Who said you get to choose?

“Holy FUCK. Erin, that’s not cool!” Tina yells. “We just met them, stripping is one thing, but fucking him. Seriously. Are you ok?”

“Yeah, I can’t let you do this either, girl. We said we would flirt for drinks. This is already more than we wanted. I’m basically nude and you are somehow more nude. This has gone too far.” Viv adds in.

You ignore them both and look right at Erin. “Are you sure, there’s no going back once we do this.” you ask her, as honestly as you can. You didn't want to ever **** a girl with a WYR, but are still out of your mind on what else could get someone to commit this fast. Are you sure you didn't **** anything she wouldn't actually want to do? Did you **** anything outside of getting her to head back home with you?

“I’m sure Master. I really want this. Please use me.” She seems more sure than anything, definitely more sure than you are.

You turn your attention back to the other two. “Look, I’m as surprised as you two. I mean I was hoping to see and maybe even feel some tits, but this is more than I thought. I can understand if you want to leave, but Erin has made her choice. So, Would You Rather leave now, or continue the game knowing what the rules and expectations for the next round are?”

“Leave.” Tina answered instantly.

Viv wasn’t as quick to answer. After a few seconds, she finally responds. “I guess I’ll leave too. But only because Erin has claimed you and I don’t like sharing.” Viv answered, almost like she lost the battle between the two of them. One you didn’t even realize was going on. Way to pay attention. Again.

“But, Alice, if you let me keep your bathing suit, You can keep my panties to remind Mr. Jimmy later what he missed out on.” Viv adds, trying one last hail mary for the win. You didn't fail to notice her shaking her voluminous ass in your face either.

“Fine, it’s probably easier anyways. Let’s get your dress and call an uber.” Alice says cleaning up your mess. Then looking at you, “Only teasing until I’m back. We don’t have rules yet, but I want to be involved in your first one.” She gives you a kiss on your forehead. “And you,” Alice continues, looking at Erin, “he’s in charge, but you will pay for any mistakes he makes.” Still getting more forceful and stronger each time she talks to Erin. God, she is looking more confident than she has been in years, you can feel her power, even when she isn't talking to you.

A quick wink to you, and Alice walks into the bedroom with to help Viv get dressed while Tina goes hunting for her and Viv's purses.

“Well, guess that means the game is over. Do you want to change or stay like this?” you ask Erin, leaving it open for her to pick her own path without being **** by magical games and whatever else is going on.

“The game isn’t over until you finish your last choice. You have to decide how to use me.." She gulps, and continues, "and then do it." You can sense that she really wants it, but is also afraid of what that means. “But Miss Alice said we have to wait, so can I keep you happy until then?” her eyes look at you longingly.

You pinch her nipple and use it to pull her to you, returning to the kiss from before. “Well, I guess I will pick then. But I don’t like my toys to know what’s going to happen. So stand up and let’s check out the bedroom.”

Complete bluff. You have no idea what you even want, much less what’s going to happen. But she seems to want to feel either powerless or controlled. So you will bluff that to the end of days if it makes her happy.