Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 20 by MisterMan1965 MisterMan1965

What do you do?

You’ve waited long enough. You want to lose your virginity to your beautiful, sexy sister

You stretch out on the bed next to Abbie, facing her. Your hard cock presses against her thigh. Your hand strokes up and down her naked body, enjoying the feeling of her warm, soft, slightly sweaty skin. You smile at her and chuckle. “All my life, I never thought I’d ever be with a girl who could even compare to my sister. You’re so beautiful and loving, and… wonderful. I can’t believe this is actually happening.”

She rolls onto her side to face you. Her forehead presses to yours. She reaches between your bodies and her fingers wrap around your hard shaft. It flexes in response to her touch. “It better be happening. I need you in me so bad” she groans. Her thumb slides lightly over the slit of your cock, and smears the precum that is leaking from it around the head. Then she starts to stroke slowly up and down. “Put it in me, Davey. I want to feel you filling me up. Want to feel you shoot your cum deep inside me.”

You nod. “Damn, I want to. Right now, Abbie.”

You can’t keep your hips rocking, making instinctive, needy thrusts into your sister’s softly stroking hand. Your hands are shaky as you guide her to lay back on the mattress. You move on top of her as she spreads her thighs wide for you. Your cock bumps against the smooth skin of her inner thigh, then prods at her glistening, slick folds. You make little fumbling thrusts, trying to find her entrance.

Abbie smiles up at you. “Let me help,” she says, as she shifts under you, and her hand moves to your cock again. She positions the head, guiding you inside her. You moan in pleasure as you shift your weight forward, sinking your cock slowly into your sister’s pussy. The warm, wet tightness enveloping your shaft is the most amazing thing you ever felt. You’re propped up on your arms, looking down into Abbie’s face, her head is lolled back and her mouth is wide open in a long, throaty groan of ecstasy as you press in, all the way to the root of your shaft.

You hold there for a moment, just enjoying the feeling of being inside your sister. Abbie looks up into your eyes, hers are filling with tears, but she’s smiling wide. Her hands grip your shoulders tightly. “I love you so much, Davey. I only want to make you happy, make you feel good. Tell me you feel good.”

Please log in to view the image

You grin, “I don’t think I could ever feel any better, Abbie.” You murmur. You lower your head down to kiss her lips softly as your hips start to pump slowly, easing your straining, throbbing cock in and out of her. You can feel her pussy walls clenching on your shaft, and she is panting out cute little high-pitched gasps in time with your thrusts, “ah… ah… ah… ah… ah… “

After a short time, her fingers clench harder on your shoulders. “Da… Da… Daaaaaave…” she cries out as her body spasms under you, and her pussy clenches hard on your cock. You stop thrusting as she cums, then start again, faster as her body relaxes. Her eyes go wide and she almost shouts “Ohhh! Oh Fuuuuuck!” Her hands leave your shoulders and grip your head, pulling you down to her for a hard, hungry kiss, as her cunt constricts your cock again and her warm juices gush over your shaft and your balls.

Abbie wraps her lean, toned legs around your waist. Her heels dig into the small of your back, pulling you harder into her. She groans out “Mooooore…” Then her words come out as guttural grunts, “Don’t. stop. please. harder. oh gaaahhhhd…” Her body jerks and tenses and another orgasm makes her pussy spasm and clench on your cock.

You’re pumping your hips hard now. Your thrusts are rapid, urgent. Sweat makes your skin slick against your Abbie’s. You can’t hold out any longer. You drive in as hard as you can and your body freezes there, as your cock pulses and pumps your load deep inside your sister’s pussy. Her head drives back into the pillow and her body shudders as she cums with you, her pussy soaking your crotch and the sheets under her.

You lay there on top of her, propped on your elbows, breathing hard, looking into her eyes.

Her head shakes back and forth slowly. “I… I never came so fast so many times in a row, or so hard with anyone. Guys who were confident, rough, and demanding, with all the technique and experience in the world, everything I thought I wanted. None of them could do what you just did. I love you so much, I feel like I could explode, Dave. You’re perfect. Magical.”

You feel like you can move a little now. You just nod and roll off to sprawl on your back, “Love you too, Abs,” you pant. That word she said, ‘magical,’ tugs at your memory again.

Abbie sits up and grins at you. “And the fact that you’re my brother — Now that I’m past the initial resistance, it makes this even hotter. It’s taboo, forbidden, makes me feel like a dirty little secret," she giggles. Your sister leans over you and starts to lick and kiss down your chest, then your belly. “God… I wasted so much time,” kiss “running around” lick “with other guys,” kiss “hiding how I felt” kiss “about you” looong lick “from myself.” kiss “Until that dream I had about you on Monday night. After that, I couldn’t deny it.” She slurps your spent cock into her mouth, suckling her juices from it.

You think about what you were doing on Monday night. How **** and pathetic you were then, trying to cast a spell to enchant a girl you barely knew into being obsessed with having sex with you and obedient to your commands. When your amazing sister was available to you and you didn't even know it. Then, as Abbie drags her wet tongue slowly over your balls, you get a queasy feeling of realization.

What do you do now?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)