Evelyn

Before long, all five of them were in John’s living room, watching a movie while they waited for Hollie and Natalie’s clothes to finish drying. John sat between Hollie and Evelyn, with Natalie and Dina sat on the ends next to their respective driver. Despite the warm weather, the air felt cold after the contrast of the hot tub, providing a perfect reason for everyone to be nestled under blankets during the movie. That was where Dina’s next suggestion took form; Since Evelyn hadn’t had a bet experience yet, she was to be the subject of the fun. As they got a bit into the movie, Evelyn slowly reached under John’s blanket, and slid her hand into his sweatpants. At first, her hand rested only on his hip, as they subtly glanced to make sure Natalie wasn’t watching. Then, she slid it down to his dick, which was already half-erect. Slowly but surely, Evelyn started stroking it, being careful not to make any sudden motions that might attract Natalie’s attention. Within a minute John was fully erect, and trying to keep a calm demeanor in case Natalie were to glance over. All four of them worried about what Natalie would say if she noticed. A few moments passed as Evelyn worked John’s shaft beneath the blankets, but before either John or the movie could reach the climax, they heard the sound of the dryer going off, and Natalie lept to gather her clothes. Unfortunately for them, Natalie was in a rush to get going, as she had other plans for the evening with her own boyfriend. They said their goodbyes, without John standing up, and the two girls left.

“That was exhilarating. I mean, I’d love a handjob under most circumstances anyways, but that…” said John

“I know! Natalie was right there, and could’ve seen what we were up to at any moment!” said Evelyn.

“That was hot, and I wasn’t even in on it.” agreed Dina.

“Well, Evelyn didn’t finish the job. Since you were the one that started this, maybe you should take your top back off, and drop to your knees.” said John.

“Oooh, taking control again, eh John?” said Dina, lifting her t-shirt above her head to reveal her breasts once again. Evelyn dropped back onto the side of the couch, sliding a hand down her pants. Dina got down on her knees with a grin, before pulling the blanket, and John’s pants away. She licked upwards from his balls to the head of his cock, and then went for it, taking nearly all of it in her mouth. She started slow, and then picked up just a little speed before John stood, took one foot out of his pants and put his hands on the back of Dina’s head. John started thrusting himself. He could feel the tip of his penis touching the back of her throat as he rammed into her mouth again and again. She gagged a little, but didn’t resist. Evelyn’s hand was picking up speed in her panties as well. John loved the view, watching Dina’s tits jiggle as she took his mass. She reached up and grabbed a fistful of buttcheek with each hand. After all the teasing, excitement, and stimulation, it wasn’t long at all before John blasted his load into the back of her throat.

“A little warning next time!” choked Dina.

“Yeah, that’s what I said earlier.” said John.

“I’m gonna go grab a glass of water to wash that down with.” said Dina. With that, John turned to Evelyn.

“I take it you haven’t finished yet?” asked John.

“We’re not all as fast as you, John.” said Evelyn.

“Hey, I had plenty of help getting there today, which is currently what you’re lacking.” said John, “Put your hands by your sides.”

“Okay…” said Evelyn, somewhat hesitantly complying. She seemed a tad confused. Without explaining, John grabbed both sides of her pants and pulled them down to her ankles. Evelyn gasped.

“It’s not like we’re breaking much new ground here, and you’re the only one that hasn’t shown some skin today. Well, aside from Natalie, but she’s obviously a different case.” said John, getting to his own knees. Only a couple seconds later, he had buried his face between her thighs.

“Oh my! I see we’re not done just because John’s finished. A pleasant surprise after last time.” said Dina, reentering the room. John lifted his face from Evelyn’s pussy just long enough to respond.

“You’re next.” he said.

Later that night, John got a text alert. Opening it, he saw that Dina had added him to a group chat with Hollie and Evelyn titled “The Exhibitionists”

Hollie: So… This is a thing now, yeah? We’re going to do more of this stuff?

Dina: Absolutely, we are. If John’s in for it, that is.

Evelyn: I may not be quite as bold as the rest of you, but I certainly hope so!

John thought for a moment before responding. He absolutely didn’t want to waste this opportunity, but he also didn’t want to just be pushed into any situation the girls might drag him into.

John: Keep giving me reasons to participate, and I’ll keep entertaining you all. ;)

Dina: We should do some kind of rotating dare system. There’s three of us girls, and only one of you, John, so that should be plenty of incentive. (.)(.)

Hollie: LOL. Yes!

Evelyn: I reserve my right to say no, but that sounds fun!\

Dina: If it’s really something that makes you really uncomfortable, then everyone has the right to say no.

(Evelyn has liked this text)

John: I’m in.