Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 3 by The Other Guy The Other Guy

Are you ready to talk to Mindy or do you want another puff?

You can't find her

Wondering through the house you can't find Mindy, she is just nowhere to be found. You check every room on the bottom floor and everyone you ask is unable to help you. After a while you end up crashing on a couch when Sarah approaches you.

"H-hey James." She says as she sits down next to you.

"Hey Sarah." You say smiling at her. She's been like a little sister to you for years, the school titular basic nerd. Short pale and boyish always wearing bagging clothes.

"Still looking for Mindy?" She asked toying with a cup in her hand. This was the first party you'd even seen her attend and didn't think she'd ever drink.

"Yeah. Why have you seen her?" You ask hopefully.

"I think she's upstairs."

"Ok cool thanks." You say standing up only to be stopped.

"N-no wait, I-I'll help you look." She hurries to your side and you head up stairs.

"If can check those doors I'll check over here." You say waving her down one corridor.

"O-oh I thought we'd check together, maybe look in one of the bedroom." She said.

"Be faster if we both look." You say with a shrug.

"Oh right sure." She looked crestfallen, she's probably not used to being the one with the bad ideas so feels bad about it.

You pat her head just like you'd done a thousand times. "Thanks for the help Sarah." You say with a smile. She smiles as shyly as ever at you and you part ways.

The first door you open is a cupboard as is the next. The third one opens to the sight of three people fucking. You freeze in the doorway as a worry that the girl is Mindy before you recognise her as one of Mindy's friends. "Oh hey James. You found Mindy?" Charlie asks happily while Mindy's friends swallows his cock.

"N-not yet." You say embarrassed. Maybe you should have smoked some more because the weed confidence is wearing off.

"Well if you wanna join no worries." There is a grunt from the women Charlie is current suffocating. "Please you've been gangbanged by most of the team eight times." He says ruffling her hair. She rolls her eyes and looks at you before nodding.

"Well I'm not taking her ass." Ben grunted as he kept pounding her pussy.

"N-no thanks I'll keep looking." You close the door on the and take a shaky step. Your body had decided blood was better elsewhere than your legs so it takes a second before you are steady.

You move to the next few door but don't find anything. You turn and head back for the stairs when you hear a muffle voice.

"Drink this and be direct." You think that is Mindy's voice and you head towards it's source.

"But what if he turns me down?" That is Sarah's voice.

"If he does, send him to my room, I'll take care of him." Mindy says as she opens the door into you revealing the bathroom. "Oh speak of the devil. Where you spying?" Mindy asked as she looked you up and down as Sarah's face goes bright red.

"N-no Mindy!" You stammer. "I-I was just looking for you."

"Well, I'm looking for a drink. Why don't you ask Sarah what we were talking about." She walks past you then spanks your ass, far harder than you would ever expect. "Hmm, you know now you mention it." She says to Sarah over your shoulder. "Do you think women should be in charge?"

"Huh?" You ask not getting her question.

"Oh never mind." She looks at Sarah. "You know where to send him." She leaves with a wink at Sarah.

"What was that about?" You ask looking at Sarah.

"Can you come in?"

"Ah," You look at Sarah as she walks downstairs. Maybe Sarah is trying to wingman you and has some tips, you know where Sarah will be anyway. "Sure." You walk into the room and Sarah walks up to you pressing her hands against your chest. "Ah, you ok?"

"Do you like me?"

"Yeah of course I like you?"

"N-no, I mean." She steps back and grabs the cup that was resting on the bench and drinks it all. Coughing when she was done. "Do you like, like me?"

"What? I- Sarah you're like a little sister to me." You are really confused about what is going on right now.

"I'm not your sister." She pouts then puts the empty cup down and looks at you. "If I'm your sister than you won't get hard." She declares.

"Hu-" you don't even finish your voiced confusion as Sarah pulls off her top exposing her flat pale, lightly freckled chest. You have no idea how you are supposed to react to this.

"Ha, see, if I was your sister you wouldn't be turn on!" She victoriously shouts.

