loving young woman who most guys would kill to be with. But you are holding onto her while also making her feel second best to another girl she knows full well you have stronger feelings for And you have prevented her from ever being able to move onto anyone else"

"You know I have made it a firm rule never to alter any of your personalities" you remind her.

"Only being interested in you isn't part of her personality, it's a restriction you've placed on her. Removing it would allow her to get on with her life and be happy. We can ensure that financially she will always be in a great place, like we have with my original. We can then bring in another money maker to replace her here, which will mean Pichichi can stay with you and not have to move to the other side of the world for the wage bump we would need her to get."

"We've been using Loyal as the template for the other Maisie's" you point out.

"Then use me and dumb them down a bit" Smart giggles "Look, it's your call Master, but you made me the smartest one here and I'm telling you it is way better to rip the band aid off now than to let this fester and end up doing the same thing further down the line when the situation has completely deteriorated. It's nobody's fault and there is no villain here, but you owe it to Loyal to handle this in the right way"

You know she is right, but this is incredibly hard. So far you have only been bringing new Maisie's into your life, not casting them out. Not to mention you are extremely fond of Loyal, who was literally created as your dream woman and whose only crime is loving you too much to want to share you with anyone else. You really aren't sure quite how you are going to do this,

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)