What does she ask you?

“Yeah, I guess I’m ready. How bad can it be?” I laughed nervously.

“Ok…” Susie paused dramatically. “Which one of my girlfriends do you want to fuck the most?” She laughed and the other three girls now giggled nervously.

Oh shit! What a question. And with all three of her girlfriends sitting right there in front of me mostly naked. Whoever I picked, I would be disappointing the other two. I knew my answer but wasn’t sure how to phrase it so nobody felt hurt.

“Damn it, sis! What kind of a question is that? No matter what I answer, somebody’s going to be unhappy. I think that’s being mean to your friends.”

Susie laughed an evil laugh. “That’s what makes it such a good question. I wanted to put your balls in a bind. So what are you going to do now?”

I looked from one girl to the other, and gave them all a big smile. They all smiled back waiting for my answer. I hit upon an answer that I thought might work.

“Ok…” I started slowly. “The girl I want to fuck the most is…” (Pregnant pause like in TV reality shows.) “You, sis!” The three friends all gasped. Susie gave me a dirty look.

“Oh, no, you’re not getting out of it like that,” she reprimanded me. “I wasn’t one of the choices. I specifically said ‘which one of my friends.’ Quit stalling and answer the question, David.”

God, this was going to be hard. I looked at Carly. She was totally naked and I really loved her hot body. It seemed like all the proportions were just perfect. Beth was totally cute too although a little on the skinny side. But that ass! But I already knew it was Amy that I really had the hots for. She was not too thick and not too thin, had beautiful C-cup tits that were perfectly shaped and an ass that was to die for. I took a deep breath and made the plunge.

“Ok, let me just say first of all that I think all three of you are beautiful and I would happily fuck any or all of you.” I never could have imagined talking to girls like this. Me totally nude telling three mostly naked girls I would love to fuck them. But actually that was the truth. I wanted them all and my sister too.

“But… I have to go with Amy, sorry.”

“You’re sorry you want to fuck me?” Amy looked at me with her head tilted. “That’s supposed to make me feel special?”

“No, no, I really want to fuck you,” I protested. “I’m just sorry if Beth or Carly are disappointed I didn’t pick them.

“Don’t worry about it, David,” Beth joined in. “If you don’t want to fuck us, maybe we’ll just fuck you instead,” she laughed. And of course all the other girls giggled.

“Damn it! It’s not that I don’t want to fuck the shit out of all of you,” I defended myself. “Susie just put me in a really bad position here. Thanks a lot, sis!” I stuck my tongue out at her.

“I think it’s funny,” Susie laughed. “I love getting you all flabbergasted. But you need to ask Carly a question now. And remember, try to make it as embarrassing as you can.”