You decompress a little

The four of you stand there for a moment, until you suddenly realize that you all are naked, and go in search of your clothes. The others soon do the same, and you all get dressed. Tom goes to the refrigerator and helps himself to a beer.

"Do you guys want one?" he calls out.

You all respond in the affirmative, and Tom brings them over as you all sit down. You sit there drinking quietly for what felt like a lifetime, but was probably just a minute or two.

"Well, that was something," comments James, breaking the silence.

"Yeah," says Dale, "it seems there's always gonna be a catch, but I guess this one wasn't as bad as the first time."

"I guess," you say. "It was weird having Lucy beg us to fuck her, felt kind of backwards.{if SlutScore > 20} Seems I can't say no to her.{else} Not that I can complain, I guess; nice to be needed.{endif}"

"It was...challenging," continues James, "before, I was able to get into the mindset of just doing what she said, but without that crutch I wasn't very keen on it."

"I mean...do we want out of this?" asks Tom. "I've just been going along with it because I remembered what a crush I used to have on Lucy, and the momentum has carried me here."

There's a moment of silence as it sinks in, and for the first time you realize that you're not the only one who has thought about it.

"I'm...torn," says Dale, "I mean, it's Lucy. I never thought I'd get a chance with her, or with anyone like her. I'm not the best looking guy, and so how else world I get a chance with someone so hot? Pay for it? Is that really better? It's not like I could afford it anyway."

"You wouldn't have to suck dick for it," says Tom.

"I guess it's true," replies Dale, "that I've had an easier time of it than you. It's been more confusing than actively unpleasant."

"Tonight wasn't so bad, though," says James. "It wasn't as weird as I imagined it would be. Being ridden by Lucy was pretty good."

You all think for a moment, until the tense moment is interrupted by Lucy's return, wearing just a bra and thong.

"Heh, forgot my dressing gown," she says, giving a giggle as she conspicuously bends over in front of you all to pick up her gown from the ground, then wraps it around her and sits down again on the couch next to you.

"That was really amazing," Lucy continues, "thank you so much for tonight. It was, without exaggeration, the best sex I've ever had. You should be so proud of yourselves."

She wraps her arms around you and gives you a kiss, then does the same to Dale, on the other side, then gets up and continues with James and Tom, before walking to the refrigerator, grabbing her own beer, and leaning on the back of James's armchair.

"So how was it for you?" she asks. "You can be honest, I genuinely want to know."

After a moment, Dale speaks up.

"It was intense. I don't really know what to think. I didn't really like the idea of touching a cock, but once I got going, I enjoyed it a lot in the moment, there was so much sensation. But then as soon as I came, the fun drained away once I remembered that I came mostly from the feeling of rubbing myself on someone's cock."

"I appreciate that," Lucy responds. "Maybe you'd have a better finish if you came another way. Fuck me together for a bit and then when you're ready, you can pull out and blow in my mouth instead. A bit more awkward for the guy on the bottom, and no amazing three-way simultaneous orgasms, but I would love to find a way to make everyone happy to do this."

"I think you were a bit uncomfortable, though, without my being a little bit more pushy. It's my fault, maybe I was trying to push your boundaries a little bit too quickly. But you can think about it a little. I don't mind playing the dominatrix given how well you've obeyed so far," she continues with a wink.

"But anyway, I've got work tomorrow, so maybe we should wrap up," Lucy says. You nod, thankful that you didn't finish your beer and so can still drive home. At the door, Lucy gives each of you another big hug, and whispers in your ear, "thank you so much, really, I don't have the words for how much I appreciate everything you've done".

Your heart melts a little, and you know that you'll be back.