Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 8 by Bran_Hopewell Bran_Hopewell

How do the girls respond?

What do you mean?

"What are you....uh....talking about?" Ellen asked, trying to play things cool with your fist still in her pussy, burried 4 inches past your wrist. You start spinning your fist in her and she starts shuddering and shaking uncontrollably as her pussy squirts noisily all over your hand. Ellen keeps her orgasm quiet enough not to draw attention from the rest of the hall, but the effect is not lost on her sister or on Jenn.

"Mmm, I'll have what she's having..." Jenn purred. You could only let the girl have it and started pounding your fist inside her as well, her juices coating your arm with her sticky honey on every stroke.

Mandy sat down next to her sister and looked down, seeing your arm impaling her sister.

"Holy fuck, sis!" she said and her hand went to stroking your arm as you pounded and stretched her sister's shaved snatch. Her thighs parted and her skirt rode all the way up, expoosing her shaved snatch, already dripping with juice. "I don't know what to believe less. The fact that you're squirting all over some guy's fist, the fact that you're in public, or the fact that you fed me grapes covered in your cunt juice!" she hissed quietly.

"Oh fuh...uck!" Ellen moaned. Her sister's hand slid up your arm and she started fingering Ellen's clit and she exlpoded again. Your eyes slid over to the new shaved snatch and saw that there was no tan lines, and she had a tattoo around it. With the rouse over, you pulled your fist out of Ellen with a noisy, wet slurch and moved over to see the new pussy.

"Eat Me, Drink Me," was tattooed in old English at the top of her slit, and as you get closer, you could see a little double pearl tipped stud at her clit, both of the tiny balls rubbing the tiny nub, and she was already glistening with juice.

"You don't seem to mind eating them now," Jenn said. Mandy moaned and giggled with your fist still spinning in Ellen.

"Who could blame me? Some of these are a little different....yours?"

Jenn giggled in responce. "Ever eaten a redhead, honey?"

"Oh fuck yes! I love gingers....they taste sooooo good," Mandy said, pulling her fingers from her sister's snatch. She moaned and you heard sucking noises. "Sister here isn't too bad either."

Ellen's whole body started convulsing, her pussy trying to crush your fist inside her and you figure it's time to give the poor girl a break. her towel is soaked, your shirt is soaked, the floor has a puddle on it, and she's gotta be damn near dehydrated. You slowly pull your arm out of her, watching her pussy clench around nothing and contract back down after you pull out.

"Oh my god," you hear Ellen moaning, repeating it and trying to catch her breath.

Mandy shifts in her seat and looks under the table, spreading her leg over the laps of the other two girls.

"So what the fuck are you waiting for, Scott? An engraved invitation!?"

"Maybe we should get all three of you out of here," you say and get back out from under the table, your forearms glistening, a cum soaked piece of bread in hand. You drop the bread on the table, and almost laugh as it lands with a heavy splat. Mandy and Jenn's hands both dart out for the honey coated treat and they both hit it at the same time.

"Paper Rock Scissors," Ellen said dreamily. "Winner gets the bread, loser chooses location."

Best two out of three, who wins?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)