Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 209 by Samus1001 Samus1001

What's next?

Zack’s Girls

“Are you sure you want to watch this bud?” Caleb asked.

Zack clapped his hands together and shouted, “Hell yeah man! The girls have been looking forward to this, and I wouldn’t miss it for the world.”

They had made their way to one of the spare bedrooms in the family wing. Zack was seated in a lounger almost bouncing with excitement. Megan, Alice, and Christie were nervously waiting for Caleb to begin.

But Caleb hesitated. It was one thing to stretch and breed Zack’s mom. Donna had been one of the go to girls in his masturbation catalog since he got his first boner. But Caleb had never seen these girls that way, and they were his best friend's women. He really didn’t want to fuck this up for him.

So he settled on some ground rules. “First, no kissing me on the lips. Second, this is the only time I will ever stretch any of you. Third, if I feel you trying to get pregnant, I’m stopping and we are done. And fourth, if you ever break up with Zack, I don’t know you. I will not even acknowledge your existence. If you can’t agree to that, then we won’t even begin.”

The three of them looked at each other and then Megan said, “What about Christie? She isn’t his girlfriend, she's sorta like a friend with benefits.”

“That’s between you guys and Zack. As far as I’m concerned, she’s one of you. Unless Zack tells me differently, she stays that way. Oh, and one last thing. When we are done, and you take your keepsake photos with my cock, you have to post them online. I want Kesha to see what she will never get.”

Once again the girls exchanged a look. Turning back to him, Alice said, “Ok, so how do we do this? Are we taking turns, or do you want all three of us together?”

Caleb tried to keep a poker face as he said, “I don’t like the idea of having all three of you at the same time. That’s something you should only do with Zack. That being said, I’ll start with you Megan. Get naked and on your knees. You’re going to slob my knob till it’s wet enough to get in you.”

Without fanfare Megan was naked in seconds and on her knees. Megan had cute perky and round medium sized tits and a heart shaped ass. If he didn’t know better, he would think her boobs were fake, but it was simply her youth and good health that made her tits looks so good. She gathered her long hair and twirled it into a bun, wanting everyone to have a clear view without her hair in the way. She did not waste a second pulling Caleb’s swim trunks down to his ankles.

Megan bit her bottom lip and squeaked through her nose as his long thick dick bobbed before her. Behind her on the bed, Alice gasped and Christie felt her mouth instantly water.

Caleb’s cock grew and hardened before her eyes. Her bottom lip slipped out from between her teeth and her eyes grew wide as his dick grew longer and thicker than his flaccid size. “Holy fuck, I forgot how big it gets.”

Caleb laughed, remembering that Megan had gotten a close look when she aided one of their classmates in Mrs. Garcia's class. He smiled down at her and said “What are you waiting for? It ain’t gonna suck itself.”

Megan gripped it in one hand, then both. There was still a significant amount of cock uncovered. A few inches from her face a dab of precum rose from his pisshole, glistening hypnotically in the light. The scent of his cock filled her nostrils, musky, primal, and manly with his arousal. It was the most beautiful cock she had ever seen. The urge to lean forward and kiss his cockhead overpowered her.

As soon as her lips touched, her tongue darted out to taste him. Her eyes flew wide, her pussy clenching as she tasted a Stretcher King's cock directly for the very first time. She'd only ever had a taste of his cum, licked off their classmate with Alice. But Caleb had already fucked several women since his shower that morning. Multiple women's pussy juices mixed with his cum had dried on him, with only tongues to clean him. His balls smelled strongest of the mixture, and drove Megan wild with it's pungent ambrosial wonder.

Caleb was still in a bad mood from his confrontation with the government liaison. He wanted to hate fuck someone, but Megan didn’t deserve that. He had actually been looking for Melissa when Zack and his girls found him first. Melissa he could hate fuck and she would enjoy the hell out of it. He had no idea what Megan liked.

She started sucking his cockhead while he wool gathered so he warned them, “Hey, if I get too rough let me know. Some of my girls are in to pain, and I don’t want to make this a bad experience for any of you.”

Alice offered, “I like my hair pulled when I cum and Christie loves getting spanked when getting it doggy style. Megan is pretty vanilla, but when she cums, bite her nipples. It sets her off really good.”

Caleb grinned, “Good to know,” as Megan switched from sucking and licking the tip of his cock to bobbing her head two or three inches. She began sucking, slobbering, and moaning wetly around him, her hands making a twisting motion as she jacked him. The blowjob felt great, though not nearly as good as Sonia, June, or Kathy could do. But Megan was certainly skilled enough to compete with any of his other girls.

Megan glanced to the side, looking to Zack, hoping for approval. The smile on his face reassured her that he was okay with Megan sucking Caleb off. While she wanted Caleb to stretch her, and she certainly would like to have one of his kids one day, she'd fallen in love with Zack, every bit as much as Alice had. As a team, she and Alice would love him forever, never knowing that Caleb and his magic watch compelled them to.

