Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 63 by zankoo zankoo

What's next?

the guys take turns on top of Abbie and Michelle

Tyler nudged Abbie, indicating that she should get up on the couch, which she did. At first she sat, then turned and lay back on the couch, her head toward the middle of the room, and her feet sticking out to the other end toward Tyler. She pulled two of the back cushions from the couch and positioned them under her head, which she then lifted to face Tyler.

"I said, how far are you willing to go?" Abbie smiled.

Michelle stood up and looked at Tyler. "Nervous to be the first fuck?" She climbed up on the other couch, mirroring Abbie. The two women had their heads at the inside ends of their respective couches. They twisted their necks to look at one another and giggled.

"I think the boys expected us to back down," said Abbie. "Tyler, what are you waiting for? I'm naked, my pussy is right here," she reached a hand down between her legs and lightly touched herself. "Do you need a written invitation?"

Tyler pulled on his dick a bit. "You want me to fuck you?"

Abbie nodded. "I do."

He took a step closer to her, though still not touching her. "You want me to push my dick against your pussy?"

Abbie took a deep breath. "I want you to push your hard cock into my soft, little, wet, pink pussy."

Stefan stood up between the two couches, and as he angled slightly toward Michelle, she reached over her head and took his cock in her hand. She pulled him toward her, and leaning her head back further, guided him into her mouth. Dominic stood at Michelle's feet, but like Tyler, he seemed suddenly shy about taking the next step.

Tyler edged closer to Abbie. She dangled one leg off the sofa, mostly to make room for Tyler to get into place. He bent down with one knee up on the couch, and lightly tapped his cock against Abbie's inner thigh. She bit her lip and wriggled at the contact.

"I got you and your girlfriend to come to a party with three strange men. Your husbands aren't here. You got naked, and now you want to get fucked?"

Abbie shook her body, jiggling her tits, and winging at Tyler. "I want to get fucked."

"What do you want?"

"I want to get FUCKED."

Tyler glanced over at Dominic and nodded. In near unison, they each stepped climbed up onto their sofas -- Dominic over Michelle, and Tyler over Abbie. Tyler rubbed the tip of his dick against Abbie's pussy, which was glistening and wet.

"Oh my god, I want that," Abbie moaned.

"You want my cock inside you?"

"Mmm, I need it."

Michelle was quiet, but only because her mouth was occupied with Stefan's dick. Dominic, behind her, spit into his hand and rubbed the tip of his dick. He pushed at Michelle's pussy, eliciting a somewhat stifled moan.

Tyler pushed just the tip into Abbie's slit, and felt her take a deep breath. "Tell me what you want," he said quietly.

Abbie smiled. "I want you to fuuu--uuuck me!" As she spoke, Tyler slid his cock into her, and the pleasure Abbie felt nearly interrupted her words.

A moment after Tyler pushed into Abbie's pussy, Dominic did the same to Michelle.


"Oh, fuck, I needed that!" Michelle exclaimed, pulling Stefan out of her mouth for a moment. Dominic smirked a bit, and pumped harder into Michelle's pussy. He grabbed at her breasts fucking her, slapping her tit, and each slap yielding a small whimper from Michelle.

"Mmm, you like that?" asked Dominic quietly.

Michelle nodded. "I like that."

Stefan turned, and offered his dick to Abbie, which she grabbed and pumped with her hand. Tyler pounded her missionary style, and her body bounced up and down from the impact. She opened her mouth, and sucked on Stefan a bit, then let go and looked back at Tyler.

"You want more?" he said.

Abbie nodded.

"You want it harder?" he said.

Abbie nodded again. "I want it harder."

Tyler slowed his pace, and lifted Abbie's legs up onto his shoulders. He slammed more forcefully into Abbie's pussy, his hips smacking into her ass and thighs with each thrust.

"Harder," Abbie moaned.

Tyler reared back and hammered into her pussy again.

"Harder!" Abbie called out.

Tyler laughed. Stefan walked around the couch and hit Tyler on the arm. Tyler nodded, and with one more slam against Abbie, he pulled back out, and stepped aside.


"Oh fuck," said Abbie.

"That's right, oh fuck. You still want harder?"

"Yes ..." she said slowly.

Stefan crawled up onto the sofa, holding Abbie's leg in the air, her foot dangling helplessly. He slapped his dick against her leg.

"Do you think you can take me?" he said.

"Yes," Abbie said, nodding, and breathing heavily.

