Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 5 by scarlettgold00 scarlettgold00

Do Scarlett and David accept her wish?

With (extra) enthusiasm

Your {if **** == 1}daughter{else}bar girl{endif} misses your dick, and my girlfriend craves it now too, why don't you come fuck them? David texted her {if **** == 1}father{else}boss{endif}.

After sending the text, he grabbed Scarlett's phone from inside and texted two guys matched with her on her new Tinder account.

Want to come over? I need someone to reach some places I can't on my own... Only if you're not afraid to share...

After sending the text, he attached an old picture of his girlfriend in her bikini, and hoped it would be enough.

Please log in to view the image

Now he couldn't wait any longer to fuck this slut his girlfriend had brought along. Letting his trunks fall to the ground, he walked over to Vanessa, tore off her top, and awaited her reaction. Eyes staring up at him, she licked her lips and wrapped her hand around his dick. "Before I let you fuck me, I want you to make true on your promise. I want to watch your girlfriend get fucked by another guy." Hearing that, his cock twitched.


Practically naked already, Scarlett took off her thong and strolled over to Tom, who was unashamedly stroking his dick. Grabbing it, she led him inside, and laid down on the bed. "Fuck me, Tom. Fuck me as my boyfriend watches. I need to feel you inside of me." Not waiting for anyone to stop him, he climbed on top of her, and slid into her already wet pussy. Scarlett let out an ecstatic moan, laden with all the tension of feeling a stranger filling her for the first time ever. "Don't stop now Tom. I've wanted this... Oh, ohhh god, you feel so good!"

At the other side of the room, David shot out a spurt of cum, as he watched his girlfriend enter metaphorical heaven. She had really embraced her deepest desire, completely aroused by another, without any reservation at all. "That is HOT!" Vanessa exclaimed, looking at Scarlett and Tom, not even noticing the cum on her tits.

At that moment, her {if **** == 1}father{else}boss{endif} entered the garden. His gaze fell first on David standing over {if **** == 1}his daughter{else}Vanessa{endif}, with cum on her tits, before it shifted to Scarlett getting fucked on the bed. He walked over to Vanessa and Tom, asking him "Are you sure you want this?"

"I'm sure. I didn't cum over {if **** == 1}your daughter's tits{else}Vanessa's tits{endif} because of her handjob. I came because of my girlfriend getting fucked over there. And I believe {if **** == 1}your daughter{else}Vanessa{endif} really wants to watch you fuck her too." Vanessa simply nodded vigorously, still stroking David's half-erect cock.

"Well, I'm not going to ask again. This is going to be amazing!" A sly smile appeared on Vanessa's face, looking up at Tom and her {if **** == 1}father{else}boss{endif}. "Fuck her hard for me, {if **** == 1}dad{else}please{endif}. I can't wait to watch you take her, as Tom here fills me up."


Finally noticing the new guest, Tom pulled out of Scarlett and asked "You are Vanessa's {if **** == 1}dad{else}boss{endif}, right? Why don't you take her face, as I fuck her from behind." Scarlett shook her head. "No, I want to taste my pussy on your cock. And I need to feel her {if **** == 1}dad{else}boss{endif} inside of me."

Both men complied, and David immediately got hard again, urging Vanessa to take his cock into her mouth. His girlfriend was now being tag-teamed by these two men. For years he had fantasized about it, but it was actually happening, and he had one hell of a chick naked in front of him.

Scarlett soon felt both cocks ramming into her, the initial jitters gone from the men.

[WIP]

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)