Yes

I'm a little stunned and very disappointed, but if Katy doesn't want to do this we should stop. I stop thrusting and slowly start pulling out, savoring last moments of the short-lived but completely unexpected experience of fucking Katy.

"Ok, now just give me a second,"

She's probably going to fumble in the dark for her clothes and get dressed.

"... and go slow,"

Slow at what? What is she talking about.

"I haven't done this since high school."

Done what? As I'm trying to sort this out, I feel Katy's hand wrap around my still hard and unsatisfied erection.

"And you're much bigger than any of those boys were."

As she says that I feel the head of my cock come into contact with Katy's backside again, but not her pussy. Katy is holding my cock so that the big thick head is lined up with her puckered anus. She's pushing back into me with slow but steady ****. As she does this I feel her rosebud twitch and relax repeatedly as she seems to be trying to overcome the anxiety of trying anal again after such a long time and loosen her sphincter. She does a good job because in no time at all the head of my cock enters her tight hot ass.

"John you're so big, You're going to have to go slow. I'm sorry we have to do it this way, I just can't risk having you cum inside me and get me pregnant." I slide push a little farther in. "OHH...Ungghhh ..John you're going to split me in two. Are you almost all the way inside me yet?"

I look down and in the dim lighting I can just make out what has to be a least half my staff still sticking out of Katy's very fine ass.