Stefan rubbed his cock along Abbie's pussy. He teased her asshole with his finger, but then pressed the head of his dick against her pussy. She was warm and still wet from fucking Tyler. He pushed into her, and was surprised at how smoothly he slid inside.

"Oh wow," moaned Abbie.

Stefan chuckled. "You still want it?"

"Yes, yes, yes, I do," she mumbled. "Please."

Stefan took a breath, and eased further inside Abbie's pussy.

"Oh my god, it's so fucking big," Abbie cried.

"Don't you want all of it? Don't you want to take my whole fucking cock inside you?"

Abbie nodded vigorously. "Just do it, just fuck me."

Stefan held Abbie's ankles, pulling her legs high into the air, and with one strong thrust, pushed himself into her.

Abbie gasped a sharp breath. "Oh, fuck," she whispered. Stefan held there, then slid back a little, before settling into a steady rhythm of small thrusts. "Fuck, yes, holy fucking fuck." Abbie didn't usually swear this much, but she also didn't usually have something as massive as Stefan's dick inside her. The combination of pressure and pleasure was so intense, and Abbie felt electrified.


Tyler had moved over to where Dominic was fucking Michelle. "Hard to believe I was just pouring you drinks a few hours ago. Who knew?"

Michelle looked up and smiled. "I kinda knew." She laughed, and Tyler smiled. "Okay, Mr. Bartender. Time to show me what I didn't get upstairs."

Dominic gave Michelle four quick and sharp spanks on her right breast before he pulled his dick out of her pussy to make space for Tyler.

"Leaving your mark?" Tyler asked.

Dominic just smiled. He moved around to the position between the two couches, and Michelle happily grabbed his cock and pulled it into her mouth.

"Tastes like me. I like it," she said. Then, as Tyler drove his dick straight into her waiting pussy, "oh wow, you're just like, right in there."

Tyler smirked and built up speed as he fucked Michelle. He gently rubbed her breasts, especially the red spot Dominic had left behind, but he was mostly focused on ramming his dick into her and feeling the warmth of her pussy on him. Michelle casually sucked and jerked Dominic's dick for a bit, though he turned toward Abbie at one point, and steered his cock in the direction of her mouth.

Abbie's eyes were closed, and she was breathing evenly but deeply as Stefan plowed into her. Dominic lightly touched Abbie's face, and she looked up and back at him.

"You think you can do a little more?" he asked. Abbie nodded, opened her lips, and put her tongue out. Dominic pressed his dick to her tongue, and Abbie did the rest, taking him into her mouth, and also reached a hand up behind her, touching Dominic's chest and abdomen.

Abbie looked up at Dominic with a grin. "Is that enough 'more'? Or did you want to fuck me too?"

"Did I want to fuck you?" Dominic asked, a bit startled by the bluntness of the question.

"Yes," Abbie answered. "You do want to fuck me." She giggled and flicked her head forward as if to indicate that Dominic should move to the foot of the couch.

Stefan slowly slid his cock in and out of Abbie's pussy a few more times before reluctantly pulling out completely. He bent forward and gently licked Abbie's labia. His tongue was as wide as his cock, but softer.

"Oh god, that feels amazing!" said Abbie, her head rolling with ecstasy. As Stefan worked his tongue on Abbie's pussy, it was as if he was providing soothing relief from the damage his massive cock had done. He continued licking, his tongue working along her slit, and lifted her legs up further to lick her asshole. He poked the tip of his tongue at her ass. Abbie first tightened her muscles, but then relaxed and leaned back into him. Stefan gave one more tender kiss to Abbie's sensitive areas, and then lowered her legs, stood up, and stepped aside.

"I know I ain't no Stefan, girl," said Dominic.

"You know," sassed Abbie with a smirk, "you'll probably enjoy fucking me more if you think about me instead of Stefan."

Michelle, overhearing, cackled. Tyler fell forward onto Michelle's back, also laughing a bit.

"In fact," Abbie continued, "all of you would be better off thinking about me. I'm not trying to be the center of attention, but I'm pretty drunk, I'm pretty hot, and I've fucked all of you, so ..." She trailed off, not finishing the thought. She took a deep breath, and at the peak of it, felt Dominic behind her.

"Not all of us," said Dominic quietly. He pushed forward, penetrating Abbie for the first time.

Abbie smiled. "Okay, now it's all of you."

What's next?

More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)