Yes, but...

Kevin releases his load into Jenny's ass making her shake and orgasm with the toy inside of her cunt still. The toy somehow got lodged out of her pussy and fell on the floor in between her legs where Kevin could see it. Kevin saw it and picked it up. "You really are kinky bringing an anal plug with you."

Jenny froze and was about to get up and tell him it wasn't an anal plug and it could get lost easier in the ass than vagina but it was too late.

She felt the jock's calloused hand shoved the toy into her already abused ass hole, letting it go further into her puckered hole.

He slapped her ass afterwards, pushing the toy to where it wasn't visible to the outside world, completely inside of her asshole.

He slapped it one more time, out his cock back in his pants and left Jenny in the hallway. She tried standing up a few seconds later and felt the toy go further inside, this time into her back entrance.