"I'm not." You start but she steps forwards and grabs your cock through your pants.

"Nah uh, I can feel it, you're ..." she looks down at her hand suddenly aware of where it was. You are also frozen as she squeezes softly. "hard." she finishes looking up at you. She strokes you through your pants and your cock bounces at the touch. "Y-you're really hard." She looks down at your pants and bites her lip. "I-I can take care of that for you." She kneels down in front of you and pulls at your pants.

You are silence, unable to think straight as all that is happening hits you. "Ok." Is all you can manage.

She pulls down your pants and underwear, your cock bouncing out and smacking her in the nose. "Y-you're really big." She mumbles as her hand returns to your length. "And hot." She warps her hand around you. "Is this too tight?" She asks shy.

"N-no that's perfect." You mumble as the feeling of her small hand on your cock makes you shiver. "Y-you're perfect." You say as the sight of her nerdy face stares up at you, the tip of your dick almost touching her lips. "C-can you..." You mime jerking off and she nods slows stroking you from base to tip. "Mmm, that- that feels nice." You moan as her hand squeezes your length.

"It's so big." She mumbles then slowly down making you look at her. "C-can I," she sticks out her tongue and you nod. Shyly she leans forwards and licks you tip then frowns. "It's really salty." She says then says. "B-but I like it." She licks again getting a bead of pre on her tongue. "I-I like you James."

"Can you suck it?" You ask as you put a hand on her head, patting her hair like you always do. She smiles at you and opens her mouth taking your tip inside and sucking lightly. "Teeth." You say as you feel them graze you.

"Sorry I didn't mean to." She says pulling you out of her mouth. You moan and pull her back into place pushing into her mouth with a happy moan. You did not think this is how the night was going to go but who are you to complain.

"You're mouth is really nice." You've never gotten a blowjob before but this feels really nice. It's warm and wet and her tongue rubs you. "Can you go a little deeper?" You ask.

She nods and pushes her head forwards a little more before coughing and pulling back. "So-sorry."

"No it's fine, your," you pull head back onto your tip and just let her suckle at your crown as her tongue runs up and down your slit, "your mouth is fantastic." You moan feeling your balls tightening.

She pulls off you cock and gently strokes you. "Are you gonna cum. The books say the tensing means you're gonna cum?" She looks up at you with bright happy eyes and you nod at her. "C-can you do it in my mouth? I wanna taste you- it, I wanna taste it." She blushes and looks down to avoid eye contact. You pull her head back onto your tip and guide her bobbing. It might just be your crown between her lips but it feels better than anything you've ever felt.

Before you cum you tap her head and she nods getting ready. You blow into her mouth and her cheeks puff out. She coughs a bit but holds herself on you. When you finish she gags for a moment before opening her mouth to show the white filling you just gave her. She swirls it around with her tongue then closes her eyes and swallows with difficultly. When she is done she opens her mouth to show there is none left. "Why'd you do that?" You ask stroking her hair affectionately.

"That's what they do in porn. Isn't that what I'm supposed to do?" She asks nervously. "Was it not good?"

"It was fantastic." You say kneeling down and kissing her. There is a salty aftertaste and you only then realise you are tasting your own cum.


You and Sarah head down to the party being very huggy. Claiming a couch the two of you cuddle while the party winds down. Eventually Charlie and Ben come down and see the tow of you cuddling. Charlie gives you a thumbs up and Ben claps as the plonk down on some free seats. The girl they were fucking comes down a bit later and sits on Charlie's lap. Adam shows up form outside looking high than a kite and collapses on the floor giving everyone an 'I'm good' sign. Mindy shows up at some point and when you notice her she gives you a kinda creepy look. She always had that look but you only just noticed it. She checks on Adam before pulling him up and taking him upstairs."So how was your first time?" Charlie asks as the sun starts to rise. You sputter and look at Sarah who blushes. "Smoking I mean." He adds with a smirk.

"Oh, it ah," you look at Sarah and see her smile back at you. "Pretty fantastic."


What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)