Caleb could tell that Megan was watching Zack. He looked from one to the other, happy with his decision to create a normality for his buddy. Megan's blowjob felt great, letting him know his best bud was getting a taste of what Caleb experienced several times a day. But he wasn’t here to feed them his cum, not until he fucked them anyway.

“Ok Megan, that’s good enough. Get on the bed in the doggie position. Alice and Christie, take your bikinis off so we don’t have to pause later.”

Megan's lips popped free with a wet smack, a line of drool bridging the gap between her mouth and his dick. Suddenly it snapped and Megan blinked before she began to rise, as if coming out of a restful sleep.

“What about me? You mind if I, you know,” Zack made a jerking off motion with his hand.

Caleb followed behind Megan's ass as she got on the bed, “Hey man, you do you. Literally.”

Megan was in the classic head down ass up position. Being a former cheerleader, she was limber and able to create an excellent dip in her back, with her head and upper body laying on the bed. Caleb lined up behind her and noticed her flower was spread and dripping. She was ready for a good hard drilling.

He felt like being a bit of an ass. Megan may not have been one of the cheerleaders to instigate the bullying at school, but she did go along with it when it happened. He had no intention of hurting her, but that didn't mean he couldn't have some fun.

He poked the tip of his dick repeatedly around her tight little hole, pretending he couldn’t find it. “Oh wait, that’s not it. That’s not it again. Wait that’s your clit.”

“Damn it Caleb! Stop playing around and get your cock in me!” Megan begged.

Caleb fake complained, “I can’t freaking find the hole. It’s too tiny. Maybe if your kitty meowed for me, I could. Meow for me kitty.”

Megan nervously let out a tentative, “Meow.”

Caleb tried not to laugh as he pressed the tip of his cock against her opening. She pushed her ass back to try and **** him inside but he grabbed her ass and moved his hips back to prevent it. “I couldn’t hear you kitty. Meow a little louder so I can find the hole.”

Megan frustratingly called out, “MEOW! Holy fuck!” As Caleb popped his fat cockhead past her lips and slid the first several inches into her.

He patted her ass and said, “Good kitty.”

But when he went to push more inside her, she cried out, “Wait! Caleb please wait! God damn you’re thick. Give my poor pussy a second to adjust. I’ve never been stretched before. Go slow, please. Some girls take a while to stretch, and your cock is fucking huge.”

Caleb felt like king of the world as Megan moaned and whimpered while he continued feeding her cunt his cock. Megan was taking longer to stretch than anyone else he had been with, and he decided he loved it. He knew what his next normality would be. This feeling was heaven.

After a couple minutes, he was finally balls deep inside her. He couldn’t see it, but she had a significant belly bulge. Zack’s hand flew up and down his own cock as he watched Megan cum when Caleb’s balls touched her clit.

“Oh fuck! So fucking good. Thank you Caleb. You feel wonderful inside me. Now fuck me please. Fuck this little kitty and make her meow.”

Caleb grabbed her hair and twisted her head to look over at Zack. He began giving her hard deep thrusts saying, “Don’t thank me. Thank him. He is the reason you’re getting stretched. He is the reason you are cumming on my cock. He is the one you should be grateful to. Now little kitty, thank your master.”

“Uh fuck. Thank uh you uh Zack. His uh cock feels uh so fucking good uh in me. I love uh love you uh Zack. My uh Master. Uh uh fuuh fuck Fuck!”

Megan fell forward on the bed as she came again, staring into Zack’s eyes. Caleb slid to the side and pushed Alice over onto her back. He smiled down at her and said, “Your turn.”

Alice pulled her fingers out of her snatch and spread her legs wide. She held her pussy lips open and purred, “Give it to me, big daddy.”

Caleb grinned as he advanced on her, licking his lips as he gazed at her pretty pussy. She had tiny pussy lips, and an equally small opening. Her clit sat upon it's throne, hood pulled back, swollen and throbbing. He couldn't wait to feel her tight cunt on his dick.

Caleb barely started getting his dickhead past Alice's pussy lips when Gabbie walked in and said, “There you are Caleb. Chloe is looking fooOOHH MY GOD! ZACK! Put your fucking cock away, you fucking degenerate! Is that your fucking cum on the carpet?!”

After Gabbie’s screaming fit, and they all left the room, Megan looked over at Alice. They were both wondering two things. Would Caleb finish what he started some other time, and how did he know Megan was a hucat? Megan had only ever told Alice. When they found out that Kesha got Heather thrown off the team for being one, Megan and Alice left the team in a silent show of support for one of Megan’s kind. Megan hadn’t yet gotten up the courage to tell Zack yet. She feared he would reject her.


Writing takes energy and coffee provides energy. If you like the story please consider buying me a cup of coffee at https://ko-fi.com/samus1001

What's next?

More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)