Confrontation

After John sat back down from showing off his bulge, the topic of discussion did indeed shift to less interesting matters. While Natalie had enjoyed John’s embarrassing display, no one wanted to push things too far, especially since Natalie barely knew three of the four people she was sharing a hot tub with. Twenty minutes or so passed before they decided to get out and dry off. John watched as gorgeous women with wet shirts and shorts climbed out of his hot tub, and then again as two more stunning bikini-clad girls followed, with Dina’s bikini bottoms riding up in the back. Despite the fact that he’d already seen her naked, the sight of her nearly-bare backside once again held his attention, and he knew he’d made a mistake not getting out first. As John climbed out of the tub, he could once again feel a bulge forming in his pants, but he hoped they wouldn’t call attention to it again, especially since it wasn’t at full mast this time. To his relief, they didn’t; At least not verbally. He caught a glance here or there from each of the girls, including Natalie, but no one said anything about his evident arousal this time. Both Hollie and Natalie’s nipples were somewhat visible through the wet shirts. They all dried off with towels, and then Dina and Evelyn went back around front to grab their clothes from the car.

“Do you want us to wait out here while you go in and get dry clothes for the three of us? I doubt our laundry is done yet.” said Natalie. John nodded and went inside to his bedroom. He dropped his wet boxers and tossed them into laundry basket. He paused for a moment, and looked at his half-erect penis. He sighed, and gripped it with his right hand. As humiliating as it was to have to show his bulge to Hollie’s sexy roommate, the whole experience was rather hot; Hollie prancing around his place nude, Hollie and Evelyn showing up in bikini’s, Dina’s doing little to hide her body and in particular her incredible booty, and even Natalie getting a look at his bulge which had been covered only by his wet boxers. Though as aroused as John was, he knew he couldn’t stand there and get any relief while he had the girls waiting. Besides, he was pretty mad at his three coworkers (as hot as they were) for making him show Natalie his bulge in the first place. He threw on some dry boxers. Sweatpants, and a t-shirt, and collected stuff for Hollie and Natalie to wear for a bit. He tucked his dick into the waistband of his sweatpants to conceal it, and went back out to his deck, just as Evelyn and Dina made their way back holding their clothes. He gave Natalie her clothes so she could go in and change first.

“If she’s inside, there’s no point in me waiting…” said Dina, setting her clothes on the deck chair and pulling off her bikini top. John’s eyes instantly went to her tits.

“I think I’ll wait to change in private.” said Evelyn.

“Dina’s got a point, John’s seen us all naked already…” said Hollie, pulling her wet t-shirt over her head. A few seconds later, both Dina and Hollie were completely nude on John’s deck. All four of them could see each other blushing.

“I still don’t know if I’m quite that comfortable flaunting everything.” said Evelyn.

“Yeah, well, speaking of… What was that back there?!” snapped John. All eyes were on him. “I really didn’t appreciate being pushed to show a girl a barely know my bulging cock!” He looked at Hollie. “Seriously, that was humiliating, and I feel kind of betrayed.”

“Okay, calm down John…” said Hollie.

“Why?” asked John, “Do you not like feeling any pressure of judgement? I sure didn’t.”

“John, if you really didn’t like that, we’ll never do anything of the sort again. I mean it.” said Dina.

“Why would I have liked that? What made you think I would’ve appreciated that?” asked John, getting a little angrier.

“Maybe we misjudged things, but I think you enjoyed getting to show off without seeming like a sex-obsessed douche.” said Hollie.

“Excuse me? That was utterly humiliating” said John.

“So was dropping my pants in the breakroom for you after our bet. I felt pretty humiliated then, John.” said Hollie.

“That’s different. You made the bet.” said John

“You’re right. We should’ve talked to you first but, that’s not the point I was making. I was humiliated when I had to show you my bum, but as soon as I got home after that, I sat down on my bed and…” Hollie trailed off for a second as John’s eyes widened. “Well, I got off on it.”

“Same goes for when I stripped for you after our first bet. It was meant to be a silly joke; I thought you’d lose and we’d have a guy in his underwear to laugh about for a minute and then we’d all go about our business. None of this was ever supposed to happen, but then I lost and, well, like Hollie said, I got off on it.” said Dina. “The thrill of having you perving of me, seeing me with so little modesty… It was so thrilling, and arousing…”

“I obviously didn’t go through the same journey to get here that you all did with the bets, but after that night at Dina’s… Yeah, I touched myself after that. Multiple times, even.” said Evelyn.

“I-” started John.

“So yeah, John… If you really hated that as much as you claim, we’ll find some non-sexual way to make it up to you and we’ll drop it forever, but if you feel the same way that we all do, maybe we can have some more fun, with you more in the loop…?” suggested Hollie.

“You can take a second to think about it.” said Evelyn, “I’m pretty sure Natalie just opened the bathroom door.” Dina and Hollie both scrambled to get dressed as Evelyn went in to change, and to slow Natalie down along the way.

“Yeah, okay…” said John, as he watched the two remaining girls throw their clothes back on. “I jerked off hard after seeing Dina strip. I jerked off twice so far about showing you both my dick in the office, and again to the night I went to Dina’s. I’m pretty sure I would’ve jerked off to you today, Hollie, had you not come over, and I had to fight the urge to relieve myself when I went in to get clothes just now, so maybe you’re right. I still would’ve appreciated a little more warning, but maybe that would have ruined the thrill.”

“Well, now that you’re in the loop, maybe we can have a little more fun tonight…” said Dina,