Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 15 by GoodBoy GoodBoy

How do you want them to make it up to you?

one-on-one time with Amy

You lock eyes with the wild redhead sitting in your lap. “Untie me, then everyone get out for the night except Amy.”

Amy smiles back at you, then speaks to the other girls without breaking eye contact with you. “You heard him, ladies.”

You see movement out of the corner of your eyes and feel the handcuffs fall away from your wrists. Then the girls move towards the door.

“But I shouldn’t have to leave,” says Ellen, “I’m the one who invited him! And it’s my room!”

“Don’t worry, honey,” says Zelda, the busty punk chick, “you can stay with me tonight.”

“But-“ replies Ellen.

The door closes.

You grab Amy and pull her into an intense kiss. With one hand on the back of her head and the other under her ass, you stand up. She wraps her legs around your waist and giggles through her lips and yours. You carry her to the bed and dump her on it as she bursts into playful laughter.

“You up for a night of Amy love, stud?”

“Shut up!” You unzip her black leather pants as she pulls off her yellow tank top. As soon as she’s naked you climb on top of her and drive your cock into her flaming hot pussy.

“Unh!” cries Amy. She wraps her arms around your neck and squirms, rubbing her large breasts against your chest. “**** to work off that pent up energy, eh?”

You grit your teeth. “I said shut up!”

Amy laughs and drives her hips up into yours. You blow your wad almost immediately, but you’re still hard. You pull out a little and suck on her left breast.

The gorgeous redhead strokes your hair. “So, you feel better now? With that much pent up energy, I’m surprised you didn’t want all four girls.”

“Well,” you say, “I thought we should get our relationship started on a more exclusive note.”

“Relationship?” she says incredulously. “We must have broken your brain. Like I told you, I mainly eat girl soup. I only occasionally mix cock into my diet.”

“Liar. I think you were serious earlier. Back when you suggested that you be my girlfriend.” You suck hard on her nipple and squeeze both breasts with your hands.

Amy coos as the sensations overwhelm her. “So… so you think you’re gonna be the guy to make me change my wicked ways?”

You push your cock all the way back into her, causing her to moan. “Yeah, I think I might be that guy.” You buck your hips into her slowly. She almost speaks, but a kiss silences her willingly. Both your hands stay on her big tits as you pick up speed.

She breaks the kiss and says, “But what about Ellen?”

“What about her?”

“Oh… I don’t know,” Amy closes her eyes tight as you twist your hips to make your cock hit different spots inside her. “Uuuhhh. I mean, haven’t you been lusting after your little blonde friend ever since your cock learned to sit up?”

“Amy, right now I can’t even remember Ellen’s face,” you say truthfully. She smiles and you increase your pace. Your hips move like an overcharged engine, stroking faster than human hips probably should.

Amy arches her back and tenses up. Feeling her orgasm underneath you sets you off again and you cum inside her. The jism pours out the bottom of her pussy onto the bed.

“Hmm” says the beautiful redhead as she comes down, “I don’t know. But hey, you’ve got all night with just me. What are you gonna do to convince me?”

Any ideas?

More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)